Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 50 · 15 December 1905
8printed page
scan 8 of 20

Page 8 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 50

The address was delivered by Dr. Natan Birnbaum. In a brilliant speech of an hour and a half, which rose far above the level of meeting speeches and which, by its logical construction, its wealth of thought and perfection of form, must be called a masterly plea for the national movement of the Austrian Jews, the speaker set out the grounds of the Jewish national demand. For technical reasons we must unfortunately forgo reproducing the speech to-day even in extracts; it will, moreover, shortly appear in print. It is a historic speech, to which a place of honour in the history of the Jewish national movement in Austria remains assured. It is almost superfluous to add that it met with jubilant applause in the meeting.

The debate at times took a stormy course. It became evident that deep bitterness prevailed against the leading Jewish Social Democrats and against Daszynski on account of their hostile attitude towards the Jewish Nationalists. As the Social Democrats present made demonstrations, there were stormy scenes. The first speaker was Herr Lucian Brunner, who advocated a self-defence organisation of the Jews and declared the existing political parties incapable of representing Jewish rights and interests. In the name of the Zionists Dr. I. Schalit discussed their attitude to the question of autonomy, the solution of which he described as the settlement of the struggle between the policy of assimilation and national policy. But a merely national policy without the Zionist aim of a homestead would be patchwork. The Zionists are for national autonomy and will join with all their energy in the fight for it, but they will not lose sight of their final goal.

Deputy Dr. Straucher, greeted with stormy applause and cheers: We Jews in the East of the Monarchy have long since begun to organise ourselves on a Jewish national basis, and we believe we owe it to our Jewish people to secure its future, everywhere endangered, on a national basis. When the question has assumed more concrete forms in Parliament, I shall not fail to stand up there for our people's cause. But a final solution of the Jewish national question and of autonomy must be brought into connection with a productive homestead for the Jews. Without soil and land of its own the realisation of the Jewish national idea is not possible in the future. In his closing appeal he calls for organisation under the sign of the Jewish national movement, under the sign of Jewish national autonomy!

The Social Democratic opposing speaker, Dr. Horn, defends Social Democracy against the charge of obdurate hostility to the Jews and considers the carrying-out of Jewish autonomy a misfortune. What the national curia is for other nations will be the Ghetto for the Jews. The overwhelming majority of the others will regard this curia like the yellow badge of the Middle Ages.

The Ruthenian deputy Prof. Romanczuk, who was the first in Parliament to advocate the national recognition of the Jews, was the object of the heartiest ovations at the meeting. It almost seemed that less would have been more. He declares that he made the proposal of the Jewish curia not out of enmity towards the Jews, but also not out of mere friendship. Three reasons were decisive: first, the actual conditions, since it is established that the Jews, despite their dispersion over the whole globe, have everywhere retained their national peculiarity, and must therefore be regarded and treated as a whole. The second reason was a feeling of justice. And then the recognition and treatment of the Jews as a nation of their own lies in the interest of Jews and non-Jews. Every Jew should indeed be left free to profess himself of any nation, but none may be prevented from professing his own nationality. Advocacy of autonomy in Parliament could only be successful if the Jews themselves pursue the work of propaganda energetically. The chief work must be done by the Jews; he is ready to champion their cause further in the Chamber of Deputies.

Herr Richard Rappaport, whose substantial speech for autonomy did not receive due attention owing to the lateness of the hour, first polemicised against Jewish Social Democracy and discussed the advantages of the national autonomy of the Jews. Secretary Fleischer (Union) considers the meeting premature with regard to practical political purposes, and therefore mistaken. The idea of Jewish national autonomy must not come before the public as the idea of a single political group; it gains value and significance only when propagated by the whole body of Austrian Jewry. For great political meetings the question is not yet ripe. A uniform treatment and a uniform platform are necessary. The speaker suggests co-operation of all political, national and social groups of the Austrian Jews and desires the most intensive work of enlightenment.

Dr. Weisengrün proposes the following resolution: "The Jewish mass meeting assembled in the Ronacher Hall on 12th December 1905 declares itself for national autonomy in Austria, and on the ground of the individual right of self-determination, as well as of the undeniable intellectual individuality of the Jewish people, demands for that people national equality of rights with all the Austrian nations." The resolution was adopted amid stormy applause by all votes against 8.

After a brief closing word from the principal speaker, the memorable meeting was closed.

How widely Jewish circles have already taken up the matter of national autonomy is shown by the telegrams and letters of greeting which had arrived from all the Crown lands and which, often passionately, demand fundamental national rights for the Jews. From congregational boards, societies and individuals nearly three hundred declarations of assent had arrived, some of which bear hundreds of signatures. The meeting must be the signal for a mass movement. National Jews of Austria, arise! Forward to agitation, forward to national work!

The Russian Relief Work.

The Relief Work. Up to the 1st of this month the collections for the Russian Jews amounted, at the Hilfsverein der deutschen Juden, to more than 1½ mill., at the Frankfort Committee to 675 000 marks, at the Alliance Israélite in Paris to 1½ million frcs., and at the Israelitische Allianz in Vienna to 500 000 Kronen. An equal sum is said to have already been raised in Hungary. In England the collections have so far yielded 78 750 pounds. It is, however, to be expected with certainty, given the great agitation which the bloody events in Russia have aroused, that Christian participation will yet assume great dimensions. A mighty movement has taken hold of the Jews of America. The well-to-do bring their cheque-books with them straight to the meetings. The by Major Weaver