Page 14 — "Die Welt" — No. 44
(continued from page 13)
…cusses, in a long leading article entitled "We and the Zionists", the relation of this group to Zionism. Whoever has had occasion in recent years to observe the hostile attitude and argumentation of the Czech-Jewish assimilationists towards the Zionist movement will be bound to note with satisfaction that on this opposing side, despite all its warped judgments and misinterpretations, somewhat more understanding of the Jewish question and a warmer Jewish feeling have gained ground. How the "Rozvoj" assimilationists in particular strive to approach all Jewish questions with earnestness and interest! Zionism has slowly taught it them. They are still far from understanding it, to be sure, but they occupy themselves with it very thoroughly. If its power of agitation and its popular basis impress them, as the leader-writer admits, that is no wonder, for they see with their own eyes how it wins more and more ground from the assimilationists of both languages of the land. In an earlier number the founding of a Zionist local group in Nachod draws from the paper the resigned sigh: "Our Czech-Jewish intelligentsia has vanished as if from the face of the earth." There is a good joke in the fact that in the same notice that local group is called an "asylum for nationally indifferent Jews". Incorrigible enthusiasts! A national movement appears in our time as an "absolute anachronism" to the leader-writing moralist, who sees the salvation of Judaism only in the reform of the Jewish religion and in the improvement of the Galician and Hungarian Jews. The Jewish renaissance movement, he says, lacks a moral foundation, because it has only material ends and the Jewish nation is not the bearer of higher spiritual ideas. The man suffers from the fixed idea that in Zionism ethical and moral motives are excluded on principle. Palestine he naturally condemns as the most barren land, without iron, without coal, without rain, without forests, without room for 12, say twelve, million inhabitants. "All or nothing" is his motto. The scribbling leader-writer is particularly hard upon the Galician and Hungarian Jews, with whom he no doubt rejects all solidarity as a cultural degradation, but whom he wishes improved, so as not to be made jointly responsible for their faults. It is his second fixed idea that the Zionists cover up Jewish faults à tout prix and dissuade the Jews from self-knowledge. Let it merely be replied in passing: criticism of the Jews and their weaknesses so unsparingly sharp and severe has scarcely ever yet been practised from the anti-Zionist side. But it would be dull-witted to hold the Jews responsible, for example, for their occupational structure, or for conditions which develop of necessity out of the economic and political milieu. In every country to-day the Jews are the product of their surroundings and stand where their own history and that of the country has placed them. In this land we alone cannot create our conditions of existence or decisively influence them. At all events the argument that the Zionists flatter the Jews and do not concern themselves at all with the morals of the people is original. Hitherto we have been hated as oppositionists and called disturbers of the peace. In the "Rozvoj" the tactics are changed. Things must be going very badly with the gentlemen up there in the districts of Bohemia when the article dies away in the cry of despair: "The Zionists, thanks to their flatteries, are beloved and we are in disfavour; they constantly gain ground and we lose it." Flatteries, beloved — do not laugh, you who are better informed! The good man exaggerates in his fear of the Zionist flood, and sees the end of the Czech-national assimilationist movement approaching. Its spokesmen in the press were not always so faint-hearted and so near to insight. One thing be granted: the people in and around the "Rozvoj" are not our most unsympathetic opponents. Not everything Jewish is foreign to them. Despite all, we may draw from the leading article the hope that they are capable of improvement.
On the occasion of a polemic, the "Egyenlőség" defines its position towards the suffrage movement. Standing wholly on the laudable ground of altruism, Mr. Szabolcsi reveals himself as a decided adherent of universal suffrage and champions its introduction with all verve. He writes: "I do not understand politics, and I cannot comprehend in what way it would harm my fatherland if two million discontented people were made content, and in how far it would be a misfortune if these, who represent a considerable intelligent and moreover also weighty part of the population, yet exercise no influence on the administration of the country, should in future vote at an election of deputies as we do, or rather only have the same influence on legislation as we. Perhaps we alone can govern well, and they not? Is it not wiser and better if more factors come into consideration in the legislation of the country? Does this not bind them more firmly to the nation, and is not the election in which 10 000 take part better than that in which a smaller number takes part? And does not such a Parliament, elected by three million citizens, reflect the temper of the country more truly than one which represents merely 800 000?" On the question whether the Parliament will be a Magyar one, he expresses himself as follows: "Hungary has given the non-Magyar nationalities far greater rights than any other State of Europe in which there are other nationalities besides the ruling nation. In Hungary there exist, among other things, several thousand schools in which the language of instruction is not the language of the State, and in which the Magyar language is at the least not taught with success. Against this, of which there is no example in no parliamentarily governed State (?), Magyardom is not guarded; yet people are afraid to grant the right which exists even in Germany, where the nationalities are robbed of their national possessions with the help of the institutions of the State. I now ask: was the State more Magyar when only few exercised the franchise, when all rights were in the hands of the nobility? Is not a State the greater and mightier, the larger the masses over which it extends its rights, the smaller the number of those excluded and entitled to discontent? Have history and the example of the civilised States any influence, then? Already the Bible teaches that the same law shall prevail for every man in the land.
What justice is it that the labouring, producing masses exercise no influence upon the country which they maintain? That is a Roman conception, which lets him alone count as master who does not work. The worker has been looked down upon and robbed of his rights . . . It is moreover incomprehensible that people do not see that not only the nationalities but also hundreds of thousands of Magyars are excluded from the franchise. For the Magyars are in the majority in the country, and so also in the classes which are now excluded from the franchise."
Only one thing Mr. Szabolcsi forgets to answer: What will become of the Jews? What advantages will they have from universal suffrage, beyond the glory of having thought little of themselves and more of others?
Index to the Protocols of the Zionist Congresses I—VI. By Hugo Schachtel. Published on commission by the "Jüdischer Verlag", Berlin. The little book, an exceedingly diligent and laborious piece of work, undoubtedly fills a perceptible gap and is a valuable supplement to the Congress Protocols, which now gain in value and usefulness for the Zionist practitioner and theorist. The arrangement of the index is very well suited to its purpose. The immense material, which embraces every field of the Jewish problem, is ordered under the following main heads: Zionism, Condition of the Jews, Organisation, Actions Committee, Congress, Palestine, Colonial Bank, National Fund, Present-Day Work, The Spiritual Element in Zionism, Economic Present-Day Work, Physical Improvement, Political Questions. A general subject index and a "speakers' index" — the names of the Congress speakers — form the next sections. The index is followed by a short bibliographical compilation of the literature on Palestine, the Orient and colonisation, as published by the Palestine Commission. Though very incomplete, it is nevertheless in place. It would be advisable to combine with the next index, which is also to bring a list of all the Congress delegates to date with biographical particulars, a more complete bibliography of Palestine and as exact a compilation as possible of Zionist literature, instead of this appendix of doubtful value. The acquisition of Schachtel's little book is a self-evident necessity for Zionist libraries and for owners of the Congress Protocols. Unfortunately the latter are in part already out of print. Would a new edition not be possible? —ss—
World Chronicle.
German Diplomacy and the Kutzo-Vlachs. A very apt remark is made by the "Frankfurter Zeitung" on the occasion of the intervention of German diplomacy on behalf of the rights of the Kutzo-Vlachs, a Roumanian tribe under Turkish sovereignty, writing among other things: "The intervention of German diplomacy on behalf of the Kutzo-Vlachs is very remarkable. When some years ago the United States of America, in the name
