Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 40 · 6 October 1905
7printed page
scan 7 of 20

No. 40. — "Die Welt" — Page 7.

Accordingly, the data on the economic condition and the legal position of the Jews in Russia collected by the so-called Jewish commissions of Count Pohlen, of General Kadeanow and of Count Ignatjew are to be handed over to a new commission, in order to acquaint the Imperial Duma with the views of the aforesaid commissions on the part played by the Jews in Russia. If one considers that the whole policy of the Russian Government towards the Jews hitherto is a product of these views, one will understand the ideas and the aims of the new commission.

It is expected of Secretary of State von Witte, however, that at the eleventh hour he will give a new direction to the views of the commission on the future shaping of the condition of the Jews in the Tsar's empire. And that is the reason why this time our kinsmen in Russia too have awaited Witte's return with suspense.

The massacres of Jews in Kertsch have had a sequel which throws a glaring light on the causes of the bloody excesses against the Jews throughout Russia. The municipal council of Kertsch, on the basis of reliable data, resolved in an extraordinary session to condemn without reserve the conduct of the police and the chief of police during the excesses against the Jews, to express its sympathy to the Jewish inhabitants of Kertsch, and to draw the attention of the Minister of the Interior to the participation of policemen in the butchery of Jews. This manifestation of the Kertsch Duma, which has caused a great sensation throughout Russia, found support in a letter from the harbour-master of Kertsch, who declared openly that the police aided and protected the plunderers and murderers of the Jews, while the Jews were persecuted by them and prevented from defending themselves. The letter of the honest harbour-master, who himself at the peril of his life saved the lives of many Jews, is described by many Russian papers as a grave indictment of the police.

The Ministry of the Interior, however, on which the branding of the conduct of the police in excesses against the Jews properly depends, unhappily continues to cling to the maxims of Plehve. All complaints of Jews against violations of their rights are rejected, the petitions of Jews for an alleviation of their hard condition left unheard. Jewish assistant apothecaries who arrived in Kasan to pass their apothecaries' examinations at the university there were expelled by order of the Minister. What, then, can the Jews hope for? Gt.


Column for Discussion.

The attitude of "Die Welt" on all questions of Zionism is fixed by the resolutions of the Congress and by the appeal of the President of the A.-C. It nevertheless remains open to every opinion advanced on its merits, and naturally permits discussion within proper bounds. For this purpose we conduct this special column, in which all unofficial opinions too may find expression.

* * *

On the Programme of the Palestine Commission.

Dr. Franz Oppenheimer's article ("Welt" No. 37), "Large-Scale Colonisation, Small-Scale Colonisation and Security under Public Law", has attracted particular attention in Zionist circles, since it appears to express not merely the personal views of the well-known economist but the common view of our Palestine Commission. I hold these arguments to be in many points mistaken and, from the Zionist standpoint, dangerous.

The proof, to be sure, that with his model colonies on the principle of the settlement co-operative he does not mean to return to small-scale organisation, Oppenheimer has furnished so convincingly that no word need be said about it here. But let us turn to the main idea of the essay: by means of the "settlement co-operatives" to be established in Palestine (or elsewhere) we must prove that a colonisation carried out according to the Oppenheimer theory yields good interest on the money employed in it, and so represents an excellent investment of capital. Only thus can we procure for ourselves the foundation for a Zionist action on a larger scale, the "credit basis" that is indispensable in view of our lack of funds.

I do not wish to enter upon a criticism of the "settlement co-operative", nor to rest my case on the fact that the majority of German economists hold the Oppenheimer theories to be mistaken. The practical proof of their feasibility is not only an entirely understandable wish of their author, but is certainly desirable in the general economic interest as well. Attempts in that direction, however, have nothing to do with the Zionist movement. If the practicability of the "settlement co-operative" has been proved and has won recognition, it is possible, even probable, that Zionism will adopt this mode of colonisation and carry it out on a larger scale. But it does not seem to me obliged or entitled to spend the scanty Zionist funds on that proof. All the less so as Oppenheimer is preparing an experiment to be carried out on a large scale in Germany. Until the results of this settlement co-operative can be surveyed, we shall have to wait, and can wait, with the redemption of the Jewish people.

And do the right of Zionism to exist and its prospects really hang upon the decision whether a theory of the economist Oppenheimer is correct or not? I believe very many Zionists will answer with me: no, most decidedly no. If the "settlement co-operatives" prove not to be practicable — we should regret it, but would we have to give up at once and for ever every hope of finding a suitable mode of colonisation? Only in the event that the experiments were carried out as officially Zionist ones could their failure paralyse or even destroy our capacity for action — and therein I see their danger — whereas otherwise the outcome of purely economic experiments touches us but little.

So much for my criticism. Can I "point out a better, easier, nearer way"? No. — I do not believe at all in an easy and near way to the goal. But it is my firm conviction that the Jewish people must not perish and also — the only way would be assimilation among the host peoples — in fact cannot perish. In the belief, then, that the only possible and desirable solution of the Jewish question lies in the direction of Zionism, I hope that an agitation and policy on a grand scale will succeed in interesting the majority of Jews and the authoritative non-Jewish bodies in the Zionist ideas. If we succeed in that, if above all in the course of time Jewish high finance is won over, then and only then shall we not lack money and the indispensable credit basis. In a financing of Zionism on purely business, speculative grounds I cannot believe. The man of money who is not specially interested in Zionism will always find loans for his capital which