Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 39 · 29 September 1905
8printed page
scan 8 of 20

Page 8. — "Die Welt" — No. 34.

(continued from page 7)

…should; it was only thought that this was not what he most needed, nor that for which the physician had been called. Herein lies the great danger for Zionism, the danger of sinking into a Chovevei-Zion movement, into debating clubs, into societies for the arranging of excursions and dancing parties. When Mr. Wolffsohn said at the close of the Congress that the crisis in Zionism was over, he was probably speaking of the internal crisis and not of the external one, our present impotence in Palestine. The internal crisis was of a twofold nature — the death of Herzl and the East Africa dispute, and the Zionists may congratulate themselves that neither of the two was able to break Zionism. And if Dr. Nordau was unable to influence the Congress, he nevertheless made possible the sure and dignified transition from the Herzl period to the new one.

In Ussishkin Herzl has found a successor in respect of zeal, strength of will and organising power. But his influence seems to be confined to the Russians alone, and it is very questionable whether he will succeed in exerting a like magnetism upon the Western elements as well. His views are too bureaucratic, too unpolitical, too much Russian. He has possibly the stuff of a Joshua in him, but he cannot be a Moses. One thing we Western Europeans — and most particularly we English, who in proportion give more money to the cause than the Russians — would beg of him: to prevent in future such election scandals as those which darkened this Congress. Zionism, after all, ought to serve as a means of education.

Time will show how far his power reaches; whether in the Committee of Seven, in which he honestly earned his seat thanks to the majority, he will make a Chamberlain, or whether, without the following with which he outvoted everyone, he will be kept in the background. Forceful personalities are ranged against him there: Wolffsohn, Dr. Marmorek and Greenberg. In the larger A.-C. he has still more opponents. But at the Congress his resolutions, like Aaron's rod, swallowed up all the others. The reason is clear: he knew what he wanted. Now if Ussishkin's plan of war, as set down in his pamphlet "Our Programme," is indeed very childish and utopian, one must not forget that so too, in great part, was Herzl's "Jewish State." And as Herzl developed more and more, so it may be with Ussishkin as soon as he is brought face to face with reality. This at any rate is a joyful fact that may be recorded: there is no lack of workers. There was much dispute over the choice of the one or the other. In reality leaders are not elected; they elect themselves, because they feel within them an irrepressible urge to take upon themselves the burden of their people. But Herzl seems to be irreplaceable in one respect, namely as a diplomatist. If one step failed, his lively mind knew how to prepare another. He was ever busy winning new potentates for his plans, and when he already stood on the brink of the grave he was still devising a new political move. Fortunately we still possess Mr. Greenberg as political agent.

It is natural that Mr. Wolffsohn, the elected leader of our movement, should develop into a real leader and bring forward ideas of his own, instead of merely trying to hold the Congress together. Perhaps he will succeed in taming Ussishkin and continuing Herzl's great political moves. Certainly he is developing a talent for diplomacy too. He evaded quite skilfully in his answers my questions, which were meant to drive him into a

corner. A man of pleasing manners, of brilliant business sense and great devotion to our cause, he revealed this year an unexpected new power of commanding a view of the Congress, while his short speeches betrayed breadth of outlook and depth of feeling. Certainly he is developing into a real leader of Zionism. And then, who can foretell what riches and surprises the youth of our people still holds in reserve for us? Zionism, then, has not yet grown faint. Let us hope that the new A.-C., which is now no longer paralysed by internal dissensions, will develop fresh activity and tread with sure foot the path that leads either to success or at least to useful experience.

Ladies and Gentlemen! The Seventh Congress has been accused of a want of dignity. Do not believe it. When 600 Jews from 22 countries come together and devote the summer days and nights to a debate, however vehement, on impersonal national questions, that can present no undignified spectacle. The long rolls of our history record no weightier and more earnest moments. There were delegates who journeyed for weeks from their homes to Basle; a woman was present there who, although her physician had told her that she had perhaps three months more to live, would not be denied spending the last days of her life at the Congress. The majority did not use its power to shout down the minority; on the contrary, it listened with remarkable patience to views that must have pierced their hearts like knife-thrusts, and their joy over the victory won, the joy of hope in Palestine, was most touching. History alone will show who was right, the majority or the minority. One thing history has already proved: that the ray of light which Herzl sent through our dark annals was no momentary flicker. It closed the mediaeval epoch and began the new age. We ought to date our history A.H. and P.H., before Herzl and after Herzl. Before Herzl — degradation, everlasting aimless wandering, the scorn of the nations, or at best the awkward assurance of our equality; after Herzl — the calm assurance of self-respecting manhood, the proud proclamation of our people, and the untiring endeavour to shape with our own hands a destiny worthy of our heroic past in Palestine.

From Bialystok.

In supplement to the report on the bloody excesses in Bialystok which we published in our last number, a further report reaches us from a friendly quarter in Vilna, from which we omit the details already described and give in extract only those passages that deal with the genesis and development of the terrible tragedy:

"Living in the neighbourhood of Bialystok, we had indeed already guessed from the meagre official report how matters must have gone there; but what our emissary reported as an eyewitness showed us a terrible picture such as we could not at all have imagined. In Bialystok the system of government staged a spectacle on a grand scale, such as it had staged shortly before on a small scale, almost simultaneously, in Schitomir, Berditschew, Pinsk, Mohilew. This system, as is well known, has as its aim to destroy not the revolution, but the revolutionaries. And