Page 12. — "Die Welt" — No. 38.
(continued from page 11)
…to Dr. Nordau that he might well refuse to support me if he wished, but that nothing on earth would prevent me from mounting the tribune and doing my duty. I mounted the tribune and delivered my speech, and nothing whatever occurred of all that these panic-stricken prophets had feared. On the contrary, my speech was even received very flatteringly. All the wild rumours that I was dragged down from the tribune are nothing but journalistic inventions.
Thus began the great debate, which, through the absence of Dr. Nordau's enchanting eloquence, was, alas, without any brilliance. But this abstention alone would hardly move me to come out so sharply against a dear friend, to whom I am bound by the tie of mutual affection. I told him that one must forgive everything to a man in his state of health. The debates dragged on through Friday, Saturday evening and Sunday morning. In the afternoon the A.-C. unexpectedly produced a resolution of its own, which, through the oversight characteristic of it, it had until then omitted to do. This resolution, which is a contradictory medley of Ussischkin's ideas with unhappy remnants of Greenberg's notions, contained everything against which I was fighting; it rejected every land not belonging to the countries neighbouring Palestine, it recommended the alteration of the Bank's statutes, and de facto excluded the Territorialists from Zionism. Now I had, however, arranged with the President that, in case such a resolution should be brought forward, I should receive the floor on a point of order to speak against it, by proving that it did not lie within the competence of the Congress to limit the activity of our Bank to any particular region, since that was the business of the shareholders alone. This resolution was now, to my further amazement, brought forward under the auspices of Dr. Nordau himself, who not only let it take precedence over mine, which he had originally signed himself, but would not give me the floor on a point of order at all, as promised. The resolution of the A.-C. was forced upon us at the point of the bayonet, without anyone being allowed to speak even one word against it; but when everything was already settled and all lands except Palestine and the neighbouring countries had been excluded, Dr. Nordau permitted me — to speak in favour of East Africa. What irony! Under such circumstances, I said, I did not wish to take up the time of the Congress and would withdraw the resolution. But when I thought of the game that was being played with me there, when I thought of the misery of the Jewish masses in Russia and Galicia and of the tragic problem of our wanderers, before whom all the gates of refuge are gradually closing, and when I considered how passionately and bloodily the nations fight one another for every foot of land, and that we had so lightly rejected the opportunity, which had offered itself to us after eighteen hundred years of captivity, of securing by peaceful means for our homeless wanderers a home secured by public law, then I felt an impulse, painful as it was to me to have to say such things to so dear a friend, to appeal against Dr. Nordau to the judgment of history. Dr. Nordau sacrificed everything to the peace and unity of the Congress. As President he held it to be his chief duty — (to which the disorders of the night sitting, at which he was not present and which were described to him in exaggerated form, no doubt served as a further occasion) — no matter whether he was right or not. But whether I acted rightly or not, I in no circumstances betrayed my mandate to the Congress; I bore the disgrace in silence. I
communicated nothing of it to my Territorialist friends, so that they should not stage a demonstration against Nordau, and in spite of the all-too-zealous interference of the English contingent I took leave of Nordau with the same friendship as before. In reality this friendship on my side was even heightened by the manly confession of Dr. Nordau to Mr. R. Brainin, as reported in the Hebrew journal "Hasman." You have no doubt read it in the "Jewish Chronicle," but it deserves to be repeated in this place. Mr. Brainin writes that after the close of the second sitting of the Congress — that is, immediately after my scene with Dr. Nordau — he went up to him and congratulated him on the victory which had been won with his help as President. With a troubled face and a sombre-sounding voice Dr. Nordau answered: "To-day we have sinned against posterity." "If you think so," I asked, "why did you not make your opinion known before the Congress, and why did you support the adoption of the resolution?" "I lacked the strength and courage to champion my view," answered Nordau. "As President of the Congress I had to submit to the decision of the majority and to save the honour of the highest Zionist institution, the Congress, from the violence of the minority." "I give Nordau's answer word for word," remarks Mr. Brainin. "The words 'To-day we have sinned against posterity' made a shattering impression upon me. I took every pains to convince him that the adoption of this resolution and the split that would follow upon it were necessary, but it was impossible to calm him. 'To-day we have sinned against posterity.'" As you can see from this, Dr. Nordau's innermost feeling differed from my reproach, in that, instead of being unjustified and unspeakable, it was only unnecessary; and when I read this truly tragic interview, I regretted the expression for the first time.
But together with the Jewish people I deplore the fact that both the Sixth and the Seventh Congress were led by sick men. Had Nordau been able at this Congress to throw his titanic strength into the Territorialist cause, our history might now be written differently. Had he even only kept the Congress within the framework of political Zionism, along the lines of his great opening address, he would have saved Herzl's ideas from defeat. And had Dr. Herzl been in good health at the Sixth Congress, he would, instead of taking every pains to recall the rebellious minority, simply have taken his stand upon the statutes of the Jewish Colonial Bank. These statutes, although they were drawn up by a Zion-Zionist lawyer, nevertheless recommend colonisation in every land of the globe. Why? Because practical men understand that, for the attainment of a political goal, one may sometimes have to be able to work in every possible part of the world, however little the country concerned may seem to be in touch with the final aim. Herbert Spencer explained it by the following example: When a coppersmith has to smooth out a dent in a pan, he will never hammer directly at the dented spot, but will always tap round about the dent, sometimes even quite far from the dent, everywhere except at the dent itself, until the dented part gradually becomes straight. In the same way it may become necessary for Zionism to hammer away everywhere, in the most diverse places, only not in Palestine itself. The question how and where to hammer is no affair of the common soldiers of the Congress, but of the skilled experts, the leaders. Since the Congress has now resolved no longer a Jew-
