"Die Welt" — No. 39. — Page 5.
(continued from page 4)
…cussion within proper limits. For this purpose we maintain this special section, in which all unofficial opinions may also find expression.
Israel Zangwill's Report on the Congress to His
London Constituents.
(Delivered on the 18th inst. at the "Wonderland.") Translated for "Die Welt" by Dr. J. M. S—d.
(Conclusion.)
We ought to have waited and gathered strength. Fresh blood, fresh money and new influence. Herzl's diplomacy did not reach its goal, not because he was a bad diplomatist, but because there was not much behind his diplomacy, as Nordau expressed it in two immortal epigrams: "The fiddler was created before the fiddle; our people had a Herzl, but our Herzl had no people." By an oversight, to be sure, Dr. Nordau greatly underestimated the number of Dr. Herzl's adherents when he reckoned them at one sixtieth of the Jewish people! It should properly have been one twelfth, since to every shekel-payer there falls a wife with several children, and since before the Sixth Congress there were 150,000 shekel-payers, who, together with their families and the non-paying sympathisers, make up at least a million souls. But even a million out of a people of twelve millions is still a very small proposition, above all when it is a million of poor and not a million of rich Jews. Do ut des — I give that thou mayest give — is the motto of diplomacy. The Sultan had something to give Herzl, but Herzl had nothing to give the Sultan. Nothing but the future labour of the Jewish people, and that lay too distant and nebulous for the practical Turk. Had Herzl had behind him a million well-to-do Jews, among them that class which invites prime ministers to its country houses and grants great loans to Russia or Japan, he would have obtained a charter on his very first visit to Constantinople. What the Zionists have now to do, therefore, is simply to collect money. Mr. Oskar Marmorek, in his good report, repeated to the Congress the well-known saying of Turenne: "What is needed is money, and money, and again money." He said not a word of muscles and morals, yet no one reproached him for it.
But the Congress resolved not to sit still and collect; the tactics of Ussischkin are rather to spend and to be busy. They mean now to begin work in Palestine without any legal security whatever, and hope in this way to obtain it. And if they do not set about at once applying the little sum of £40,000 sterling to the purchase of land, it is only because Dr. Leopold Kahn, the one man in the Congress well versed in Turkish law, proved to them that at present there is not even legal security for a purchase, and that they might simply lose the money. One would think this sufficient to serve them as a warning sign of the untenability of their method. But no! The will to purchase land is still as strong as before, as soon as the prospect of a secure legal fiction offers itself; meanwhile, however, they have pledged themselves to promote agriculture, industry, etc.; in that "etc." lies a peculiar danger, for it hides a whole multitude of sins. The present resolution does not belong wholly to Ussischkin; the glory of one word in the principal paragraph is due to Dr. Marmorek. Ussischkin wished to develop Palestine by work in the country and the drawing in of new forces. Dr. Marmorek, who had raised his voice for the old political method, believed he was fighting desperately against petty colonisation when he construed the expression "new forces" as meaning new colonists, for which reason the expression naturally could not stand. But as Ussischkin declared that he meant by it only "agricultural teachers," the word "intellectual" was added in order to reassure Dr. Marmorek. Yet if Ussischkin really meant only teachers, Marmorek's victory was merely verbal. However that may be, Marmorek did not attack the Ussischkin resolution at the right point. For Dr. Herzl's method did not seek to prevent fresh colonists from going to Palestine, but held that no further Jewish labour should be spent on the regeneration of Palestine. For the power of our people to bring Palestine to life again was the chief offer we were in a position to make to the Sultan in return for granting us there a home secured by public law. But in excluding new colonists while permitting the Congress to undertake agricultural and industrial work, Dr. Marmorek voted for a resolution which, from the political standpoint, is full of contradictions within itself, and stands far nearer to the Ussischkin method than to Herzl's. So too was the other principal resolution, which is a mixture of Ussischkin's and Greenberg's ideas: but whenever an Ussischkin resolution was mixed with that of another, it happened in the same manner as the lion was mingled with the lamb. The lion and the lamb both lay together, but the lamb lay inside the lion. If one intends to promote the agriculture and industry of Palestine, it would surely be more reasonable to settle new colonists there, whereby at least the population of the country increases. But if the Sultan has only to look on quietly while his desert province is regenerated and his revenues multiply, why should he repay us with political rights and run the risk of a complication that might arise from our self-government and our dominion over many other subjects in Palestine? Professor Warburg gives an answer to this: because appetite comes with eating. We wish to cultivate only a small area, and when the Sultan is convinced how nice it is, he will, like Oliver Twist, ask for more. But why, after all, should he ask, when he has only to wait, since we are compelled — compelled, that is, by our avowed method and by other necessities — to pour out more and more, because we need Palestine far more than he needs us? You know, the Sultan is the cleverest politician in Europe. He will permit the Jews to settle in Palestine and to found banks and other institutions there — as the cat likes to see the mouse draw near to her. But what guarantee is there that, after the mouse has eaten itself a little fat, the cat will not seize it with her paws?
Let us suppose for a moment that the land for which the Zionists long were not Palestine but Morocco, which would indeed lighten the task inasmuch as the Jews there form nearly a third of the population. Suppose that the Jews, in their longing for Morocco, after first carefully summoning a Congress in order to make their intention known to the Sultan of Morocco, had resolved at this Congress to found a Jewish national library at Mogador, to subsidise the Jewish girls' school at Fez with 1000 francs, to call into being a small Anglo-Moroccan society at Tangier for the promotion of Moorish agri-