Page 10. — "Die Welt" — No. 38.
(continued from page 9)
…wish with regard to three of these gentlemen, who were in fact elected. And if I am missing from the A.-C., to which, à propos, I never belonged, Mr. Greenberg in return entered the inner A.-C. Mr. Greenberg well deserves his seat in this cabinet. With the exception of Dr. Herzl and Mr. Wolffsohn, no one has yet accomplished so much of practical value for the movement as he. Your last instruction was to oppose any alteration of the statutes of the Jewish Colonial Bank, at least until the Eighth Congress, because you regarded this not only as an injury to the interests of the shareholders, but were also of the opinion that any alteration whatever of the Zionist institutions at the first Congress after Herzl's death would mean an insult to his memory. My efforts at the Congress were directed chiefly to this end, and if a new Jewish Territorialist organisation has been called into being, the obstinate insistence of the Congress upon the alteration of the statutes bears the direct responsibility for it.
I arrived in Basle two days before the Congress and found the air full of the wildest rumours. The parties were said to be so mortally hostile to one another that, in these days of Russian self-defence leagues and pocket-pistols, the worst was to be expected. The sole occasion for this talk seems to have been given by some hot-headed Russian students, who marched through the streets and demonstrated with flags. In reality, however, the situation was of a far more serious nature: an overwhelming majority of unpolitical Zionists, who at a Congress held shortly before in Freiburg had united into a homogeneous body, now became master of the situation. Since both Mr. Chamberlain and Mr. Balfour appeared to favour the idea of a Jewish settlement on a broad basis, I was of the opinion that we had only to approach the Government for a suitable territory in order to obtain it, and I came to the Congress resolved to bring forward a resolution in this sense. But how was I now to act in the face of this Russian majority? Was I to desist from the resolution because I could already foresee that it would be rejected? No! My duty towards you and towards the Jewish people told me plainly that at least a moral protest must be made before the whole world. I have never yet heard of a parliament whose members refused to put their proposals to the vote for fear of being outvoted. I therefore resolved first to raise my protest and then — to submit to the decision of the majority.
The same counsel I gave on the following morning to the Territorialists and the Russian political Zionists, who did me the honour of consulting with me. They are said to have been 150 strong. If one added to them the sympathising English and American Territorialists, the half-sympathising German political Zionists, and the delegates who had not yet formed a definite opinion and could therefore be influenced, one could count with certainty upon the quite respectable minority of 200. I was therefore of the opinion that these 200 should remain in the party even after defeat, so that, if possible, they might form the nucleus of a victorious majority at the next Congress. I explained to them the evils of a split; the world would no longer regard us as one people striving towards one goal, and the Territorialist party, even if separated from Zionism, would meet with obstacles in its undertakings, since the Zionists, by sending commissions to countries which they might not accept, even were they true earthly paradises, because they were entitled to colonise only in Palestine and the neighbouring lands, had brought the political seriousness of the Jews into disrepute. My Territorialist advisers, who made upon me the impression of men of much political training, replied, however, that the split had already been brought about by the Zion-Zion, who had already driven many Territorialists out of Zionism by refusing to take shekolim from them, whereby the Territorialists are naturally so weakly represented at the Congress. This roused my utmost indignation: What, when the Sixth Congress had had a Territorialist majority, Zionist institutions dared to squeeze Territorialists out of the movement!? To influence, nay, to falsify the verdict of the coming Congress in such a manner was nothing but brute force and disgrace. The Territorialists said further: "Even if we are not yet excluded, the Seventh Congress will without doubt lead to it. Let us rather go, and be you our leader." To this I replied that the Congress would indeed suppress every territorial project on its appearance, but that it would never be able to exclude the Territorialist principle so long as the statutes of our Bank permitted us to work for any territory in the world. And since I knew that Mr. Greenberg and Mr. Cowen were, like myself, opposed to any alteration of the statutes, I invited them, and even Dr. Marmorek, to the Territorialists and political Zionists, that they might help me to calm the minority and to move them to abandon every thought of secession. You see, therefore, that I took every pains to keep all the national forces within Zionism. I also requested the minority in any case to conduct themselves quietly at the Congress and not to impair the repute of our public sessions.
If the Territorialists have not always kept their promise, it is probably because there are moments which are too exciting for human nature. He who fights for a high principle cannot always be as cold and motionless as an English Jew in the synagogue. You know the hour when the minority behaved unbecomingly; but do not forget the long sultry hours in which they conducted themselves in exemplary fashion; think especially of that great moment of their complete defeat and humiliation, when they sat in quiet dignity and uttered not a sound. They did not follow my advice as to tactics — which, be it remarked in passing, proves how little I had in common with their doings — they did not vote against the victorious resolution, but they abstained from all voting as a protest against the illegal composition of the Congress. For according to Dr. Stein, the chief of the Russian political Zionists, besides the illegal refusal to sell shekolim to the Territorialists, still far worse illegalities are said to have occurred, such as the admission of delegates without shekolim or, at best, without having been elected by the prescribed number of 200 shekel-payers; there were also delegates who had not yet quite reached the prescribed age, and then pressure was exerted by the Actions Committee throughout all Russia which makes a mockery of every constitution and of all lawfulness. The Zionist general staff in Vienna seemed still too weakly organised to be able to annul such elections. Our Credentials Committee had indeed admitted that several Russian mandates must be declared invalid and that a great many had been incorrectly filled in, but it would not examine any complaints that had come in during the Congress, not even such as that a delegate represented a town in which there absolutely
