Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 37 · 15 September 1905
3printed page
scan 3 of 20

No. 37 — "Die Welt" — Page 3

(continued from page 2)

...the lot of the little ones, who are robbed of the care and tending of a loving mother, anxious.

And numerous are such victims and others like them, of whom no one knows anything, of whose fate scarcely anything reaches the public. The revolution staged by the Jews has been subdued and vanquished by the guardians of order in Bialystok; whether these victims, too, who have been cited here as examples, deserved their fate, will be judged by those who one day read these lines, when they have become history.

The very latest event took place in the old Kishineff, world-famous in Europe and beyond it. A Jewish woman was stabbed to death without reason or cause — a poor mother of four children, whose father died a few months ago. A young man ran after the murderer and was severely wounded by him with a knife. One may imagine what excitement this deed was bound to call forth. The police looked on calmly at the crowd gathering before the house of mourning. Only when the funeral procession was in motion did the guardians of order steal out of their hiding-places and lay into the crowd without mercy. Shots were fired from the crowd, and — a blood-bath ensued such as had not been seen for a long time. How many wounded there were one would have to ask the police, for they strictly forbade the wounded to be taken to the Jewish hospital, and gave orders to lodge them in the Zemstvo hospital and in that of the prison.

Thus only 9 severely injured (two of them in danger of their lives) and 12 slightly injured were taken into the Jewish hospital. The administration of the Zemstvo hospital refuses all information on the number of the wounded, which is said to exceed 50.

Is it intended to withhold this sad event from the public? Has it already come so far that in Kishineff they are beginning to shy away from public opinion? It almost seems so. For the post office, too, refused to accept a telegram about the events addressed to the Vilna daily "Hasman," which was able to bring the news only two days later, from a letter, after it had already become known abroad in every detail.

And now that it is known outside, will they prevent such events from repeating themselves? God alone knows! M. Bendow.


Large-Scale Colonisation, Small-Scale Colonisation and Security

under Public Law.

By Dr. Franz Oppenheimer.

In the Zionist press and at the last Congress, that action which was resolved upon, and indeed already begun, on my — if I may so call it — "authority," namely the establishment of model colonies in Palestine even before the winning of the Charter, has lately been subjected to manifold criticism. I gladly acknowledge that this criticism has on the whole been not only moderate but even amiable; nevertheless I hold myself obliged, in my own name and in that of my colleagues on the Palestine Commission, who are in this respect, too, entirely of one mind with me, to throw an anti-critical light upon the criticism.

I.

The Work of Settlement and Small-Scale Colonisation.

"The Palestine Commission aims at the planting of individual agricultural colonies in the Holy Land without security under public law." So we heard it said. "Exactly the same thing was aimed at, and in part carried out, by Rothschild, by the 'Esra' Society, by the Geulah, etc. But that is not only without value for the Zionist movement; it is without value altogether. It lifts individuals out of Jewish distress — perhaps: what does the community as a whole gain by it? Nothing."

Heard thus, it might seem passable enough! In fact: we do mean to call into being individual colonies without security under public law. In fact, we can thereby directly, in the most favourable case, lift out of the worst Jewish distress only those colonists whom we select for the work. In fact, our procedure resembles that of the colonisation societies as one egg resembles another.

Only that the cleverest man can never tell by looking at an egg what bird will hatch from it. And here it is the bird alone that matters. We are in the firm hope, nay, the conviction, that from the egg which we shall entrust to the hot soil of Palestine to hatch there will creep forth no respectable barnyard cock, content to scratch in his little poultry-yard, but a roc, which will not cease to grow until its mighty wings overshadow the whole land. And that is precisely what distinguishes us from the charitable colonisers, who thank God when dwarf chicks creep out of their eggs.

In brief: what is an end to the colonisation societies is to us a means to a far greater, far more comprehensive, far more fundamentally revolutionary end. Anyone who knows my position on general social questions even from afar must have assumed this as a matter of course of an action in which I take part in a leading capacity. For already in my first work I made it the criterion of every social relief activity whether it acts in the sense of private economy, that is, lifts individuals out of their class, or in the sense of national economy, that is, lifts the class as a whole; and I have always rejected every action that did not promise "national-economic" effect. I might have been trusted not to become unfaithful to my own programme in the face of the infinitely urgent distress of my own kinsmen by blood, and not to try to deaden my sympathy and sense of duty by taking part in merely private-economic actions.

What the colonisation societies did and do is conceived in the sense of private economy, seeks to lift individuals out of the class: what we do is conceived in the sense of national economy, seeks to lift the whole. What they do is each time an end, a fulfilled purpose, and begins afresh with the founding of each new farmstead: what we mean to do is a beginning, is a means. They lay stone upon and beside stone, and at best persuade themselves meanwhile that a house might gradually come of it, large enough to shelter a few thousands; we plant tree beside tree, each one conceived singly as the centre of a forest of the future sprung from its own energy of growth, in the hope that out of this a wood shall arise that will give shade to millions.

What we want, therefore, has nothing in common with Rachmones-colonisation but a fleeting, outward resemblance in the very first beginnings. The very near future must show how differently the two endeavours are meant; for what for the colonisation-