No. 37 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 11
The Outcome of the Seventh Zionist Congress.
By Dr. Max Besser - Hamburg.
Party discipline in Zionism requires that the minority, despite the greatest divergences, submit to the decision of the majority; but it cannot allow itself to be deprived of the right of sharp, objective criticism. This criticism, and the endeavour to bring about by legal means a transformation of the prevailing view, becomes a duty when the representatives of the minority hold the interest of the entire Jewish people to have been gravely injured.
Something of the passion by which probably all who attended the Congress were seized trembled on in the non-participant too. But he nevertheless had occasion to regard all the events with a calmer eye. It was not the scenes of uproar, which certainly lowered the prestige of the Congress, that had a depressing effect, for they might be the consequence of purely external circumstances and need not touch the inner firmness of the movement. What could not but pain him was that a compact majority crushed a minority remarkable for intelligence and numbers, and, without a serious attempt at refutation or understanding, showed itself inaccessible to the weighty and politically eminent argument of a Zangwill. Its will to power has led to a resolution of fateful tragedy.
The explanation of the hostile attitude of the Congress majority towards a territorial action lies in a conception of Zionism in principle which, up to a certain degree and in conjunction with other factors, appears justified, but which, propagated by the Zione-Zion with this exclusiveness and detached from the question of practical necessities, was bound to produce a caricature of Zionism. In those ranks the notion had taken root that the Jewish-national movement, as to its origin and its goal, might refer only to ethical and cultural factors, and that the attainment of a homestead signified only the creation of a cultural-Jewish centre. All arguments derived from an economic distress of the Jewish people appeared to them as subordinate, and, where they were more sharply emphasised, as a dangerous dilution of the Zionist idea, as a turning aside to philanthropic and socialist ideals. They failed to recognise that the mightiest driving factor in the beginnings of the Zionist movement had been the material distress of the Jews, just as this also took up a broad space in Nordau's expositions at the first Zionist Congress, and that only later was the attempt made, by way of theoretical considerations, to detach Zionism from this material foundation and to make it an abstract cultural movement. They failed further to recognise that only the creation of better economic conditions of life could pave the way to a higher culture in the human and the Jewish sense. A glance at Germany might have taught them that Social Democracy, proceeding from Marxist, that is, purely material premises, has been able to raise the German working man to an astonishing height of general culture. Up to a certain moment the representatives of the different views could work together peaceably, for in what signified to the idealist Zionist only the realisation of the Jewish-national Palestinian idea, the other could also discern a means for the creation of normal conditions of existence, worthy of human beings, for the Jewish people. Then at a single stroke the situation changed. The attainment of Palestine in Herzl's sense appeared for the present to have been removed into the far distance, and at the same time the East African territory came into view upon the scene, an offer such as had never yet been made in such magnificence to the Jewish people in the Golus, an offer which apparently did not fit the premises of a cultural-Palestinian Zionism, but which promised to become a mighty factor in the social and economic upward movement of the Jewish people. Thereby the economic and ideal congruence of the goal striven for in the movement was abolished. The question of the motives of the individual's adherence to Zionism, which previously had had only theoretical interest, acquired practical significance. Those who regarded it as the task of Zionism to safeguard the collective interest of the Jewish people could not, on the supposition that the land offered answered the necessary conditions, let this opportunity for putting their views into practice pass by. What at the beginning of the movement had been justified, a work directed solely towards Palestine, they could no longer maintain after Herzl's hopes of support on the part of the financially powerful Jews and of a diplomatic success had proved in part mistaken. For those who saw in the distress of the Jewish people only a factor subordinate to their personal ideal interests, the acceptance of the Uganda project could not but mean an endangering of ideas grown dear to them.
To the latter view the Congress has given the victory. The majority of the Jewish parliamentary representatives has sacrificed the practical possibility of removing a part of Jewish misery upon the altar of the pure Palestine principle; it has set the land above the people. The distress of the Jewish people has been regarded by the national representative body as a quantité négligeable. Those who cry for bread have been put off with the caviar of the future! Or did they believe that the enrichment of Turkey by a few Jewish colonies, possible only at heavy sacrifice, would have any influence whatsoever upon the condition of the Jewish people? It seems to me that by the petty work planned in Palestine they wish to deaden the pangs of conscience over the abrupt rejection of a valuable action, and to preserve within themselves the fiction of a truly large-scale activity in Herzl's sense.
But this conduct involves great dangers for the existence and the significance of the Zionist movement. If the Jewish proletarian masses of the East, who even in socialist organisations still keep touch with Jewish nationhood, come to the recognition that the majority of our Parliament possesses no understanding for their interests, they will be driven into the arms of the ideal of a denationalised socialism. Then Zionism will become an army of officers who lack soldiers; then the popular movement will sink to a politically insignificant party of friends of Palestine colonisation; then we shall in fact appear to the world as the dreamers who have lost all sense of reality.
But does the Uganda project, even from the standpoint of the preservation and development of Jewish cultural forces, deserve the abrupt rejection it met with at the Congress? The inadequacy of the present offer did not, after all, exclude the possibility of obtaining a better territory. Here, in a Jewish commonwealth, even with lesser political concessions in the matter of autonomy, a rich Jewish-national life could develop, which in its existence would not be threatened by a higher modern culture and would thus be free from all the dangers of assimilation. But on this point too blind party zeal has triumphed over calm deliberation.
We are compelled to give expression with all decisiveness to these views, which are shared by the majority of the German Zionists, because we hope by frankness soonest to bring about an understanding. If the victorious majority sees that it is confronted not by a group of Aschzionisten, but by a considerable, organised minority whose loyalty to Palestine is beyond doubt and in
