Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 36 · 8 September 1905
10printed page
scan 10 of 20
Facsimile · scan 10 of 20
Scan of p. 10
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 10. — "Die Welt" — No. 36.

Against the ill will of the high and the higher, the Jews will not be able to find protection even in the Imperial Duma. Gt.


Column for Discussion.

The position of "Die Welt" on all questions of Zionism is fixed by the resolutions of the Congress and by the appeal of the President of the A.-C. It nevertheless remains open to every opinion put forward on its merits, and as a matter of course gladly permits a discussion within proper bounds. For this we open this special column, in which all unofficial opinions may also find expression.

* * *

We have received the following letter and article.

Oppeln.

Dear Sir,

I enclose herewith a short article for "Die Welt", whose early insertion I request. As a member of the governing Directorate of the Jewish Territorial Organisation, I have considered it my duty now to set forth briefly to the Zionist world — I myself, as a political Zionist, have officially remained faithful to the movement — the motives which led us to the new foundation.

Yours respectfully, G. Wunderlich, Advocate.

Necessary Consequences.

Zionism, so far as the overwhelmingly great majority of its adherents is concerned, is the movement of masses who live out their days in the worst economic conditions conceivable. This circumstance the majority of the Seventh Congress forgot; forgot so thoroughly that in the official organ of the German Zionist Federation the result of the Congress could rightly be summed up thus: "Zionism has emphasised and established the historical and the national as against the economic; that is the greatest result of the Seventh Congress."

At a time when economic factors are decisive, among a people the majority of whom do not know what the morrow will bring them, amid nations which treat the members of our people as pariahs, to emphasise exclusively the pure idea of future redemption and to detach it from all real foundations may be ideal and elevating; practical and political it is not. But it is downright dangerous for the preservation of the people when this idea is proclaimed to the world at a time when the mightiest state in that world had offered its hand, on the one side to turn a part of the men who live on air into men firmly rooted in the soil, and on the other to give this people, through the possibility of immediate practical work, a moral support worth more than the most ideal enthusiasm.

For the minority, which stood upon the ground of practical activity, the majority, devoutly enraptured with the pure idea, had absolutely no understanding. A compromise was impossible; the majority, of whom nothing more was asked than to refrain from any restriction of the Basle Programme that would affront the minority and to leave the Programme in its old simplicity, curtly rejected this offer. A united party of the centre was lacking; attempts at its formation miscarried for reasons not to be discussed here. Submission was impossible, the contradictions being irreconcilable; the thought of later exerting an intimidating influence upon the leadership by, say, a palace revolution à la Charkow was, as a matter of course, out of the question.

Thus only one thing remained as the necessary consequence: the formation of the new organisation.

Its foundation had become necessary on other grounds as well. In our view Zionism had the great task of growing gradually into a national movement embracing the whole Jewish people. With the narrowly limited programme which official Zionism now pursues, this is impossible. Only a widened programme, such as we have drawn up, will be the platform able to unite all nationally-minded Jews who still believe in a future for our people.

Our organisation was, moreover, a necessity in order to preserve for the national idea all those elements which for many years had worked faithfully for Zionism, after they had been excluded from official Zionism. For the Territorialists there is no Zionism any longer; between them and Zionism the cloth has been cut; but they will be able to work with enthusiasm in the new organisation: to work for the preservation of our people.

And then one thing more: it is not to be discussed here what causes gave rise to the unfavourable report of the Uganda expedition. One thing is certain: even with a favourable report official Zionism would have declined England's offer. The attempt to win the great philanthropic institutions for the cause failed from the very outset, and would have miscarried again now — with a favourable report — for they all abhor the national element in any treatment of the matter, such as is unconditionally demanded on our side. Now the world will never understand why Palestine alone may be the goal of our wishes, and it is — the writer, for his own part, doubts it, to be sure — not out of the question that the leadership of Zionism may once again be confronted with the question of taking a position on some other offer of settlement, all the more so as the various leaders of official Zionism are said not to be entirely agreed on the notion of the neighbouring lands. Then Zionism will not need to knock in vain at the gates of the great philanthropic institutions; then it will find in our organisation the organ that will carry such plans into execution.

We are, therefore, no fighting organisation against Zionism, as we have, moreover, already declared in the resolution appended to our programme. We are gladly prepared to fight shoulder to shoulder with Zionism; we have points of contact enough. But in order that, though we march separately, we may one day strike together, we must demand one thing: that Zionism recognise and respect in our organisation a brother with equal rights.

G. Wunderlich.


Tribune.

(The Editors are not responsible for this column.)

Esteemed Fellow Zionists!

The opportunity is given us of bringing large sums of money to the National Fund in the easiest manner. This opportunity is offered by the Postage-Stamp Department of the National Fund Commission in Vienna. Here used and unused postage stamps are collected, sorted and sold. This work is carried out by those of our Zionist youth who are versed in philately. It is now the business of every true Zionist to keep these young people supplied with work. Of workers we should have no lack, but precisely of — work. We hereby earnestly call upon our fellow Zionists, men and women, to send it to us.