No. 32 — "Die Welt" — Page 5
(continued from page 4)
…then replies, and place the necessary material in their hands. Our friend Klee in Berlin has introduced such seminar exercises with success, and this example ought to find imitation.
To spur zeal for the small, everyday work, one might perhaps bestow a certain public recognition upon those who can show larger tangible successes. When someone today gives a sum which is perhaps insignificant to him, he may see his name immortalized in the Golden Book or on the Olive-Tree List, while he who recruits hundreds of new workers goes away empty-handed. One might, then, think of giving some such gratification to anyone who wins 200 new shekel-payers within a year. I pass on this suggestion, which has reached me, without being able to warm to it overmuch myself, for the matter has its reverse side as well. Agitation must not degenerate into sport, nor must a contest arise as to who can bring down the most assimilationists. I believe that zeal for our cause is already the highest conceivable, even without such artificial means.
Once we have established what agitation is to accomplish, we come to the further and no less important question of how the work is to be done — the question of method. This question can never be answered exhaustively by making a series of expedient individual proposals; rather, for method too it must be possible to lay down definite guiding principles.
There is in truth only one single method: to work by conviction. — We state our premises, develop our conclusions logically, and report on our activity. We have only to furnish the material on the basis of which Mr. Public, the stern judge, is to pronounce his verdict. Our best acquisitions we make among those people who, on the strength of their own careful examination, have arrived at the same result as ourselves. Our cause is a cause of strict logic, and we do not merely tolerate, we demand that our audience examine it for themselves. (Bravo.)
Thus far, then, the question of method is answered easily enough. But in practice it turns out that it is by no means always so easy to sift out and furnish the right material. What is important and what is not? An excessive abundance of detail, as we have already seen, only confuses — too little is not good either!
And now there come the evil spirits of opportunism, of particularism, and a few other petty spirits besides, and lay snares for us. Important and expedient as it is, for example, that the speaker should also suit himself to his public, this endeavour to make everything palatable to his hearers may at times become dangerous. Certainly, before an audience of worthy, plain citizens it will not be especially expedient to make the distinction between the deductive and the inductive acquisition of views, as a weighty imponderable in judging the Jewish national psyche, the foundation of an agitation lecture; just as little will it be necessary to reassure a circle of atheistically minded "co-religionists" that Zionism brings no danger to religious institutions. But such consideration must never touch the kernel of the matter itself; it may only affect the manner of presentation. Now it is no more than natural that a fellow Zionist who, somewhere at an advanced outpost, has to struggle hard with the prejudices and backwardness of his surroundings, should gradually come to view everything from the local standpoint, and arrange not only his agitation but his entire Zionist outlook according to what his dear fellow-townsmen will say of it. Then a newspaper article, a political action, a speech may often drive such a delegate to despair, because it perhaps disavows the doctrine of the Zionism he has been preaching — a Zionism adapted, censored and corrected for the riper youth of Tiertschiegel or Dingsdorf. Whoever frequently undertakes agitation tours knows this interesting phenomenon. Already at the railway station the expected speaker is given his first instruction: "Here one must be quite especially careful — quite peculiar conditions prevail here — this is exceptionally difficult ground." Well, that may pass! Peculiar conditions and exceptionally difficult ground are to be found everywhere, and are the agitator's daily bread. "Only do not wound religious feelings — nor love of country!" As if a reasonable man could ever feel himself offended in a religious or patriotic direction by a serious exposition of our idea. But it gets better still: "Here they are greatly afraid of the antisemites" — or "Mr. So-and-so has an aunt in Jerusalem" — or "Kommerzienrat X has a Catholic son-in-law." Well, such an aunt in Jerusalem or such a commercial-councillor's son-in-law may, in certain circumstances, set their stamp upon the whole local Zionism. A sensible speaker will naturally not let himself be frightened. He will take note with pleasure of the family circumstances of the esteemed Messrs. So-and-so and X, but will say his little piece undeterred. The great whole must always be kept in view, and in certain circumstances an agitation speaker after whose lecture 90 per cent. of all the members of a group declare their withdrawal — because, namely, they have now really learned the nature of Zionism — may work more beneficently than the delegate who has brought about mass enrolments by heaven knows what hazy presentation. It is precisely the agitators who come from outside, unacquainted with local conditions, who can accomplish infinitely much for the unity of the movement. It would be exceedingly desirable, as I wish to anticipate at this point, if from time to time the principal speakers of the several countries went to foreign countries, in order thus to promote international discussion and so strengthen still further the uniformity of the work.
The whole, then, is to be kept in view; we are working towards the victory of the idea, and not merely to convert this or that individual. Nor should we be overmuch afraid of giving offence to left or right, of provoking misunderstandings, or of intimidating timid souls. We do not speak for children and the feeble-minded, but for mature men with their own power of judgment and normal courage. The others we shall forgo, and without great regret. Above all, in agitation we must guard against every compromise. The organization, the well-knit, disciplined unity, may enter into agreements, but not the agitator, whose task is precisely to proclaim only what is new in our idea, and who must show clearly in what we differ from the others! Only so can we avoid that — just as for a long time past every Jew has possessed his own Shulchan Aruch — every Zionist should now also provide himself with his own programme for domestic use. (Lively applause.)
And with this we come to speak of another important point: our organization embraces representatives of almost all the tendencies present in Judaism, namely of all currents except assimilation; but that is less a current than a stagnant swamp, and our
