Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 31 · 2 August 1905
4printed page
scan 4 of 20

Page 4 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Special Edition No. 31

Monday Afternoon Session.

Opening 4. 30.

Chairman Wolffsohn makes some announcements of business and gives the floor to

Deleg. Staretz: (speaks in Hebrew) He proposes that all motions be rendered into Russian and Jewish, so that all participants in the Congress may take part in the debate.

Thereupon Deleg. Ussischkin (greeted with applause) receives the floor for a motion: His resolution reads: The VII Zionist Congress resolves:

That, parallel with the political-diplomatic activity, as its real foundation and for its strengthening, and in accordance with Point 1 of the Basle Programme, the systematic development of our positions in Palestine must take place, namely by the following means:

  1. Research work in every direction,

  2. Promotion of agriculture, industry, etc., in as democratic a spirit as possible,

  3. Cultural and economic raising and organisation of the Jewry of Palestine through work in the country and through the enlistment of new forces,

  4. Pursuit of the reforms in administration necessary for the raising of Palestine.

The VII Zionist Congress rejects so-called small colonisation, that is, every planless, unsystematic and philanthropic settlement activity.

Rezek (Prague). I beg leave to put before you the following in the name of the Bohemian Zionists: We stand on Herzl's ground of the Basle Programme. Palestine is and remains for us the immovable goal of the Zionist movement. For the attainment of this goal, towards which we strive with all political, economic and cultural means, we hold, now as before, a national, autonomous settlement even upon a territory lying outside Palestine to be a means, and therefore to lie within the framework of the Basle Programme.

Gissin (Mohilew) speaks in Russian and afterwards translates. The members of the A. C. represent the wish for self-taxation on a definite system already worked out. After 2 years the Congress will determine how the money is to be applied.

  1. An education fund is to be founded in Palestine. But first a commission and a league for the spread of education in Palestine are to be founded.

Goldenberg. (Speaks in Russian; Mr. Weitzmann translates as follows):

He declares that no small colonisation is possible in Palestine, that one would meet with great difficulties, and that Turkey would not permit the final carrying out of the Basle Programme; he therefore proposes that no motion be adopted by the Congress which aims at occupying ourselves with small colonisation. One must first obtain the Charter, or great concessions, railways etc.; only then could one begin with small colonisation.

Chairman Wolffsohn. There is before us a motion of Mrs. Dr. Kritschewski to close the list of speakers, and a second motion to limit speaking time to 5 minutes. There are still 36 speakers entered on the report of the Palestine Commission, 39 speakers in all. I draw your attention to the fact that we have first to discuss the report of the A. C., further the organisation, the main matter, further hear Kremenezki's report and speak on propaganda and agitation. And then the Congress has also resolved to deliberate on the Bank. I draw your attention to this and wish to put Mrs. Dr. Kritschewski's motion to the vote. The motion is for the closing of the list of speakers.

Architect O. Marmorek. I do not know what can be said about Palestine that has not already been said. But consider: we have a very great deal to say about the activity of the A. C. and a very great deal on the other points. I beg you, if you wish the Congress to be closed to-morrow evening, rather to choose one general speaker or two and to proceed further; otherwise you will bring it about that we shall, for example, not be able to speak at all on the report of the National Fund and on organisation, and that you will not be able to speak on the Bank to-day. Bear in mind that we may hold no night session; that is the result of the conduct on that certain Saturday. Pray accept my proposal.

Dr. Pasmanik speaks against curtailing the Palestine debate. At worst, he says, the Congress could be prolonged by a day.

The motion: closing of the list of speakers is carried by a large majority.

On a point of order there speaks

Dr. Grünhut (Jerusalem): We are entirely in agreement with the report of the Palestine Commission, but wish that a second commission be appointed, to which would be entrusted, as it were, the control over everything that takes place in Palestine.

Scheinkin (speaks Jargon). Two general speakers may well be chosen, one for and one against But on the most important matter, the report of the Palestine Commission, the speakers entered should be given 5 minutes' speaking time.

Mrs. Swenigoroskaya: On the earlier items the speaking time was not limited; now, when we are speaking of the most important matter, the Palestine Commission, freedom of speech is to be limited! Let us keep freedom of speech; if the time does not suffice, the Congress should be prolonged by one or two days.

Dr. Loewe: I too must oppose the motion now to appoint general speakers, and for a special reason. The debate on the activity of the Palestine Commission must also grant to us, who represent a quite special standpoint, that of cultural work in Palestine, the opportunity of setting forth the programme of our activity. I in particular have undertaken the charge of speaking concerning the library in Jerusalem.

Add to this that there is no more important question at the Congress at all than positive work in Palestine, both from the standpoint of those who, in my opinion not rightly, consider this work inappropriate, and all the more for those who wish to see the centre of gravity of the work transferred to Palestine. I therefore move that you reject the motion for the election of general speakers.

On the vote the motion is rejected by a large majority, while the motion to limit the speaking time of the speakers entered to 5 minutes is carried.

Widrin speaks in Russian.

Temkin takes over the chair.

Scheinkin is in principle in agreement with the work in Palestine. It is of no use, he thinks, much to