Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 29 · 21 July 1905
9printed page
scan 9 of 38

No. 29 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 9

(continued from page 8)

…the nineties laid waste to Africa, carried off the ruminant game and cattle in a proportion of some 95%, and took a form that distinguished it from all other epidemics hitherto known in that part of the world. The most credible explanation of its origin is perhaps that it was brought into Massowah by infected cattle from the Caucasus and, under new conditions, assumed a more violent character, as is mostly the case with diseases that were hitherto unknown to some particular race of men or breed of cattle. Although a few isolated cases have occurred of late in some parts of Africa, the disease seems to be neither so malignant nor so devastating as at first. This is probably because African cattle are now inoculated and consequently fairly proof against it. At all events, so far as we know, the disease does not appear to have broken out afresh among the game in any instance.

The fact that African cattle compare but poorly with European cattle is not, in my opinion, explained by Mr. Kaiser's theory of degeneration through climatic influences. The South African breed shows not only no degeneration, but evidently a steady improvement. Careful selection in breeding will doubtless bring about results just as good as has been the case in England. The Masais are, as Mr. Kaiser says, more intelligent — or, as I should put it, less unintelligent — than the other natives, and have always been a pastoral people; but at best a cow is to them a cow and a bull a bull. I do not mean to say that they are incapable of distinguishing between an exhausted animal and an animal in good condition, but the African has never gone very much further than that, and has frequently spoilt his breed of cattle with inferior stolen (raided) cattle.

Another point, which, however, does not materially affect the position, lies in the assertion that sea transport is injurious to cattle. Last autumn I travelled from America on board an Atlantic Transport liner which carried a considerable cargo of cattle. The voyage lasted ten days. There were no losses, and the superintendent informed me that the cattle invariably gain considerably in weight during the voyage. The two animals which the Austrian Lloyd carried with it on its voyages were not slaughtered because they were sick. I hope at any rate that this was not the case, for I took part in their consumption. The company rather carries two oxen on every voyage in order to have fresh meat for the table.

With regard to Mr. Kaiser's assertion that cotton plantations in East Africa have been unsuccessful, I think I am right in saying that he has in this respect misunderstood Sir Donald Stewart. Sir Donald remarked that until then cotton had been planted only by way of experiment, and that although it was impossible to judge definitely from this of the prospects of cotton production, he nevertheless hoped that it would yield good results in the future.

As against Mr. Wilbusch's report I would observe the following: in order to estimate even approximately correctly the appearance and value of a territory during the eight or nine months of growth, a knowledge of the territory in question, or of one similar to it, gained by personal experience is absolutely necessary. Mr. Wilbusch introduces his remarks by saying that he criticises the position from the standpoint of the son of a Russian landowner. Now the son of a Russian or of any other European landowner may possess a very thorough knowledge of the agrarian conditions of the district in which his father is settled, or he may not possess it; but we must not forget that such conditions are entirely different from those obtaining in tropical Africa, and that the experiences of a Russian or of any other European landowner can be of any use in Africa only in conjunction with a knowledge of the conditions there.

We are told that on our entry into the territory (Camp 28) we came upon barren plains … "there were no trees, no pastures, no people" and (Camp 29) upon "desolate, parched grass plains." It is surely an acknowledged fact that Africa is not the vast desert as which the maps represented that continent to us thirty years ago. There are numerous fertile, luxuriant tracts in Africa, and I have seen many of them. Those two days' marches led us through one of the most beautiful regions I know. Rolling grass plains covered with dense "Sour Veldt," invaluable for cattle, dry, it is true, as is only to be expected at the end of the dry season, but by no means to be called a desert; red clay soil which, to judge from the earth carried down by the rivers, is unusually deep. Even at that season we never travelled six miles without coming upon good water, and it would be difficult to find any spot in the whole territory where water was not to be found within a radius of two miles. The paths for the most part do not follow the watercourses, but lead directly from one water to the next in the direction taken. That region is in truth a natural continuation of the Nandi country, and was described to me as a good example of it.

We are also informed that no timber is to be found in that territory, whereas in reality wooded tracts occur everywhere, and always at a short distance from the homesteads contemplated for the future. It is also said that there is no game in the territory, whereas hartebeest, reedbuck, bushbuck and probably other species as well, which I did not meet with, occur in great numbers. Near Camp 28 I shot a hartebeest which Mr. Wilbusch helped to eat. I must also say that I later photographed a buffalo at a distance of 25 yards between Camps 28 and 29. According to Mr. Wilbusch's statements this animal does not exist on the plateau at all. There are no human inhabitants there — in this respect Mr. Wilbusch is right.

We are further told that the waters of the Kubkong are almost stationary in its lower course. Before the Kubkong unites with the Nalosegele it has a course of about 35 miles and a steady fall of over 1500 feet, or 43 feet to the mile. The course of the Kubkong ends in a series of rapids, over which — for so short a river at the end of the dry season — a considerable volume of water flows. Mr. Wilbusch's knowledge of this river comes to an end at a distance of one third of the way from the source to this junction. Although the water, as is the case with most rivers, is checked in places, it can hardly be described as stationary, let alone stagnant.

We then learn that "the northern Nzoio system appears to possess even less water" than the Ekotakok. On what evidence can this assertion rest? Mr. Wilbusch has seen neither the one river system nor the other. The Ekotakok is a small