Page 4 — "Die Welt" — No. 29
(continued from page 3)
…obstacles could be removed, though by political means. One need not therefore despair that a conjuncture may some day arise through which acquisitions in the intended sense might be made for the Jewish National Fund, whether in its own name or in the name of a body representing it as a juristic person.
For the present this is not the case! If any acquisitions are made now, they must be purchased in the name of an individual. It is clear that in this case one is delivered up, for better or for worse, to the nominee who is entered in the land register. Indubitable security in this direction there really is none. If the mind of this third party changes, so that he does not justify the trust placed in him, if his circumstances worsen and he becomes a debtor, so that the creditors lay hands on the property formally belonging to him, then nothing remains for the real purchaser but to carry on lawsuits, which in itself is certainly nothing agreeable, and as a rule to be left empty-handed. Even the private purchaser in another's name must therefore look about for certain safeguards and precautions to protect him against the occurrence of such eventualities. It is believed—and many private persons are in the habit of making shift with this—that the nominee can be bound by having him execute an attested document at a consulate of the foreign Powers, in which he declares that the immovables bought in his name belong to the real purchaser who furnishes the equivalent. In this respect one is under a delusion. By the law of 7 Sepher 1284 (9 June 1868), by which the subjects of those Powers that co-signed the state protocol in question were admitted to the acquisition of landed property in Turkey, the provision was expressly made, and accepted by the Powers as a condition, that with respect to land its owners, of whatever nationality they may be, are subject solely and exclusively to Turkish jurisdiction and Turkish laws. According to this principle of territorial sovereignty the Turkish authorities have to be guided only by the state of their land register and cadastre, and acquisitions, declarations and reservations made elsewhere can be of no legal significance whatever, all the less so since transfers of rights of ownership, possession or usufruct in landed property are subject in the cadastre and land register, under Turkish law, to quite special formalities to be fulfilled before Turkish authorities. Recourse was also had to the following expedient, which seemed to be afforded by the peculiar form of mortgages in Turkish law: the formal owner, whose name appears in the land register and cadastre, constitutes in favour of the real purchaser a mortgage for a sum far exceeding the value of the landed property in question. Under Turkish law the mortgaging is effected in the form of a conditional sale, and the creditor, whether the encumbrance on the land be real or fictitious, can carry out the sale only if a special power of attorney, Wekialet-i-devrié, is at the same time delivered by the debtor to him or to a third party, granting authority to sell the land when the debt falls due. With this, as indeed already through the mortgaging itself, the debtor has of course given up a right of disposal over the pledged land, and a right of disposal on the part of the creditor comes into force on the lapse of the term of payment. But if the debtor has died in the meantime, the power of attorney is extinguished and the mortgage annulled. The creditor, be he a real or a formal one, can demand payment of the debt first from the movable and, if need be, the immovable Müll property, and only for the deficit hold himself to a part of the pledged Miri land up to the amount required to cover it. If, however, there are no heirs, he stands face to face with the Fiscus, to which the land must fall as Kaduk mahlul, and that in itself is already an unedifying situation. One sees, therefore, that this expedient too affords no security.
If a private person makes acquisitions in such a way that, trusting in the probity and in the fortune of another, he has his property entered in that other's name, he may certainly do so. To be sure, he must also see to it that this other has legal heirs in the sense of Turkish law, and must also be convinced that these heirs will be just as honest as their father was, But what a private person does and leaves undone with his property is his own affair. He may, to make use of a Talmudic turn of phrase, keep his moneys in the antlers of a stag . . . . But the administrators of a national property, which is made up of the kreuzers and sacrifices of even the poorest, and which may rightly be called orphans' money, have no right to place trust in a person and his heirs, since they cannot know whether the heirs even of the most pious and most national Jew will in turn be Jews too, and whether, as non-Jews, they will keep the obligations entered into by their father, honestly transfer the properties in question to other trustees, and not rather regard them as a good prize.
Nor is it to be overlooked that in the case of a national possession one had to have in view not merely a period of first heirs, but must possibly look ahead for a period of several generations.
But who would be able to do that?
What? The statute of the National Fund has permitted its administrators, as the élite of the nation, whose heart and reins have been tried, the disposal and the exact application to the desired purpose only under onerous safeguards and stipulations, and these curators could venture to entrust individual portions of this sevenfold-guarded property to any Tom, Dick or Harry, where no guarantees whatever appear to be given that it might not after all somehow be lost through breach of trust or through misfortunes befalling the nominee in question? I know from one of my clients, a certain Mordechai Mendilsohn of Beyruth, of the case in which he, together with two others, had bought a fairly large estate, I believe Sedschera too, which was entered in the land register in the name of one of the three partners, or else the title-deeds to the parts of the estate not yet transferred in the register were in the hands of one of the partners. This man went and ran it into debt and finally sold it to the "Ica", which regarded him alone as the person entitled. As he had meanwhile died, the
