Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 29 · 21 July 1905
17printed page
scan 17 of 38
Facsimile · scan 17 of 38
Scan of p. 17
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 29. — "Die Welt" — Page 17.

(continued from page 16)

…schools, but there are Russian monasteries. We open banks, but there is a Deutsche Bank. There are non-Jewish railways, French and Italian steamships and British capital. If we wish to win Palestine by an industrial campaign, what hope have we of holding our own in competition against the other companies, behind whose backs stand such mighty governments? Above all when the Sultan not only refuses to concede Jewish autonomy, but will not even hear of a Jewish immigration. Do you think, my friends, that I could not forge fine phrases like the others about the land of our fathers, about not turning to the right or to the left? Do you think that I could not maliciously attack Mr. Greenberg for seduction? Do you think that I cannot dance and sing? These things are easy, but they make nothing easier. Where it is difficult, there is something to be done. We have already had a congress in Palestine under the presidency of the fiery Ussischkin. But what result did it have? What progress did our cause make by it? By a large majority women were excluded from the work! This is what you may live to see in Palestine under the regime of the pure Palestinians.

Back to the Basle Programme.

It is easy to see that they could not win many over to the exclusion of other countries besides Palestine from the sphere of their operations. For whither would such a step lead? Since Palestine proper can receive only a minority of our people, we should be cut off for ever from all expansion, even in the event of success. For not only Mesopotamia and the Sinai Peninsula and the countries neighbouring Palestine must remain open to our operations; no soil and no method may be closed to us. We do not wish to see the Basle Programme narrowed. We do not wish our funds to be shut up. For if the adherents of small colonisation come to power at the Congress, the future of Zionism will look like the present of the "Ica". Once a year we shall publish a report — 180 cows here and 416 brood-hens there, and so forth. We shall make fine speeches, sing and dance, and then go back home. The other policy, however, is best indicated in the report of Mr. Wilbusch: "Leave Berlin by the Basle express. Arrived at Basle. On to East Africa. Leave East Africa. Arrived in Palestine."

In Ussischkin's pamphlet is laid down the programme for the acquisition of Palestine inch by inch. In place of Doctor Herzl's great diplomatic method, every man is to become his own diplomatist. A chaos of chattering, bargaining, intriguing and plotting; through a countless number of holes Israel is to creep back into its land. But we do not wish to creep; that we have done enough already. We wish to march in with banners flying and our faces turned towards heaven. For thus it is written in our prayer-book: "He will cast the yoke of exile from off our neck and lead us with uplifted head into our land."

* * *

Mrs. Zangwill's Speech.

"And Moses sent them to spy out the land of Canaan, and said unto them: Get you up southward, and go up into the mountain."

And they returned from searching of the land after forty days."

"And they brought up unto the children of Israel an evil and false report of the land which they had searched, saying: The land, through which we have gone to search it, is a land that eateth up the inhabitants thereof."

"And the Eternal said unto Moses: How long will this people provoke me? How long will it be ere they believe me, for all the signs which I have shewed among them?"

These verses, or the first three of them, may fairly summarise the East Africa Blue Book. The verdict of that ancient commission bears a striking resemblance to the present report. Of the twelve men whom Moses sent southward to spy out the land, only two returned with a favourable account. The East Africa expedition numbered only three members; of these only Major Gibbons is more than half favourable to the matter, whereby the same proportion is obtained — one-sixth. When I say of Major Gibbons that he is only half favourable, I believe I am understating the case. I heard him say in private conversation that he would be ready to begin something in East Africa on his own initiative in the event that the Jews should reject the project. I think one needs no more favourable verdict than that. Truly, what is discouraging in our verdict is not that it casts a bad light upon East Africa, but that it casts one upon the Jews. One feels that even if the land offered literally flowed with milk and honey, the Jews would still find something to murmur at — the slipperiness of the soil and the costliness of the drainage. The Jew is so busy looking the gift horse in the mouth that he forgets not only that it is a gift, but also that it is a horse.

There are certainly serious objections that may be raised against the proposed territory. It is said to be too small to bring a final solution of the Jewish Question. This, however, is a reproach they have manufactured themselves. Had they been powerful and united at the outset, the English Government would doubtless have granted them a larger territory. Even now it would be foolish to reject what is offered on the ground that we could get no more. If you offer a ragged boy a suit of clothes, he will not refuse it because in a couple of years he will have outgrown it and will need another suit. The Guas Ngishu Plateau would suit us quite well now; perhaps even better than a larger territory. A people that has possessed no land for 2000 years is a child in the matter of self-government, and has no need of a large territory either. A rabbinical legend relates that during the forty years' wandering in the wilderness the garments grew together with the children. Perhaps the plateau will display a like elasticity. Be that as it may, in East Africa the Jew would receive a lesson in colonisation and administration. What is more important still is the moral centre that would be offered to Jewry in a Jewish State, however small it might be. The plateau would be a beginning, never an end. For in the future, I hope, the Jew will inhabit his own land, with none above him — save God.

The greatest objection that can be raised against Uganda is not the lack of area, but that it is not Palestine. Certainly it is not Palestine; it is twice as fertile. I should like to remark on this occasion, moreover, that Palestine proper is smaller than the plateau. Palestine itself would not be able to solve the Jewish Question either; it could only be a beginning. But what must not be forgotten, in weighing the question of East Africa against Palestine, is that we have no choice, since Palestine has not yet been offered to us for the present. When that happens, we shall still have time enough to give up Uganda. We have a Zionist flag, which fluttered at St. Louis among the flags of all nations, although it does not yet wave over the Temple; we have a Zionist parliament, which will be convened next month at Basle, although it cannot yet be held in Jerusalem. Why should we not also have a Zionist State, although we cannot set it up in Palestine?

But even when people see that, they still have something to find fault with. They maintain, namely, that with East Africa and Palestine Zionism would fall between two stools. They forget, however, that Palestine and East Africa are to be represented as two stools of different heights. Pales-