Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 29 · 21 July 1905
15printed page
scan 15 of 38

No. 29 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 15

(continued from page 14)

…rience learn? Why not gather this whole divided immigration into one great centre and there found a Jewish settlement with self-government? Why does political autonomy so frighten the "Ica," Lucien Wolf and the sober English Jews? It is a simple confusion. They feel in a vague way that their position in Europe is threatened. At present their position has reached a height to which they have not been able to climb since the fall of Jerusalem. Two hundred and fifty years ago they were told that nothing stood in the way of their immigration into England, and they came in; now they are offered a British territory, and they run away. I can imagine no finer celebration of our 250 years' settlement in England than the acceptance of England's generous offer. The offer was made not to the English, but to the Russian and Roumanian Jews, who have no rights at all. How dare we presume to reject such an offer so long as we have nothing better to offer them? I am quite sure that England would improve the offer if we were united. But is the territory really so black as it is painted to us? Let us look at it a little.

Criticism of the East Africa Commission.

The report of Major Gibbons is fairly favourable, that of Prof. Kaiser middling, but that of Mr. Wilbusch wholly unfavourable. So unfavourable that Major Gibbons finds it necessary to declare him ignorant. But Wilbusch is not so ignorant so long as he keeps to his own subject, hydraulics. He has valuable information about the volume and the speed of the rivers. Only when he begins to deal with problems of colonisation does he speak like a town child who is surprised when it first learns that loaves of bread derive their origin from a little grain, that the roads were not laid by Nature, and that the milestones do not spring up in the primeval forest. A commission needs a man of science; unfortunately Mr. Wilbusch is only a Zionist. His last word is: "Where there is nothing, nothing can be done!" What nonsense! Land and water exist, and where these exist everything can be done. All the more so where they are joined with a healthy climate. Mr. Kaiser and Major Gibbons are agreed that, considered hygienically, the country is a paradise. Now I turned to Wilbusch in the expectation that he would describe it as unhealthy. And sure enough he says: "Although I personally have not had to suffer, these enormous fluctuations of temperature hardly seem to me to be very healthy." Truly, Mr. Wilbusch's love for Palestine is so great that it leads him into the wildest under-estimation of Uganda. Thus he writes in his diary under the 11th of February: "Territory: first 4–5 miles fairly good pasture grass, last 9 miles middling, poor pasture; short, drying grass; no trace of water and wood. Numerous antelopes everywhere. Camp by a brook which ends in a swamp and has scattered bushes on its banks. Last mile deserted stone kraals, but no people." Can there be anything sadder? No wood, no water, no people, nothing at all. But let us examine the description somewhat more closely. No water — yet Mr. Wilbusch camps beside a river. No wood — yet bushes, which doubtless served him as fuel for his camp-fire. No raw material of any kind — yet numerous antelopes, of whose horns and hides manufacture has always made the most ample use, to say nothing of their flesh. No people — but that is just what we want. The stone kraals prove that men have lived there and could live there. But Mr. Wilbusch repeats again and again, gloomily: "Not a single human being seen." I imagine how joyfully he would have reported, had he travelled through Palestine: "I saw half a million Arabs." For that, alas, is the number of those who rival us for the possession of Palestine. The East African territory is open to development without opposition and under our own laws. That was always the great attraction inherent in this project.

Beware of Snails.

Far more scientific is the report of Mr. Kaiser. But he too exceeded his instructions. He was commissioned to report upon the fitness of the territory for a white settlement, but he sets forth his views upon a Jewish settlement and even takes into consideration such absurdities as, say, the antisemitic feelings of the few East African farmers. He is so carefully at pains to draw attention to the disadvantages of Uganda that he even points out the damage which the snails might possibly do. As if an English garden were free from snails and other noxious little creatures. If the Jews are still to take snails into account, they will never reach Palestine, even if they go at a snail's pace. All Australia was ravaged by the moths, and yet Australia flourishes. The caterpillars too alarm Mr. Kaiser greatly. But in Victoria it is a common occurrence in summer for the caterpillars to cover the railway line so thickly with their fat bodies that the trains cannot run. And yet the Victorians have not yet capitulated to the caterpillars. Still more comical does Mr. Kaiser appear when he declares that the freight charges on exports would never be reduced. Surely the shipowners will have to adapt their tariffs to the new conditions. Mr. Kaiser further relates that "all these ships, which call at the port of Mombasa once a month on the outward voyage and once on the homeward voyage, go partly empty and have no great prospects of better times." The ships would have better times precisely if one were willing to employ Jewish capital and Jewish labour in this territory. What do you think — would it pay better to take lower rates, or to let the ships run to and fro partly empty? The misfortune with Messrs. Kaiser and Wilbusch is that they possess no imagination. They can see only the raw present, but are incapable of looking into the ripe future. They are full of the fear and the irresolution of a paralysed race.

The Possibilities of the Guas Ngischu Plateau.

Quite different is the tenor of the report of Major Gibbons, with his Anglo-Saxon spirit of enterprise. But his report too is more a geographical sketch than an agricultural document. None of the three members of the expedition, despite the valuable information they have amassed, has told us enough about the soil, its constituents, its depth. What proportion is granite rock and therefore barren, and what is made fertile by