Page 16 — "Die Welt" — No. 29
(continued from page 15)
…the decomposition of volcanic rocks? The possibility of growing costly products such as coffee, cotton and wool, or of breeding horses for export, receives no consideration. No report on the rainfall, and the temperature not measured at any one base. Major Gibbons thinks there are no mosquitoes there, but he forgets that he was there at the end of the dry season and that the mosquitoes come with the rain. He at least did not go looking for disadvantages, like Mr. Wilbusch, who doubtless told himself that if the cattle starved during the dry season, they must surely drown during the rainy season. I imagine what more he would have said had he met with mosquitoes there. And yet in the English village where I am spending this summer I have had to furnish the windows with mosquito curtains. A large part of the plateau is described as treeless; but if the soil is good, that is surely only a product of the winds, which have so far given the wild trees no opportunity of an attempt. Plant a long row of trees protected by a wall of shrubs, and you will soon get trees. The territory is further described as grazing land, but the transition from a pastoral country to an agricultural state is only a question of application. This year I lived for some months in Florida, which, once abandoned to swamps and crocodiles, is now rapidly developing into a prosperous State. I can imagine what our Jewish commissioners would have said had they been sent there a century ago. Yes, even Australia was condemned at the outset. When Lieutenant Collins, the captain of the "Calcutta," who was sent out to Australia with a small fleet of convict transports whose inmates were to be settled there, landed at a spot 36 miles distant from Melbourne, he reported that this territory must be left for ever to the kangaroos, which alone were capable of finding a living there, and he moved the planned settlement to Tasmania. Now Melbourne numbers over 500,000 inhabitants.
A country which is now remote from civilisation may within a generation become its hearth. What means are there for a people without a land to obtain one? There are only two possibilities. Either it must get a developed country or — an undeveloped one. But developed countries are populated, and if one wishes to have them one must drive out the inhabitants with weapons in hand. But if one cannot take the path of war, one must go the way of peace. If one cannot wage war against men, one must direct it against Nature. We must have a new place far from civilisation and build up a new civilisation there. If we do not do so, we must either vanish among the nations or remain for ever a lost and wandering people.
The Failed B. A.
A young Hindu once had printed on his visiting-card, in the place where one is accustomed to put one's profession, "Failed B. A." He had not passed the examination, and thought it honour enough that he had made the attempt. The greatest deed that Zionism has hitherto accomplished is the offer of the British Government, and if we now reject it, I seriously fear that we shall have to wait many, many years before we may boast of anything else — except, of course, the fact that we rejected what was offered. "Rejected O. A." will be the proudest title of our movement, and this Blue Book, which we owe solely and entirely to the untiring zeal of Mr. Greenberg, will remain our only official document. There is a Jewish proverb: One must not pour out the unclean water before one has clean.
The Palestine Question.
What are our prospects of Palestine? In my opinion Palestine is out of all question before we receive an increase in men and means. We have struggled for over eight years, and it is clear that our forces are not sufficient. If we will not work upon a territory, we must wait for a long time and merely gather our forces — without the consolation of a territory. Work in Palestine is fatal — fatal for political Zionism, which prescribes for us work only upon a territory where we have Self-Gouvernment; fatal for our funds, which would trickle away in small experiments. Mr. Warburg, another of the new leaders, recommends us to buy land in Palestine, to plant oranges and almonds, forests and olive-trees, to irrigate and till the soil, etc., etc. But to what end? To enrich the Sultan? If I own an empty piece of land and labourers are so good as to till it, why should I pay them? For what reason grant them rights? If they are so stupid as to work for me, they are welcome. Mr. Ussischkin tells us that "every inch of soil that is bought in the Land of Israel, and every Jew who settles in the Holy Land, etc., forms the foundation-stone for the upbuilding of our whole people." Well, if that is so, it would surely be the duty of Mr. Ussischkin and of all the Zionists who think as he does to pack their bundles and hasten to Palestine. If they do not do so, we shall know what value to set upon their sincerity. They raise their right hand never to forget Palestine; but why do they not raise their right foot — to march? They maintain, however, that they can serve the cause better outside Palestine. But that is just the very reason why we are so much in favour of a territory.
Our departed leader somewhat under-estimated the period of time necessary for the resurrection of the Jewish State. But one could foresee its realisation, however distant it might be, if only the beginning were rightly made and its development provided for. Let it take time, if only it is sure. But there are things which remain uncertain in spite of all waiting. If you set the tortoise on the right road, it will at last reach the goal. But if at the beginning it takes a wrong road, its patient crawling will only carry it ever farther from the goal. If the little bird visits the granite block a mile broad and a mile high once in three hundred years and pecks off a little piece with its beak, it will one day be finished with its work. But if this block is watched over by a Russian bear, a German eagle or a Turkish hawk, I fear that the little bird could visit it only once. We found colonies in Palestine, but the Christians found them too. We build