Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 29 · 21 July 1905
12printed page
scan 12 of 38
Facsimile · scan 12 of 38
Scan of p. 12
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 12 — "Die Welt" — No. 29

(continued from page 11)

…friends the Jews have ever had, stamped. From a long conversation which I had with him last December, I learnt that he would most zealously have supported a Concert of the Powers for the solution of the Jewish question. He even permitted me to make known his view that participation in the Zionist movement would under no circumstances impair the reputation of the American Jews as patriots.

At a time of such affliction and loss for Zionism, a strange shout of jubilation rings out in our camp. At the American Zionist Convention which has just been held in Philadelphia, there were scenes of enthusiasm, jubilation, singing and dancing that are indescribable. What is the matter? Peace has come! The Actions Committee has rejected the East Africa project. Our brethren in America had not yet so much as read the report of the Commission, but that was of no consequence — peace reigned. A peace at any price. A peace without progress. The old motto ran: "All is lost save honour." Ours is to be: "All is lost, save peace." Mr. Wolffsohn*), one of our new leaders, confesses that he could not breathe freely until the Uganda project was rejected. It is the same man who, when it was first proposed, said "Sche Hechejonu." Now he sings "Scheprotani." "Blessed be He who has freed me from this burden!"

A great opportunity has been lost to the Jewish people. We are still outside the gates of Palestine, but that does not matter; we have Schalom. And the American Conference rejoices and dances for joy, and our leaders pronounce the "Schepotrani" blessing.

The Peace — No Healthy Peace.

But does peace really reign? No. The cover of this Blue Book bears a Zionist emblem and the inscription: "Zionism strives to create for the Jewish people a home in Palestine secured by public law." The Blue Book, however, treats only of East Africa. Zionism thereby admits that the East Africa project belongs within the legitimate sphere of its operations. Mr. Wolffsohn said last month at the Shekel Day meeting in London that the obtaining of the East Africa offer had been Herzl's greatest creation, since by this offer the English Government had sanctioned the Zionist principle. Yes, but at the same time the Zionist principle had recognised the English Government. The Actions Committee itself, in the resolution rejecting the Uganda project, admits that Zionism had the possibility of accepting it, for the resolution says: "The Committee, having examined the report of the East Africa Commission, etc." Why, what right had it to examine the report if it was not entitled to accept the offer? The A.-C. and all those pure Palestinians who are so fond of speaking of the worthlessness of Uganda behaved like that rabbi who, having already begun to eat his dinner, exclaimed: "Take this trefa roast away from me — it is too tough!"

I think, however, that the roast, tough as it may be, is kosher, and will be more welcome to a hungry man than no meat at all, inasmuch as it will strengthen him to reach his final goal. And even were it admitted that this roast is uneatable, is it then out of the question to obtain a savoury morsel? So long as it is not yet established that the Uganda project is to be rejected because it is trefa or because it is uneatable, there can be no true peace.

The one party cries: "Only Palestine," and would devote all means to this corner of the earth alone; the other believes that a territory with autonomous rights would bring us much nearer to the acquisition of Palestine than the founding of small colonies in Palestine itself. If now a third party has arisen, the Territorialists, who are for the founding of a Jewish State in any country whatever, the fanatical Palestinians alone are to blame for it. Their zealot narrow-mindedness has called forth this reaction. A small example: Mr. Ussischkin, their chief, sent me his little work entitled "Our Programme" with the dedication: "From Ussichkin, the Zionist, to Zangwill, the Territorialist" — at a time when I did not yet know Territorialism even by name. I believed, and still believe, that we feel no need for sects and factions. If the Territorialists were in a position to found a Jewish State, it would be the best thing for the pure Palestinians, for in the Jewish State a centre of power would be offered them for their endeavours. Only compare the power to help the Zionist cause possessed by the Jews in New York with that of the Jews in Palestine or even in Russia. The greater the freedom of the Jews, the greater the influence they can exert upon affairs. At the very worst: what harm would Zionism suffer if the Jewish flag, dishonoured for nineteen centuries, could wave again upon Jewish soil? What a wonderful moral uplift it would call forth, were it hoisted even upon a barren rock!

A Jewish Hall of Fame.

But now we possess nothing — nothing. You have perhaps heard of the Jewish sculptor Galizenstein, who lives in Rome and whose latest work was recently purchased by the King of Italy for his palace in the Quirinal. This sculptor, who is a Zionist, worked for some years on a colossal figure representing the genius of our people, asleep, but holding a shofar in his hand and ready at any moment to blow the call of resurrection. This monumental work is to be dedicated to the Zionists in eternal memory of Herzl, and the artist asked me to indicate to him a Jewish national building where it might be housed. I replied to him that we, alas, possess no such building. With all the millionaires we have in masses in every country, we possess not a single place, not a single building, that belongs to the whole of Jewry and in which we could preserve such a national treasure. The best I could advise him was to place a cast of the figure in one of the back rooms of the Basle Casino. But even the Basle Casino is our national building for only one week. Can you not the necessity of a


*) Mr. Zangwill was in error here, for it was not Mr. Woffsohn but a member of the Russian A.-C., as the chairman, Mr. L. J. Greenberg, pointed out to him. (Translator's note.)