No. 28 — "Die Welt" — Page 5
(continued from page 4)
…if not actually encouraged, butcheries and exterminations in Russia and other lands, simply be swept away as dangerous dreamers. Why, then, the struggle over principle? Men who think politically and wish to be politically active ought surely not to remind us of the young married couple in the play who quarrel over the question of principle whether the children they expect are to be treated coldly or warmly, at a time when there is not the slightest prospect of the arrival of the offspring to be brought up. Do the gentlemen Territorialists of the Geneva or the Warsaw persuasion really lack nothing more for the realisation of their idea than release from the Basle Programme, or even the demolition of that programme? Have they everything else already: the suitable territory, the consent and guarantee of the government that rules it, the means required for the purpose, and the human material, which last two will still be the easiest to find, and does nothing more stand in their way to rescue and felicity than the question of principle? It is, as shown above, simply not true that the Basle Programme stands in the way of any relief action, least of all one so comprehensive! To carry a principle through without there being any reality before it to which it is to be applied belongs, no doubt, in a seminary or a Beth-Hamidrasch, but not in a body called to deliberate upon great public affairs, such as the Congress is. The adoption of Territorialism as a programme would appear to many as political windbaggery. In truth and in fact, however, it would level the ground for political adventures. Over this, serious men cannot and must not quarrel.
But it is said, in a passing phrase, that "all hope is lost for the foreseeable future," and from this some derived the necessity of striding boldly backwards to the old Chowewe-Zionism, and others the necessity of seeking another territory altogether. Both tendencies saw in it the impossibility of obtaining the Charter for the span of a whole generation. I, however, go further; I say the Charter will never be obtained. I mean, that is, the fully grown Charter as it appears to present itself in the imagination of many who are inclined to believe that we still live in the age of miracles. Unhappily, a remark of mine on this subject, that a State cannot be cut out of a piece of cloth like a garment, but must develop and grow organically, led to a misunderstanding and to an ill feeling whose removal required a good deal of time and loyal explanation.
On the other hand, I am convinced that a Charter coming into being slowly and naturally is beyond doubt attainable. There are great tracts of land, probably more in Syria than in Palestine, which Turkey would gladly make over to a land company appearing with large means, for cultivation and colonisation, together with the necessary rights of road-building and water use, if the colonists would adopt Ottoman citizenship and would not run to the consuls of foreign Powers upon every proper and improper occasion and cause Turkey nothing but inconvenience, and if, further, the actual creation by industry and enterprise of sources of wealth useful to Turkey as well, because they increase the taxes, were held out in demonstrable fashion. In such a case, and given a loyal attitude on the part of the immigrants, who would certainly not otherwise be prevented from living after their own fashion, it would also quite certainly be attainable to obtain certain concessions with regard to the collection of taxes, whether by farming or by fixed lump sums, and thus to be withdrawn from the dreaded pressure of taxation at the hands of unsalaried officials. Such a colonisation would already contain within itself the most necessary beginnings of a Charter, and, with constant watchfulness that confidence in the loyalty of the colonists be strengthened, must gradually perfect itself and redound to the blessing of both honest contracting parties. Whoever knows the Turk and Turkey knows only too well that it is hard and goes very slowly to obtain a binding promise from them, but that the sanctity of the given word and of the concluded treaty stands there almost higher than among all the other peoples who parade their culture.
Here, then, is where the lever must be applied, and our chief activity must be directed towards carrying such a project through at the Jildiz.
Political activity with the other Powers would have to confine itself to winning their goodwill, in the sense that they should not become a hindrance but, on the contrary, a help so far as possible, since for them too a political advantage results from it through the relief of many districts overcrowded with Jews, an advantage they will know how to appreciate.
Thus, not "small concessions in proportion to the forces available," as is recommended in the programme of a number of associations, because this would of necessity mean only a splintering and an absorption of forces and means through petty successes, and the small concessions would demand disproportionately greater sacrifices than a single great one that would comprise all the others. But neither the fanciful, rapid taking possession of the land, such as a colleague of the old school of infiltration so picturesquely sketched in "Unser Programm," assigning their functions to the several Jewish organisations, such as the Ica, the Rotschild administration and the Jewish National Fund, and to the last even the destiny of being squandered upon barren and dead tracts; because, first, the factors mentioned would not be found willing to undertake such programmatic work, and because, secondly, this work would be conceived without any rights at all and would therefore be worthless, a house of cards that would collapse at the slightest rough breath and bury beneath its ruins a vast number of livelihoods and, with them, the hope of Israel.
Political Zionism can only begin an enterprise on a large scale, and that not stealthily and in the darkness of night, but in the light of the sun and of publicity. Beginnings and tracks commanding respect are indeed there, but they are still insufficient.
As for war, so for this work of peace there is needed money, money, and again money. The more we strengthen the Colonial Bank, the more we collect for the National Fund and bring it to an imposing figure, the better these institutions will be able to call such a land company into being and to it, as powerful participants, ac-
