Page 10 — "Die Welt" — No. 25
(continued from page 9)
…promising for the future is above all the systematic introduction of carpet-knotting into Palestine, as well as of various small home industries.
In order to begin the work and to carry it on for three years, about 40 000 Marks are required, according to careful calculation, and there is good reason to expect that a considerable part of this sum will be contributed by societies once we have a larger fund together. In the event of success, the work will after three years either be able to maintain itself, possibly with regular subsidies from the societies, or it will be carried on along commercial lines with the help of the workers trained by then, for which purpose the Palästina-Handelsgesellschaft in Hamburg and the Anglo-Palestine-Co. in Jaffa and Jerusalem have already promised their co-operation.
For everyone who unites Jewish interest with social understanding, a fine opportunity for useful work is here offered. It is not to be an alms, given with averted gaze to relieve a passing need; rather, a vigorous organisation is to arise which shall unfold from within itself the forces of healthy growth, an organisation under whose shelter thousands, and it is to be hoped tens of thousands, may within a short time rise from useless beggars to free citizens morally elevated by work. To give the first help here is a duty and should be a joy.
Jacob Alexander, Hamburg; Prof. Badt, Breslau; Privy Councillor M. Barschall, Berlin; Siegm. Bergel, Berlin; Jonas Bing, Hamburg; Advocate Dr. Blau, Frankfort-on-Main; Justizrat Oscar Cassel, Berlin; Gustav G. Cohen, Hamburg; Justizrat Dr. H. Meyer Cohn, Berlin; Privy Councillor Prof. H. Cohen, Marburg; Director M. Dorn, Berlin; Chief Rabbi Dr. Ehrenpreis Sofia; Dr. D. Feitelberg, Berlin; Senator Leopold Fischer, Hanover; Sally Floersheim, Dortmund; J. Freymark, Berlin; Prof. F. Gernsheim, Berlin; Landrabbiner Dr. S. Gronemann, Hanover; Rabbi Dr. Guttmann, Breslau; Manufacturer S. Hepner, Charlottenburg; Sanitätsrat Dr. Hessberg, Essen; Dr. Hirsch Hildesheimer, Berlin; J. S. Hirschland, Essen; Rabbi Dr. Horowitz, Frankfort-on-Main; Berthold Israel, Berlin; Jozef Israels, The Hague; Dr. A. Klee, Berlin; J. Kremenetzky, Vienna; Kirchenrat Dr. Kroner, Stuttgart; Prof. L. Landau, Berlin; Rabbi Dr. Leimdörfer, Hamburg; Prof. L. Lewin, Berlin; Director P. Lewy, firm of Gladenbeck, Berlin; Prof. Max Liebermann, Berlin; E. M. Lilien, Berlin; Consul Litten, Koenigsberg in Prussia; Willibald Loewenthal, Berlin; Ludwig Mathiason, Hamburg; Dr. E. Mittwoch, Berlin; Dr. Franz Oppenheimer, Berlin; Director Dr. Pakscher, Dresden; Simon Pfeffer, Breslau; Prof. M. Philippson, Charlottenburg; Rabbi Dr. Porges, Leipzig; Sartorius Reinhold, Hanover; Fritz M. Rosenthal, firm of Rosenthal & Tobias, Berlin; Rabbi Dr. Rosenthal, Breslau; Rabbi Dr. L. Rosenthal, Cologne; Town Councillor Salomonsohn, Hohensalza; Rabbi Dr. Ad. Salvendi, Dürkheim; Prof. Boris Schatz, Sofia; Dr. P. Schotlaender, landed proprietor, Breslau; Manufacturer Dr. Ernst Schwerin, Breslau; Dr. S. Soskin, Charlottenburg; Isidore Spielmann, London; Hermann Struck, Berlin; Gustav Tuch, Hamburg; Rabbi Dr. Vogelstein, Stettin; Moritz Warburg, firm of M. M. Warburg, Hamburg; Prof. O. Warburg, Charlottenburg; Emil Wassermann, Bamberg; Rabbi Dr. Werner, Munich; Joseph Wisloch, Frankfort-on-Main; Director Dr. Wolffsohn, Cologne; Dr. Th. Zlocisti, Berlin.
Contributions, marked "Bezalel", are to be sent to the banking house of Meyer Cohn, Berlin W., Unter den Linden 11.
Dr. Soskin on Palestine.
Israel Zangwill writes to us:
In his second attempt to correct my figures, Dr. Soskin throws some light on the differences that have arisen between him and me, inasmuch as it turns out that the translator of my article wrote square kilometres in error instead of square miles. Thus, whereas I gave the area of the East African territory as 5000 square miles, "Die Welt" said 5000 square kilometres — instead of some 13 000 square kilometres. But Dr. Soskin did not feel obliged to correct this. Likewise, in the translation of one passage my answer was not rendered quite precisely, for I naturally did not say that Palestine, even were it ten times as large as it is, could hold only three million inhabitants; I said rather that I wished Palestine were ten times as large even as Dr. Soskin estimates it, and it could nevertheless hold no more than three million inhabitants (and accordingly could not solve the Jewish question).
Apart from these misunderstandings, Dr. Soskin was able to establish only one simple error. Relying on the authority of Ussishkin (and of Dr. Herzl, who often expressed himself to me in this sense), I remarked that the crown lands of Palestine could be purchased. Dr. Soskin now thinks that the Sultan would not sell them. If Dr. Soskin is right, then the difficulties of obtaining Palestine are even greater than I feared. All the remaining difficulties which we Zionists have to overcome stand uncorrected, just as I set them forth. According to Dr. Soskin, Palestine is thinly inhabited. Yet he himself assumes 18 souls to the square kilometre, which makes over 46 to the (English) square mile. That, of course, is not very dense. But the density of population of European Russia, too, amounts to only 42 souls to the square mile. And I never said that Palestine was densely settled, but only that an "alien question" (Alien Problem) awaits us there: inhabitants whom we should have either to displace or to rule. By Dr. Soskin's own reckoning only 12.5 per cent. of the population are Jews, so that seven-eighths of the 650 000 inhabitants, that is, no fewer than 568 760 non-Jews, would have to be absorbed by the Jewish commonwealth.
But that I represented these difficulties as "insuperable" springs solely from Dr. Soskin's imagination. On the contrary, he will find in No. 17 of "Die Welt" that, having stated the difficulties, I also endeavoured to find their solution. By way of example, a sentence which gives the difficulty and the solution without even a separating comma: "The difficulty lies in the non-Jewish population and the solution of the question lies perhaps in the extension of our idea of Palestine to its still desert neighbouring lands." Now Dr. Soskin says that it is the tone that makes the music. But Dr. Soskin's tone is singularly unjustified when it is noted that my brief statement of the difficulties was preceded by incomparably longer passages pleading the cause of Palestine, which ended as follows: Situated on the coast of the Mediterranean, in the centre of the ancient world, this land of ruins still has a future before it and it awaits its resurrection, and it would be an infinite pity if the future of this land were not bound up with the future and with the resurrection of the people that has yearned after it for so many centuries."
Israel Zangwill.
Letters from Palestine.
Jaffa, 4th Sivan 5665.
In the year 1904 various goods to the amount of Fres. 13 723 800 were exported from the port of Jaffa, while the imports amounted to Frcs. 11 360 520, so that the exports show a surplus of Frcs. 2 363 280, a figure which is to be regarded as favourable for the development of trade in Palestine. Unhappily the Jews have but a small share in this favourable development of the sea-borne trade, since they occupy themselves exclusively with petty trade in the interior of the country. The chief exports were: wheat, barley, poppy-seed, beans, oranges, wine, cognac, soap, hides, wool, dried fruit, honey, almonds, olive-wood, oil, etc.; the imports extended
