Page 4 — "Die Welt" — No. 19
(continued from page 3)
…ating and taking resolutions which should strive for a change in the situation of the Jews by their own strength and labour.
And then the incredible happened: the Munich Jewish Community — mark well, not the more or less philosemitic Town or Municipal Council, not strangers, but members of the Jewish people, a corporation whose task it is to guard and represent the interests of Jewry — protested against the choice of Munich as the place of the Congress, and thereby brought upon this Jewish community a disgrace which still awaits its effacement.
The initiators of the Zionist movement thereupon resolved to convene the Congress in Switzerland, the traditional land of political freedom and freedom of thought.
It is true that in this country, a few years before, tradition had been broken with regard to the Jews, in that their right to live according to their religious precepts and views had been restricted, whether for doctrinaire or for directly anti-Jewish reasons. We Jews are accustomed by the practice of thousands of years to endurance, to the bearing of restrictions and oppressions. But where was there, and where is there, a country that could be regarded as friendly to the Jews, or at least as decidedly not hostile to them? Of one thing we believed we could be sure in Basle: that free Swiss citizens would never, even when hostilely disposed, let themselves be led into disturbing manifestations of free opinion by force and making our assembly impossible. Equally, however, we had become convinced that our kinsmen and co-religionists in Basle, even if at first they had not yet grasped our idea and were not yet Zionists, would nevertheless not reject the assembly in their city, still less thwart it in brusque fashion. The facts did not disappoint our expectations in either direction. The same Swiss citizens who had resolved upon the prohibition of ritual slaughter had, in their love of freedom, full understanding for the tragedy of the Jewish question. Not only did they not disturb our deliberations by hostilities, but they followed them with sympathy, and in Basle there rang out a cry which no Jew had probably ever yet heard from Christian lips: "Long live the Jews!"
The Government and the authorities of the Canton and City of Basle did everything possible to further our deliberations, and this sympathy increased from Congress to Congress. The Jewish population of Basle entered our ranks in troops, to work side by side with us at the great task we have set ourselves.
The Jews who streamed together from all the world — and among them not merely those into whose faces the insult is flung elsewhere that one would not otherwise have recognised them as Jews, but also Jews who as such are certainly not to be mistaken, the poor Ghetto Jews — were all received alike in friendly fashion beside the Jewish intelligentsia, and between the two races there developed bonds of true friendship and respect, which were knit more firmly with each new Congress and must fill us with deep gratitude towards the city of Basle and its inhabitants.
Now a new Congress is coming, and you demand in the name of the Jewish feeling of solidarity and honour that we should leave "antisemitic Switzerland and the antisemitic city of Basle" and seek out another city. You advise us, esteemed Herr Doctor, to go to Belgium, Holland or England. Is the prohibition of ritual slaughter then the sole criterion of antisemitism? Is Germany not antisemitic because it has not yet introduced the prohibition of ritual slaughter? Or are we to go to England, where we might perhaps run the risk that, through the recently adopted Aliens Bill, entry might be made difficult for many a one of our delegates as an "undesirable immigrant"? And are there in Belgium and Holland no antisemitic newspapers, professors, deputies and other plain manifestations of antisemitism?
Since there is unfortunately no country that offers more guarantees for the security of the free sitting of the Congress than Switzerland, the Greater Actions Committee of our movement, despite the prohibition of ritual slaughter — which certainly touches us, too, very painfully — and despite many other no less serious expressions of the racial antagonism that unhappily comes to light everywhere, has decided to retain Basle as the place of the Congress.
Two considerations in particular led us to this resolution: Basle is a place of historical significance for Zionists and Zionism. In Basle Herzl for the first time set forth the situation of Jewry before all the world without any retouching, and, in the name of numerous like-minded men, in words that should never be forgotten, addressed to the whole of Jewry an appeal for union and for systematic self-help. It is for us Zionists an act of piety to hold the first Congress without Herzl — the leader idolised and beloved by his followers — once more at the place from which he so often addressed his inspired and inspiring words to us; at the same place his successor is also to be elected and the new era for Zionism inaugurated.
Most highly esteemed Herr President! For the reasons given we are unfortunately unable to act upon your most kindly offered suggestion. But your letter is nevertheless of great value to us and could be of great significance for Jewry. It showed us, on the one hand, the gratifying fact that the wholly dismissive attitude which the non- or not-yet-Zionist Jews at first adopted towards Zionism has given way to a recognition of the significance of this great current of thought in Jewry, which manifests and spreads itself with almost elemental force. A Jew may be of whatever opinion he likes, he may be a vehement opponent of Zionism, but he may no longer say that Zionism does not concern him.
If your action, highly esteemed Herr President — you who stand at the head of one of the greatest Jewish communities in the world — were to serve as an example to the other members of our Community, then there might easily result an entente between the two greatest party tendencies in Jewry, both of which after all have only one aim — the prosperity and development of Judaism and the welfare of Jewry — an entente which could only further this aim and bring blessing upon it.
I therefore make use of your permission, Herr President, and hand over your letter and my reply to the public.
Accept, most highly esteemed Herr President, the expression of my most excellent respect, with which I sign myself your entirely devoted Oskar Marmorek.
Appeal of the Central Committee of the Zionist Federation for Germany.
To the German Zionists!
The approach of our Congresses has always been for us the signal for a heightened exertion of our forces, for an inner and outer gathering.
