No. 18. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.
(continued from page 2)
...alone does not make them holy if the true Jewish spirit is wanting in them. While memorial services for Herzl were held in almost all the synagogues of the world, to the great German Synagogue in Jerusalem he was still a heretic, and it ignored him. Instead, services were held there for the success of the Russian arms. No — rather Zionism without Zion than Zion without Zionism.
I should like to leave the development of the already existing Palestinian colonies to others, in order to seek a provisional Palestine somewhere. Any territory that was Jewish and stood under a Jewish flag would save the body and the spirit of the Jews, would become a rallying-point for Zionism, a preparatory school in the art of self-government, a lever of political importance, and a nursery for the training of husbandmen for Palestine. You will doubtless have heard of the rolling pavement at the Paris Exhibition, which was to render carriages and locomotives superfluous. The first pavement came rolling up so slowly that one could jump on to it. Only there did the real rolling pavement begin, which carried you swiftly to your destination. I fear that to attain Palestine at a single bound is too great a labour for us. It was too much for Moses, too. He kept his people forty years in the wilderness. His first pavement was Sinai, and those who believe that nothing holy or Jewish can be created outside Palestine may remember that the Ten Commandments and the whole Mosaic legislation were given at a time when the Jews did not possess Palestine at all. But where are we to find our first halting-place, our first rolling pavement?
We thought of Sinai itself, and entered into negotiations with the Khedive of Egypt and the British Foreign Office. Under these auspices we sent out an expedition, but unhappily our experts brought us word that the Sinai Peninsula was a desert, and that, for all the romance that lies in a return to Palestine by the ancient road, we can no longer count upon manna nowadays. The cost of irrigation would be enormous. Mesopotamia, too, would exceed our means, although the reclamation of that country might become a profitable speculation through the advance of policy towards the Persian Gulf. Cyprus is the island lying nearest to Palestine, but the attempts to carry on Jewish colonisation there have always stirred up the population of the place. When the United States were forming, there might perhaps have been room for a Jewish State as well. Now, however, it is already too late, although I am not quite sure of that. There are immense tracts of land in the United States that stand in need of labour, but we are too stupid to turn them to account for our political plans. Agents of the great railway lines often came to me and pointed out how towns might be built and peopled and the land round about settled, if we would send our emigrants in that direction. The same conditions prevail in Canada too, where there are great unused areas of land, though it is certainly too cold there. Argentina, where Baron Hirsch's colonies opened the dance, is probably too Catholic. Hitherto, moreover, we have had good experiences only in Protestant countries. And finally — last not least — we come to England's offer, the offer of the plateau of Guas Nguhu, as some call it, although Sir Charles Eliot calls it Uasin Gishu. Both names are too unpronounceable for a successful settlement — let us suppose we call the country New Sinai. It is a territory in East Africa, 5000 square miles in extent and thirty Saiten
railway journey from the sea. The districts lying near the coast, towards Mombassa, are unhealthy, whereas this tableland, despite its equatorial position, is cool and healthy owing to its elevation of six to eight thousand feet above Lake Victoria Nyanza, on its south-western shores. Do not fear that the Jews have been offered some death-dealing tropical province. When Joseph Thomson, the first explorer to traverse Masai Land, came to this plateau, his black porters cried out: "What a terrible country is this! We shall perish of cold." "We reached the plateau of Guas Ngishu," wrote Thomson, "and my men were hindered from going forward by the cold. I was therefore obliged to halt and have great bonfires lit in order to revive them."
The plateau is 95 miles long and 55 miles broad, and for a stretch of 45 miles it runs at a distance of 20 to 40 miles from the Uganda Railway. We were told at first that the railway lay within 5 to 10 miles — and this is a sad proof that our delay in sending out an expedition has brought upon us our being pushed back a certain distance from the best districts along the railway. But after all, a people that for eighteen centuries has not possessed a square mile of soil has suddenly been offered a country the size of Wales, in which it would enjoy local autonomy under the suzerainty of England. Mr. Chamberlain and the British Foreign Office grasp what the Sultan cannot grasp, namely, that it is profitable to have an empty territory worked by an industrious people. No one values more than I the magnanimity of the offer that England has made to a suffering people. Earl Percy said in the House of Commons that the Government had been guided in some measure by the feelings of sympathy which every Christian nation ought to have, and which the English people always had and, it was to be hoped, always would have, for a people that through centuries of persecution had clung with so wonderful a tenacity to the hopes and promises which it believed it saw confirmed in Revelation and in the words of the Prophets. But England's offer springs as much from a broad understanding as from a broad heart. It spares England the necessity of breaking with her old ideal of being a place of refuge — for the anti-alien party rages more and more every day — and at the same time it contributes to the peopling of the British Empire. This Empire is still in its infancy — immense and overwhelmingly great upon the map, it numbers only a few millions of white inhabitants. There are nearly twice as many people in London as in Australia, and a million more than in the whole of Canada. The want of population in the British Empire has been most strikingly proved by the example of South Africa, where the importation of coolies proved necessary. The admission of the Jews to East Africa is Mr. Chamberlain's own idea, as it was in his day the very plan of Oliver Cromwell to open England again to the Jews after nearly four centuries of banishment. With both statesmen this idea, apart from its purely humanitarian character, was part of the same dream — the dream of imperial expansion. "The Jews," says Mr. Lucien Wolf in his brilliant monograph on Menasseh ben Israel, "must have appeared to Oliver Cromwell as useful instruments for his colonial and commercial policy." Mr. Chamberlain, too, possesses this wide outlook. The East Africa Protectorate,