Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 17 · 28 April 1905
9printed page
scan 9 of 20
Facsimile · scan 9 of 20
Scan of p. 9
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 17. — "Die Welt" — Page 9.

(continued from page 8)

…Jewish competition, or of very legitimate non-Jewish competition. But the same Herr Ussischkin who on page 17 promises the suppression of all land speculation quite forgets that on page 13 he has described in glaring colours how the mere appearance of a single would-be purchaser for a small plot incites the Arab landowner to speculation. One needs no great training in political economy to see that, no matter when and under whatever legal conditions the purchase of land begins — the right of expropriation apart — a rise in land prices must inevitably accompany it. But we create the most unfavourable market for ourselves if, with nervous haste, we try to buy everything that is to be had, and in doing so do not even obtain in return the unrestricted possibility of exploiting a secured property; and any non-Jewish competition which, even without legal security, knows itself sufficiently covered by diplomatic power, will easily be able to drive us from the field.

III. The immediate beginning of a Zionist colonisation of the Holy Land signifies the return to the Basle Programme, is indeed its first realisation in full — and for this assertion the spokesmen of Palestinism appeal to the sentence of the Programme which speaks of "the purposeful promotion of the settlement of Palestine."

We are thus asked to believe that the authors of the Basle Programme had simply forgotten until now one of its most significant sentences, that six Congresses had passed it by without a thought, and that all that is now demanded is that we should bethink ourselves of the good old Programme and act accordingly! Pray, whom do these gentlemen think to dumbfound with such naïveté?! Since the First Congress, where Kohan-Bernstein alone still preached the Chowewe Zionism in modern trimmings, the principle has been repeated without contradiction at every Congress that Zionism can contemplate the purchase of land and settlement only under securities of public law; and though the notion of the requisite legal guarantees may at different times and with different speakers have found differing interpretations, it could more and more be referred to the legal norms at present in force. This had apparently passed so completely into our flesh and blood that at the creation of the N.-F. this point was spoken of only in passing; to an inquiry from L. Behr the "Government Commissioner" Schalit replied that, as a matter of course, not only the amount of capital attained but also the conditions of the Basle Programme would be decisive for the beginning of land purchase. All the more astonishing is it that at the Sixth Congress — after Oppenheimer, towards the close of his report, had still briefly pointed to the absolute necessity of legal guarantees — later, in the debate on the reduction of the minimum sum of the N.-F., the earliest possible purchase of land was desired on all sides and almost without contradiction, although Diesenhoff and Pasmanik, who for that matter also pleaded for it, had pointed out plainly the change of principle that this would involve and its further consequences. In studying the minutes one cannot rid oneself of the impression that here, from fear of a new secession and to reconcile the Nay-sayers completely, a strong, very abrupt and very ill-considered change of course was tacitly carried out. In this question, however, tactical and practical considerations can in no case be decisive; for here we strike upon the foundation pillars of the Basle Programme. And so

I must say without circumlocution: I hold it a crime to invest national property so insecurely that it would be exposed to all the chicanery of bureaucratic interpretation of the law, if not to the caprice of Turkish officials. Not even the strongest grounds of expediency can get over this. One need only read again what Kaminka related at the First Congress: "The colony Cheiera was originally the property of 18 persons, whose shares, however, were not delimited; when in 1891 the colony was acquired by a company of 70 persons, a deed of sale had to be made out to each individual purchaser by each of the former owners, so that no fewer than 1261 judicially executed documents were necessary! And when one has had the good fortune at least to register the land lawfully in this way, there begins the great misery of the difficulty of building, since not a single house may be built without direct authorisation from Constantinople." The conditions are lit up still more drastically by what Pineles recounted at the Annual Conference of 1904: "When in 1882 the old Chowewe Zion in Roumania bought the estates Samaria and Tantura, and that in the name of their President, Is. Loebbel, and when he died soon afterwards, they elected his son, Dr. L. in Galatz, as President; when he too died soon after, childless, the Turkish Government confiscated the estates. There were great difficulties and expenses. The Austrian Ambassador in Constantinople had to intervene, since the L.'s were Austrian subjects; the French Ambassador likewise interposed, since the estates had meanwhile been sold to Baron Erlanger (Paris), Rothschild's confidential agent. Finally two Mohammedan merchants from Galatz had also to travel to Constantinople and testify there on oath that I. L. had left yet another son and heir. Thus it was at last possible to obtain the registration of the estates in the name of Baron Erlanger. He has several sons, and the succession is therefore secured." The report does not record that Homeric laughter arose in the council of the Actions Committee gods, who were at that time in a particularly earnest mood. But is it not a devilishly clever idea to install, alongside the Ussischkin land committee, a secret Schidduchim committee as well, which would have to choose for the men of straw, with the care of ancient dynasties, a life's companion promising a rich blessing of children? And since Ussischkin himself admits that "without the almighty baksheesh it is not possible to take even a single step, even an entirely lawful one," I would propose creating a baksheesh fund at once, but having it administered not by the Colonial Bank but by the Chaluka collecting office. But jesting aside! Who could, without shame and repugnance, suffer our sacred cause — which sought to bring the Jewish question, in all openness and honesty, with earnestness and dignity, to an honourable solution — to be degraded by such backstairs politics, with tricks and subterfuges, distortions and evasions of the laws? So, by God, the Herzlian ideal did not look! Well, even the most zealous Palestinists, to be sure, feel somewhat uneasy when they think of these conditions. The Berlin group speaks of colonisation "in all publicity and on the basis of an open agreement with the government of the country," but later forgets itself and in its concluding theses demands the most active colonial policy without any restriction. The same gentlemen in one place describe our goal as "an ideal wholly without analogy" — rightly so, just as our people itself is an incommensurable magnitude, its whole history an unheard-of thing without parallel —