No. 16 — "Die Welt" — Page 5
(continued from page 4)
…cal one-sidedness, or rather straight-ahead-sightedness, could only prove fatal for one part of the Jewish people, and I fear the gentlemen are sawing through, without noticing it, the national bough on which we already sit so insecurely as it is.
For eight years we have been proclaiming orbi et urbi that Palestine belongs to us by right, that we must and shall have it, and yet up to now we have only succeeded in suggesting this axiom to ourselves, but not to the Sultan, who for the present will hear neither of an autonomy nor of a Charter, although we, with our Herzl, long hoped that the Turk would grasp the soundness of the "do ut des," that he would perceive that a "Jewish State" in Palestine could only contribute to the elevation of Turkish culture, industry, and Turkish trade, and so forth. The Charter, which our Leader had such good prospect of obtaining, was indeed the chief attraction, whose power of appeal carried along with it even those who had formerly entertained the very gravest doubts as to the possibility of taking possession of Palestine. But if the Turkish gentleman will still not let himself be persuaded, are we on that account to continue practising the old system of smuggling ourselves in, which so deeply repelled our late Leader? Is Zionism, this grandly conceived movement, which might one day really afford us the possibility of founding a "Jewish State" in Palestine, to content itself solely and entirely with a colonisation advancing at a crab's pace, which has already swallowed many, very many millions of francs and in 25 years has lured thither some 4—5000 farmers and vine-growers, who, scarcely provided for, are half of them still recipients of alms, and whose property in the soil is, into the bargain, protected by nothing? Are we still to indulge in the self-deception that we are working God knows what miracles in Palestine, while in fact we are merely drawing water in a sieve?
The fact is that, with the prayer "schono habo" on their lips, Jews, without first asking us, are emigrating in masses to America, South Africa, etc., not only from Russia but — from Palestine itself. And that is, after all, so natural. For all the love which the Jewish masses bear in their hearts for Palestine, they know perfectly well that for the present there is little to be got there, that the Turkish agrarian laws are the most intricate on the whole globe, that back-stairs politics, baksheesh, the evasion of the law — these dear, familiar acquaintances from home — that all this must not raise but rather depress the cultural level of the Jews in Palestine, that, so long as Turkey is not numbered among the civilised countries, an emigration to Palestine is as fitting as going out of the rain into the gutter. For it is not merely a question of herding a great number of Jews together in Palestine. If it were only a matter of quantity, we need only make an excursion to Berditchev to see what a sight this Jewish ant-heap presents, which, moreover, looks far more cultured than the 60,000 Chaluka Jews of Palestine. We wish, after all, to rear cultured, free, self-respecting Jews, and that is for the present entirely out of the question under the Turkish management, unless the European Powers should move Turkey to cede Palestine to us as our lawful, historic inheritance. But we are still far from having got so far.
And then come the faithful watchmen of Zion and say: "What harm is it, then, that the Holy Land is now so desolate, that caprice instead of freedom reigns there, that an emigration is for the present forbidden?
Can we not wait, then? Does not the Bride of Zion deserve that for her sake we should languish some fifty years more in the Ghetto and perform forced labour, while meanwhile Palestine is conquered by us economically, through the purchase of land, through industrial undertakings of every kind, whereupon it must fall into our lap politically as well, like a ripe apple? Patience! Only wait!"
But that is just it — we cannot wait any longer. Whoever maintains the contrary is playing a very frivolous game with his love of Zion; he will not, or cannot, penetrate into the deep misery of the Ghetto. We simply cannot wait. Apart from the mass misery which drives thousands upon thousands aimlessly and hopelessly into distant lands, where they are either turned back or otherwise often go to ruin, apart from the indescribable demoralisation which is spreading rapidly in the swamp of the Ghetto, we are compelled to render help, even if at first only partial, by the circumstance that our Russian-Jewish youth, on whom we stake our whole future, is falling away from us in droves and turning to currents which have nothing in common with Judaism and the Jewish people. The religious bond which until now has knit the Ghetto Jews together is growing ever looser, and if the only one that still remains — the national idea — should not be kept awake, it might easily happen that at the moment when Palestine could be obtained we should have no Zionists left. The Jewish-Russian youth, in whom undreamt-of potential forces lie slumbering, is striving after political freedom and positive work, and if we give it stones instead of bread, if we merely put it off with the promise of a future paradise in Palestine, then they will turn away from us and perish in the prisons of Siberia, instead of devoting their powers to their nation. And such a return to their nation would be possible only if they were to see that an autonomous land fit for colonisation is being opened to the Jews, where they could exercise their energy and convert their potential force into actual force. That is why I am a zealous champion of every grandly conceived colonisation which tends towards creating a national Jewish centre of strength, one which could cherish and preserve Jewish self-respect, the Jewish character, Jewish ethics. Let no one object to me that the number of emigrants to the new field of colonisation would be a minimal one and would not, within any foreseeable time, stem the mass misery after all. That is not true. If only the first beginning succeeds, if the first pioneers are young, healthy and energetic, and the economic and political possibilities favourable, then in a short time the number of emigrants grows like a snowball, and after a longer period like an avalanche. That is the lesson of the history of all colonisations.
And just here I must meet an accusation which is laid at the door of us Yes-sayers, as though we wished to give up Palestine altogether and turn only to East Africa. By many this charge is raised bona fide. Many, on the other hand, use it as a means of agitation. And so I will now declare, in the name of my fellow Zionists, that we cling to the idea of Zion with body and soul, that Zion as the final goal of our endeavour is present most intensely to us in particular; but we are realists enough to recog-