No. 15 — "Die Welt" — Page 5.
(continued from page 4)
...takes the initiative in establishing a local-Jewish, centrally collegial body in Palestine, which shall join together and unite the Jewry of Palestine and shall be regarded as the representative corporation and protector of Jewish interests in Palestine."
But with this first political act they have at once proved their dangerous incapacity for this work. I do not intend here to discuss at all the material side of the question, whether the carrying out of this resolution is possible and useful. But its publication is surely the most certain way of filling the Turkish Government with mistrust, of frustrating its execution, and of making life harder for the Jews of Palestine. Does Mr. Ussischkin no longer remember what attitude the Turkish authorities took towards the conference pursuing similar aims which sat under his direction during the Sixth Congress? These gentlemen act just like the conspirators in the opera who, before they proceed to the deed, first sing their plan out to the world in a loud aria! They have acted like the Sorcerer's Apprentice, but unhappily the Master is no longer there who, with his "Into the corner, broom," could lay the spectre.
If, after what has been said so far, you should be ready to grant me that it not only does not violate the fundamental principles of Zionism, but might even be of advantage to it, that we should accept the charter from the British Government and should continue to occupy ourselves with it for some time afterwards, in order to secure a use of it that is expedient and commensurate with the importance of the matter, then the second of the objections in view will very soon confront me: "If you really pursue only such unpolitical aims, what do you need autonomy for?" In answer to this question it must first of all be recalled that the letter of Sir Clement Hill speaks only of granting the colony full freedom of action as regards municipal legislation and the regulation of religious and purely internal administrative affairs. Municipal autonomy is what we in Germany would call communal autonomy, only extended over the whole territory, and this alone interests us, as the most important and indispensable precondition for the establishment of a commonwealth on a social-liberal, that is to say a land-reform, basis. We may quietly dispense here with security under public law, and thereby with any political aspirations whatever, as I already remarked some weeks ago in the "Rundschau," for English liberty is security enough under public law. Mr. Greenberg also points to Herzl's well-considered intention in setting the limits of this autonomy. It is, namely, the only way of reserving the ceded territory de facto for the Jews as well; for it would be a monstrosity in constitutional law, and naturally cannot be expected of the English Government, that it should expressly and formally exclude English citizens from an English territory. Municipal autonomy, then, is to make it possible for the self-given laws and institutions to be adapted specially to Jewish needs; I need only recall the possibility of introducing the Sabbath as the legal day of rest. The same purpose is served by the Jewish chief officer, who is otherwise to be appointed or confirmed by the Government.
Thus municipal autonomy, too, cannot fill us with mistrust of the offer from our Zionist standpoint.
Let us come, then, to the last of the three objections: "Forces will be withdrawn from Zionism and from the work in Palestine," to which I oppose the assertion: "On the contrary, new forces will flow to Zionism. Some weeks ago I already briefly asserted in the "Rundschau" that, according to the laws of energetics, a Jewish settlement of the East African territory would, on the contrary, set free precisely those mighty material and spiritual potential energies which now lie latent in the people, by converting them into kinetic energy, and that they would redound to the benefit of Zionism. In that brief hint, as I have been told, this was not understood at the time. I should therefore like to show here, by an ascending series of examples, that the laws of energetics hold good not merely for the material forces of nature, but also in the organic and spiritual world, in the life of the individual and in the life of nations.
Very briefly I must recall the law of the conservation of energy. You know that energy can neither be newly produced nor destroyed. Wherever we see an effect of energy appear, it is in reality only a question of the conversion of potential energy into kinetic energy, or the reverse. Heat can at any time become energy, energy heat, that is, potential energy. Heat, however, cannot be employed for the performance of work; it must first be converted into energy. In some cases this is possible, in others not. The heat or potential energy stored up in coal can easily be converted, by burning, into energy that drives machines. The potential energy stored up in the water of the Jordan would, as has been calculated, suffice to run 30 railway trains day and night without cease at a speed of 100 km an hour through the whole of Palestine. On the other hand, the enormous quantity of heat stored up in sea-water cannot be used even to propel a single ship, but for that we are dependent for all time upon outside forces such as wind and coal.
Why, then, are the comparatively small quantities of heat in coal and in the Jordan able to perform such great work, while the incomparably greater quantity of heat in sea-water cannot be converted into kinetic energy? The answer is: in the Jordan there exists a tension, and in coal it is easily introduced by kindling, which is termed the fall of energy; in sea-water, on the other hand, there is no fall of tension present, and we have no means of introducing one either. The potential energies of the sea are thus of no use as slaves of labour, because there is no means of converting them into kinetic energy, of forcing them into a definite direction of motion.
The releasing tension, however, or the potential, as it is called, need stand in no proportion whatever to the energy obtained. The pressure of a child's finger on the button of an electric circuit sufficed to convert the potential energy of great quantities of dynamite into kinetic energy and thereby to blast huge reefs and masses of rock before New York harbour. The beat of a crow's wing in the high mountains unchains, out of existing potential energy, the kinetic energy of the avalanche.
If I now set about showing you that this law holds good also in the organic world and in the domain of the mind, I naturally cannot offer mathematical proofs here, but can only let intuition speak.
We have all often experienced in ourselves how, in the course of a discussion, of a dispute, the subject often becomes clearer to us ourselves, how our own conception gains more precise forms, how we can grasp and present the matter more sharply and from more sides, although our opponent has convinced us on no single point, although he has brought us not one single new element of knowledge. Indeed, we may for all that remain convinced, as before, of the incorrectness of all the reasons he has advanced. But his objections have nevertheless, as a tension or potential within the circle of our ideas, called forth a fall of energy, or increased the fall already present, so that it became possible for us, through intensified active thought, the material better in de-
