"Die ✡ Welt" — Page 4 — No. 14
(continued from page 3)
…movement towards the goal is everything. Only the movement must be directed towards the goal. We therefore demanded work in Palestine even before the Fourth Congress, just as we also called for the creation of a vigorous Palestine Commission. As we have already expressed ourselves on the question several times¹), we may be brief here.
We can scarcely imagine a healthy, normal activity in Palestine, capable of development, under the given circumstances, that is, without further preparations. Even if we wished to confine ourselves to the purchase of land, it is above all necessary that our National Fund should obtain the rights of a juridical person. One may well buy for a time in the name of private persons, but the matter is not so simple as Herr Ussischkin represents it to us. On the other hand, the land cannot be left uncultivated, for economic and juridical reasons. All this, however, under the conditions now prevailing in Palestine, cannot proceed otherwise than is the case.
What can be done now is surely not the systematic colonisation of which Herr Soskin speaks.
But it does not follow from this that we must merely await the "great day." Political Zionism is not merely a goal, but also a method. Before the great day there comes first the long and tedious work. But not in the sense of obtaining a charter from the Great Powers, but in the sense of acquiring concessions from Turkey herself. In this sense we wrote in another place: "Zionist diplomacy must pursue with all energy one purpose only: the acquisition of concessions in Palestine and in the neighbouring lands. As a matter of course, therefore, the centre of our diplomacy must be transferred to Constantinople. But it may well happen that the nearest way from Basle to Constantinople leads through sundry European capitals, for example through London, St. Petersburg or Rome. That depends on circumstances and on the political instinct of the leaders. But no proposal of the Turkish Government may be rejected merely because it does not contain what 'we usually understand by guarantees under public law.' We go so far that in the interest of our people we would accept any concession whatever in Palestine. If, for example, such a concession were offered us as would give us the possibility of colonising thousands of Jews, who could live out their lives and develop normally in body and mind, we believe we can affirm that our people would greet such a concession with joy, even if it had been demanded that the colonists should become Turkish subjects, must remain under Turkish jurisdiction and might possess only communal self-government, like all other Turkish communities. For in spite of all this, these Jews could recover physically and economically, and likewise found a national spiritual life. In time these concessions would have to expand.
One must not say that the Turkish Government will grant us no concessions either, if it knows that we shall not be content with them but would go on working until the Basle Programme is integrally realised. We are
¹) On a Practical Zionist Programme. Ewr. Jisu 1904. No. 4. Charter and Concessions. Die Stimme der Wahrheit 1905.
convinced, namely, that a time must come when Turkey too will recognise that Zionism can under no circumstances become harmful to her, that a Palestine brought to new life can only strengthen the whole Ottoman Empire, but that only the Jews can breathe new life into this land; that, on the other hand, the Jews are not bent on possessing an army of their own and ambassadors of their own, but are filled only with the longing for normal conditions of national life; that, in a word, they wish to found a Jewish home under Turkish suzerainty.
We must, however, give Turkey concrete proofs of our capability; we must prove our usefulness to her by facts. That we can do only by way of concessions. Then all mistrust on Turkey's part towards us becomes groundless, for a concession is bound up with no interference by foreign Powers." ¹)
Now there are, however, people who seem to know everything exactly, even the intentions of the Porte. In the first place we have one fact: in the opening speech at the Sixth Congress it was officially announced that "a scattered, disconnected colonisation in various parts of the Turkish Empire" had indeed been conceded by the Turkish Government. Secondly, in this respect we cannot rely on hypotheses, but must be placed before exact facts: we must therefore try everything. In any case we shall sooner be informed about the possibility of acquiring concessions than about the possibility of a mass colonisation in a territory wholly unknown to us.
Above all, however, we must procure for the legalised National Fund juristic personality: then the purchase of land on a large scale can begin.²)
Secondly, we must obtain the right to collect the State taxes ourselves, so that the mismanagement of the tithe tax may cease.
Thirdly — the free immigration of the Jews into Palestine.³)
Only in this way are we protected against relapse into the petty-bourgeois Chovevei Zionism, which can never, never develop into a movement of the people. Only in this way are we protected against stagnation in our activity. Then the empty dispute about the charter will cease: practical life will show the right way of itself.
What we see now is the most hopeless confusion: on the one hand people speak of "work in Palestine" pure and simple; on the other they demand diplomatic work, without being really clear how in fact these
¹) Die Stimme der Wahrheit. First Year. Page 73.
²) Turkish law knows no "juristic persons" at all, and in particular none such as holders of rights of property in land. Exceptions have hitherto been made only in few cases, and these only by special Iradé of the Sultan, and only in favour of such companies as had it stipulated a priori that the property would revert to the Turkish State Treasury after a number of decades. (Editor's note)
³) For the second point a charter is already required, because this belongs to the sovereign rights of the State. The tithe system is by no means so bad, and was in force in the ancient law of the Torah as well. The "thirdly" is surely to be taken cum grano salis, since complete freedom for an unregulated immigration would be a downright misfortune. See Haemeth m'erez Jisrael in Achad-Haam's al paraschath Drachim. (Editor's note.)
