No. 11. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.
(continued from page 2)
...ced Romance-Catholic culture, in a country which forms a field of emigration for the prolific Italian people, there can be any talk of a Jewish autonomy and cultural independence. The abstract declamations of the Territorialists only very thinly conceal their concrete wish: that the commission may find Uganda fit for colonisation. Let this wish be fulfilled. What then?
What, after all, did the thinking Ugandists expect from the new project? What can one reasonably expect from it?
Despite all the high esteem in which we hold Dr. Nordau, we do not at all agree with his idea of the night-shelter. This idea has caused great confusion. People supposed that the Jews were to migrate first to Uganda and from there to Palestine, which is the purest fantasy. Some expected from Uganda a vigorous relief of Jewish distress. Now we believe that Africa, for purely objective reasons, is not suited to an intensive colonisation, so that the saturation point of Uganda would soon be reached. Nevertheless we were for the East African project, even if it could grant a humane and normal life to only a few hundred thousand Jews. We held that this new colony would have a high political and moral value for us. It was a matter of creating a real programme for the present, which should not weaken our forces but strengthen them. The most zealous defender of the East African plan, Mr. Greenberg, still stands on the same standpoint today. For him it is a matter of the partial alleviation of material distress, of the strengthening of our positions with a view to attaining Palestine.
We were for East Africa as for a real programme for the present, because we believed the Jewish people strong enough to fight on two fronts; we believed that Uganda would draw in new Jewish elements which had until then stood aloof from our cause, and would introduce them into the circle of ideas of national Judaism; we hoped that our uprooted youth would find a splendid cultural and social work in the Jewish field and would thereby draw nearer and nearer to our people; we imagined that new potential energies would arise, which would benefit Zionism in general. We could not for a moment admit that Uganda should become an end in itself, that Territorialism should arise out of it. We could not possibly foresee that so-called Zionists would be found who, in order to stir up feeling for Uganda, would agitate against Palestine; that Hebrew writers would agitate in the language of the Bible against the land of our fathers, of our nationality, of our greatness and of the aspirations of our people.
No, Mr. Greenberg! It is no longer a matter of simple dissensions, such as are present in every movement capable of life, but of upholding the foundations of the national ideal. Let us confess openly: the Jewish people is still too weak in every respect to work in two directions, to link Uganda and Palestine harmoniously with each other. Let us confess openly, after the experiences since the last Congress, that we have little to gain with Uganda, but much to lose. Above all we lose the unity of our movement, and with it our power is broken. All those who are of the opinion, with Mr. Greenberg, that "nothing can replace Palestine for the Jew. There and only there can he again found a Jewish state; in Palestine and only in Palestine can we again become a nation," must unite in order to manifest before the whole world the continuity of our endeavours toward the attainment of a secured home in Palestine. Back, back home!
(To be continued.)
On the Article: "Questions of the Day and Points of Dispute in Zionism."
In his essay in No. 9 Dr. Pasmanik took a few sentences from an article which I published in the "Jüdische Rundschau" as the occasion for a quite lengthy polemic. The editors of the "Welt" have now been so kind as to place at my disposal, before printing, the article of Dr. Pasmanik published in this number, so that I might have the opportunity of asserting a differing standpoint in good time. I am unfortunately prevented at the moment from making use of this opportunity, but should nevertheless not like to omit a brief reply, in so far as I have been attacked. With certain parts of Dr. Pasmanik's other arguments I am, moreover, in agreement. These are not truths of today, but insights which I, and others just as I, have long been in a position to maintain, without our first having had to make the detour by way of Uganda. As regards, however, his position on the questions of the needs of the Jewish masses, on large-scale and rapid colonisation and the problems connected therewith, an answer, in this paper or elsewhere, addressed to him or to those who think likewise, will surely be all the less wanting as the questions touched upon do in fact stand at present at the focus of the Zionist debates.
Coming to his polemic against me, I cannot take it amiss in Dr. Pasmanik — notwithstanding the somewhat awkward form of discussion — that he has drawn upon and picked apart a few sentences from my argument; but I regret that he proceeds from a great misunderstanding and that his polemic is from the outset one built upon unsound premises.
Readers of the first article of Pasmanik will remember that, in the author's view, Zionism must not leave out of account the material distress of the Jews, in particular the distress of emigration and the needs of the Jewish masses called forth thereby. But in the arguments of mine adduced by Dr. Pasmanik I was concerned not with the inner substance and the inner policy, but with the external policy of Zionism; that is, I endeavoured to examine how far the Powers, in their attitude toward Zionism, allow themselves to be influenced by the distress of the Jews settled in their countries, or of those immigrating or emigrating. As one sees, these are two quite differently constituted fields of inquiry, although points of contact between them are not excluded. Even in the few sentences he singled out, Dr. Pasmanik could have found that I was speaking not of the foundations of Zionism, but of the foundations of the policy of Zionism. I should have to repeat myself to the readers of the "Jüdische Rundschau" were I to set out once more what I declared to be the foundation of Zionist policy. I mention only once again that the dogma that "the Powers have, out of their domestic political situation, out of egoism (because the Jewish question causes them anxiety and difficulties), occasion not only to further Zionism, but even to exert pressure upon the Turkish Government, should it perhaps resist Zionism" — that I regard this so rigidly framed dogma as false in its premises and untenable for political practice, and that only a positive policy with cultural-histo-