Page 2 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 10
(continued from page 1)
…it is, however, a telling proof that the tendency of the Ministry no longer lay in the further sharpening of the Jewish laws, but that another direction had been taken.
Minister v. Plehwe, to be sure, fully earned his terror-inspiring popularity, for more than any other he made the Jewish policy the serviceable, subordinate instrument of his general policy. He wished to discredit the revolutionary movement completely with the people by stamping it as a specifically Jewish one. This policy, too, can lay no claim to any particular novelty, for it had already been in use repeatedly at the end of the 'seventies and the beginning of the 'eighties. Every anarchist attempt, even every politically unwelcome utterance, every political ferment, almost every demonstration was then represented to the "misled" people as a Cramole (stirring-up) on the part of the Jews and Liachen (Poles).
But v. Plehwe transformed this old method into an entire system and directly propagated it. He directly took occasion several times to express himself to the heads of the Jewish communities to the effect that, if the Jewish youth did not keep aloof and withdraw from the political movements, he would assume no guarantee for the conduct of the population towards the life and the property of the Jews.
This system came out with particular clearness and free from all ambiguity in the famous speech of the Governor of Mohilew, Herr Klingenberg, the immediate subordinate of Herr v. Plehwe. I have in mind the speech of the 3rd, or respectively the 16th, of September 1903, immediately after the Homel riots. "The causes of the recent events" — said the representative of the Government to the plundered Jews — "must be sought much deeper. I have known the Government of Mohilew for 25 years; then the Jews were well-disposed (loyal), then they took part in no political movements, and then there was no inkling of riots. Now the Jews are the leaders, the guiding spirits in all movements hostile to the Government. This whole 'Bund' and the 'Social Democracy' are nothing but Jews. True, there are among them also persons of other confessions, but these are the misled; the misleaders are always Jews.
In the gymnasia the Jews demoralise the youth; in the university only Jews take part in all the forbidden assemblies ...
And there are the fruits of their activity. You propagate among an uncivilised population disobedience, conflict with the Government, but the Russian masses will have none of this and turn against you yourselves."
Exactly the same thing was repeated in the other towns inhabited by the Jews. In Vilna, Minsk, Witebsk, everywhere, quite plain intimations were received — that if unlawful demonstrations took place on the Jewish side, riots would follow upon them.
Therein, in this turning to account of the Jewish question for the purposes of general Russian policy, lies the historical significance of Plehwe's person. But even in this direction the activity of this statesman could never have been so momentous, so horrifyingly fateful, had it not corresponded to the spirit of the powerful higher circles of Russia and had it not found a firm support in the influential party of the "Russian Assembly."
Under so all-powerful a protection as that of the Minister v. Plehwe, to be sure, the unofficial circles, the secret sources of active hostility to the Jews, retired into the background, and the entire anti-Jewish policy appeared to be identified with the person of the Minister.
But with the fall of Plehwe the anti-Jewish policy is by no means done with.
At the very moment when a liberal and humane personality had come to the head of the Ministry of the Interior, a firm union of all reactionary and anti-Jewish elements took place. They rallied round the "Russian Assembly" into an imposing opposition and continued their systematic, pernicious work in defiance of the Minister; they prevented every liberal measure proposed by the Minister, paralysed his activity at every step.
Thus, for example, Governor Klingenberg, whom the foreign papers reported months ago as dismissed, has, in spite of Prince Mirsky, remained in office and in high position; to the judicial proceedings concerning the riot in Homel the public was indeed admitted, but the conduct of the trial took place in such a manner that, in the gagging of the defence and in the prevention of the elucidation of the actions of the police and the military, it very considerably surpassed the Kischinew trial:
From all this it follows with evidence that in Russia, as in the whole rest of the world, we have to reckon with social parties as political factors.
Even now the main features of the parties of the politically mature portion of the Russian population can be traced without particular difficulty.
Above all we now see at the head a powerful "Court party," or better said "Grand Dukes' party"; then follows the warlike-minded Junker party (military party); further we have a firmly organised conservative-reactionary party (the party of the "Russian Assembly,") finally there emerges also a half-liberal, protectionist party of the great industrialists. Further to the left we find a purely constitutional, democratic (in the political sense) Zemstvo party; still further to the left comes the "organised" Social Democratic Labour party, and quite at the end the half socialist, half anarchist, purely revolutionary party.
Besides these parties of Russia proper, a very important part in the constellation of Russian political forces is played by the various national parties; thus, for example, the influence of the Polish, Finnish, Armenian, Lithuanian, Little Russian and other national parties is by no means to be underrated.
And should the present ferment, unheard of in the annals of Russian history, allow something salutary to ripen for Great Russia, it is to be expected that it will most probably assume the form of a constitutional State of somewhat the structure of Austria, or respectively of a mean between Austria and Roumania. In that case the principal struggle of nationalities will be played out in the western provinces of the Empire, that is, there, where the whole Jewish population is concentrated. We must by no means deceive ourselves about the destinies awaiting us in the near future, and since everywhere, in every Government without exception, we are in a minority, our interests will, even under the most liberal constitution, which is still far from being carried through, be safeguarded in no secure manner. We may expect that we, on paper, in theory, some rights or other, or even the civ-
