Die Welt · Vol. IX, No. 7 · 17 February 1905
7printed page
scan 7 of 20

No. 7. — "Die Welt" — Page 7.

(continued from page 6)

…room for such dissensions, for by them our strength, which even now is not too great for the mighty task we have set ourselves, must of necessity be weakened. We must agree to differ upon methods and details, for differences of opinion cannot be avoided. But let us preserve with the greatest care the true strength of the Zionist movement, the unity in the national ranks of the Jews. For the final goal for us all, of that we may be sure, is that for which we set out upon our way: the attainment of a home for the Jewish people in Palestine recognised by public law, the rebuilding of Israel as a nation. May it come soon and in our days.

With Zion's greetings I remain Yours respectfully L. J. Greenberg. 9 February 1905 — 4 Adar 5665.


From England.

"Toujours perdrix!" Always partridge! Always the same miseries, the same tales of want and wretchedness, of emigrant questions, of party vexations! I believe I may for once leave this question aside, and must touch upon other, merrier, airier themes. By our probing about in the wound it is not yet healed. And though we protest against the Aliens Bill for the thousand-and-first time, it will nevertheless be carried through, if the welfare of the English nation or the supremacy of a political party shall require it. I have once already set forth in this place the eventualities which would result for us Jews — and especially for those most affected by the Alien Bill — from the victory of the Unionist or of the Liberal party. I asserted, and I hold fast to this assertion, that the change of Government policy will exercise no essential influence upon the aliens question. Let us look, for example, at the latest — I had almost said "Pronunciamento" — of the leaders of the Liberal Opposition in the Upper and Lower Houses, Lord Spencer and Sir Campbell-Bannerman. And what do we see in these programmatic declarations? A departure from the Government policy now pursued in a few questions — in the fiscal policy of Chamberlain, in the administration of the Transvaal, which question has become the apple of discord of the parties in England, and, if possible, the granting of a Home Rule to Ireland. These are the maximum demands. And since one knows from experience that the party ruling at any given time cannot translate its whole programme into deed, that the stormers of yesterday are the waverers of to-morrow, that they who as men of the Opposition ruthlessly attacked everything are, as men of the Government, full of considerations, one has very little to expect from the change of Government, from the alteration of the "system." And least of all in the immigration question! In this respect most Englishmen are of the same opinion. And it is, after all, comprehensible. England's production has, at least in certain branches, declined in recent years. England has a hard economic struggle to sustain with Germany and America. In London misery is rampant, thousands of unemployed loiter about the streets — and then come ever new streams of wanderers, poor, ragged, for the most part unskilled labourers. It is indeed clear even to the most dogged enemy of the foreigner that these "Aliens" possess treasures of abilities, powers, talents. But before these come to unfold themselves, some years must pass.

And during these years the foreigners will have to work in the filthiest holes, in the "sweating-hells," for starvation wages, and lament — and thereby they will injure the residents and undercut prices. That is the very comprehensible logic of the anti-alienist. To give an example of the blind fear and rage of the English, especially of the "Great Englishmens" (in distinction from the "little Englishmens" — that is, adherents of a Little England) against the foreigners: I believe that I have once already reported that a party of Macedonian gipsies had arrived in London, and in what hideous colours the "Daily Mail" depicted the depravity, the degradation, the filthiness of these "barbarians." And I even gave expression, "bona fide" — upon my word — to my indignation that the Jewish emigrants may be compared with such a rabble. What! We, the descendants of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, we are compared with gipsies, "Gipseys," at any rate descendants of Ham! But do you know who these "Macedonian gipsies" were? It will scarcely be believed. They were simple German peasants from the Rhine. With a delightful naïveté the "Daily Mail" relates how it came upon this. It sent thither, namely, a reporter who understands many languages, among them no doubt "Macedonian Gipsy." He arrived, in the full consciousness of his exotic mission. He addressed them in some one of the "seventy" languages — presumably in some Hottentot-like idiom — and behold, our "gipsies" answered in the purest Rhenish dialect. The frightful creatures, the Asiatics, turned out to be honest German Michels, a little dirtier than is seemly, nothing more. The "Daily Mail" forgot that these are primeval Germans, that from their midst the real "founders of Britain" came forth. Its blind fear drove it to absurdities. I have reproduced it at such length only for the reason of showing how strongly the aversion to foreign immigration prevails in most circles of society. The "moral" is clear.

But are these the "airy and merry" heights which I wished to show the reader? Well, the power of suggestion is great. When one is possessed by a question, one cannot get rid of it. But I shall forcibly quit the gloomy region. We come to — Palestine. To Palestine? How so? Is the way from the East End to Jerusalem then so short? Or do all roads lead not only to Rome, but also to Zion? I must confess, I once believed it. I believed that all the roads of Jewish history, all the wanderings of the Jewish people, will lead, must lead, to one goal — to Zion. So I thought, and saw in Zionism a logic of facts, a necessary, irrefutable causal connection of cause and effect, of historical conformity to law. But I soon had to perceive that my construction of history limps a little. All roads do not lead to Zion. Some lead to — do I know whither? To Uganda, to other territories. The straight line is broken. We have a crooked line before us. And this, as is well known, is harder to calculate. Well and good. I will speak a little of Palestine. I hope not to exceed my competence, since I do not propose, as the Talmud has it, to "sit in Pumhadita and dream of Aspamia," but to give the impressions of an address on Palestine delivered in London. The lecture took place in the Wharncliff Rooms about two weeks ago. It was arranged by the "London Zionist League," under the chairmanship of Mr. Herbert Bentwich