No. 7. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.
(continued from page 4)
…tractive to make, and to that end autonomy is the best means. The plan connected with the Argentine colonies miscarried because sentiment had no voice in it; autonomy will form the sentimental element in East Africa. We must not found here merely a glorified Ghetto — a place to which the Jew turns more or less under compulsion. We must create a settlement which possesses attraction for him on other than material grounds as well. The matter would stand otherwise if we were founding small colonies or states for Jews; but here we wish to create a great settlement, of about half the size of Palestine, and for such a settlement autonomy is an essential requirement. If we are to have no autonomy in East Africa, the whole plan is more or less useless. For there is still room in Argentina and elsewhere for countless Jewish colonists, if the matter were only a question of room and opportunity. Autonomy, even outside Palestine, would call forth in those who emigrate to East Africa, and still more in those who are born there, the practical beginnings of a Jewish national consciousness, and such a consciousness of Judaism in the wider sense would in its turn call forth a justified feeling of independence and an abiding interest in the territory. There is, moreover, a reason for Jewish autonomy in East Africa which, as I hope, will win over practical people.
The immigrants who are to form the settlement will probably come from every country under the sun and be subjects of various governments. It is true that the Jew quickly adapts himself to new conditions and people, but it would assuredly contribute to the speedy and lasting foundation of the settlement if a form of government were introduced which every settler can acknowledge as his own, whether he be Russian, Austrian, Englishman or American; this form of government, which all acknowledge, must be a Jewish one. The difference which autonomy would make is to be that which shall distinguish this attempt at the uplifting of the Jewish people above all others hitherto made. The others have failed, or have at best been attended with only partial success. They had almost all the advantages which the present one offers, but they offered no autonomy. Would it not be illogical if those who have the welfare of their people at heart were to reject an opportunity of making good this omission, especially as the opportunity might not offer itself again?
But whatever may happen, let us beware of the disgrace which must of necessity fall upon us if we Jews leave this offer of the English Government unheeded! The lesser part of this disgrace will fall to the Zionists; for they have at least obtained the offer, they have at any rate sent out the Commission to explore the territory. As soon as the report arrives, it is the duty of all Jews, Zionists or not, to see to it that the proposal is subjected to a thorough examination, if the report justifies this. The excuse that such an experiment does not pertain to this or that body is not valid. The matter is not one that can be evaded by each man working in his own narrow sphere and taking no part in his brother's work, nay, sometimes regarding it with an envious eye. We have no room here for the "Chewra" ideal, for petty strife and narrow-hearted jealousy. A call has gone forth to the whole House of Israel to begin the work of its own liberation on a great scale, by solving first of all the gravest problem that oppresses it. And if Israel to-day proves itself so remiss, sluggish and degenerate that it is no longer capable of work for the common good, shows itself so denationalised that it no longer has regard for its people, then still more sufferings await it and it will sink yet lower in the eyes of the world.
Should this happen, however, we Zionists will perhaps reap little glory thereby, for it would prove that our ideals have as yet found little entrance among the Jews. And therein lies for Zionists a duty which they must take to heart, for this matter concerns them above all others. They should make it their business to foster national feeling in the Jews everywhere, without necessarily referring to any particular plan. They should everywhere do their utmost to make clear to the Jews how important it is that they leave to posterity a heritage which, in spite of all that has happened, is a glorious one, and has lost nothing through the last generation to which it belonged. The series of problems that are comprised in the so-called Jewish Question concern us all, men, women and children, and the children most especially, for they will reap what we sow; they concern the poor as well as the rich, the Jews in the East and in the West. One of these problems, which the events of recent times have made a particularly urgent one for us, is a vital question. We are called upon to find a means by which the Jews can be preserved to the world as a people and by which their historical continuance can be secured. It depends upon whether, during a few years in the immediate future — a trifle in the existence of a people — we are able to justify the persecutions, the sufferings and the sacrifices that have been laid upon us through thousands of years, and to become again a great people — great in the best sense of the word — or whether we must gradually, but surely, perish. To-day we stand at the cross-roads and must decide. Seldom has a people been confronted with a greater problem; no graver question has ever been put to the Jews. We must find means to lead our scattered people back to a unity of thought and of aims. We must gather many manifold interests, many different ideals, around our national ideal, which springs from our unshakable faith in the possibilities that lie in our people. To-day the Jews are united by a bond of fellowship which grows weaker from day to day, and which may soon cease altogether. The hope for Jews lies in holding fast to the national ideal, and the Zionists must devote themselves to the spreading of this ideal as a cult, without regard to persons and circumstances. There is no straight road to the rebuilding of a Jewish nation; this national work must find its beginning and its end in the heart of the people. I have heard Zionists assert that if we could obtain from the Turkish Government a charter for the taking possession of Palestine, or even of only a part of it, all Jews would at once become Zionists. I am not of this opinion. I believe that this would in any case be a premature step. Let us first foster courage and resolution in our people, and readiness to make personal sacrifices for the saving of our people as a nation; until this spirit prevails among the Jews, we are building upon sand, and any charter that we might obtain would not be worth the parchment on which it is written. The Zionists have, it is true, proved in many cases that they of a
