No. 4. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.
(continued from page 4)
…ing be; but this renewal must not take place by leaps, but gradually. Irreplaceable men there are not, and must not be, in our organisation. We must have only active, conscious workers; for if our organisation rests only upon the irreplaceable, it will be severely shaken at the death or the treachery of this or that irreplaceable man. To this an end must be made once and for all. (To be continued.)
Alliance Policy and Zionism.
By D. Elias (Mülhausen).
The present directorate of the Alliance upholds the idea that the Jewish distress can be relieved only by way of assimilation. One need not exert one's mental powers in any special manner to understand its train of thought: assimilation sees to it that Judaism disappears; with Judaism the Jewish distress disappears. Now, however, there are places in which assimilation has come about and in which the Alliance is nevertheless active. In the report for the year 1900 it is stated, for example, that in Marrakesh (Morocco) the Jews had adopted the customs, the faults and the superstitions of the Mohammedans among whom they lived; conversion to Mohammedanism, too, was said to occur there very frequently. The goal which the assimilationists have set themselves will therefore be attained in Marrakesh within a measurable time; Judaism will disappear there, and the Jewish distress, and that without outsiders having to intervene. Nevertheless an Alliance school was founded in Marrakesh.
What purpose may this school have?
In the national sense it may not work; for assimilation it need not work. The assumption is therefore very well justified that it pursues aims which are only loosely connected with the relief of the Jewish distress.
This school has in fact, like all its sister schools in the Orient, the purpose — or, as the spokesmen of the Alliance directorate express themselves, the secondary purpose — of spreading French culture and the French language.
That it regards French propaganda as one of its tasks, the Alliance directorate admits in official and semi-official utterances; I recall only the speech which the Honorary President of the Alliance, Herr Jakob Kahn, delivered at the grave of Goldschmidt, and the pamphlet which the Secretary of the Alliance published a few years ago. That the Alliance carries on French propaganda with success is certified without reserve by the French press and by French politicians. I refer to accounts of travel which the "Monde illustré" published two years ago, in which the importance of the Alliance schools in Palestine for French policy is illuminated; to articles in the "Journal des débats" which treated the same theme at the beginning of 1903; further to a series of articles in the "Matin" in which the services are emphasised which the Alliance renders to France in Morocco; and I recall besides the speech which Senator Count Annay delivered on the occasion of the Budget debate in the year 1903.
It is no doubt certain that the Alliance directorate has never given its teachers the definite commission to stand up for a policy which is not Jewish. But teachers who are trained in Paris according to French methods become automatically political agents of France; schools in which French is the language of instruction must be seats of the French spirit. It goes without saying that pupils who are educated by these teachers and in these schools will be not champions of Judaism, but pioneers of the French mind and of the French character.
The French Jews who stand up for their fatherland at home and abroad fulfil their duty as citizens. He would be a fool who took it amiss of them. Like the non-Jews, they have to give practical proof of their patriotism. Yet they have to serve their fatherland only with their persons and their fortunes; they have not the right to make Jews who do not belong to the French State serviceable to French purposes, and to carry on French propaganda with moneys which do not come out of their own pockets. In fact, most of the places in which Alliance schools exist lie outside the French sphere of power and interest; the French Jews form only a tiny minority in the Alliance, and the revenues of the Alliance are for the most part of non-French origin. The relatively largest contingent of the members of the Alliance is furnished, for example, by Germany, almost 41 per cent., and the capital fund of the society comes for the greater part from the Austrian Baron Hirsch.
The idea that Jewry has not to stand up for the foreign policy of an alien State is familiar also to the President of the Alliance, Herr Leven. With great sharpness he turns, in the Bulletin of the year 1901, against the Hilfsverein deutscher Juden, which, according to its statutes, is to spread German culture in the Orient. But what Herr Leven finds blameworthy in the Hilfsverein he finds a matter of course in the Alliance.
Those Jews who are of opinion that the Alliance has to serve exclusively Jewish interests must make front against the present directorate and the present policy of the Alliance; but so too must those whom its tendencies hostile to Zion do not suit.
Let Zionism not forget that the present Central Committee of the Alliance is a stronghold of assimilation. It works in the assimilatory sense upon all the schools which it directs, upon most of the Jewish communities in the Orient, and upon the "Ica." Rightly was the summons once addressed to us to conquer the communities. But the conquest of the Alliance directorate is of far greater significance for us. A community will never solve the general Jewish question; through the Alliance it can be solved. It is demanded of us that we work. What work is more important than that which Zionises the Alliance and with it the "Ica"? The "Ica" and the Alliance administer funds which constitute a Jewish National Fund. Is the work of making this fund serviceable to the Jewish people not just as important as, or even more important than, that of creating a new one?
That the struggle against the Alliance directorate has hitherto been taken up so slackly on the part of Zionism, or as good as not at all, has its reason in this, that many Zionists hoped to be able to count upon the Alliance at the "decisive moment." This hope is a deceptive one. The few national-Jewish elements which belong to the board of the Alliance have no influence upon the conduct of affairs. In the Alliance Herr Leven reigns as absolute ruler. And he has never concealed his hatred of the Zionist movement; he has never made a secret of what is in his heart. Still in everyone's memory, no doubt, is the refusal which Dr. Herzl received from him when he invited him to take part in the expedition to East Africa. It is also very interesting, for example, to know what Herr Leven imagines Zionism to be. It is, according to his remarks in the Bulletin of 1901, a movement which demands of its disciples "to place themselves apart from the other peoples and of the
