Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 1.
(continued from page 5)
…purpose, without method. We grope in the dark. Once agitation could fill our student years entirely. There still lives in everyone's memory the Zionist academic of former days, who with songs and fiery words called upon the Jews "to rally round the blue-and-white banner." To-day we are much further. We have won power and regard for ourselves by force; to-day the forms of our movement must of necessity be different ones. For us there work history, the present, "the problem." These we must know. And then, have we not our agitators among the citizens? No? Why then, where are the A. H.? Hic Rhodus! That is already the declaration of bankruptcy of our old manner of working. Because we carried the Zionist word in our mouths ever again in the same enthusiastic tone, it became stale and dreary to us, and sober life overthrew the Zionist "youthful enthusiasm." Yes, if the students used the time to educate themselves in those few years into complete Jews, to carry the struggle against assimilation to its end in their own persons, to come to know the people as it lives and breathes — I believe that does not let a man go again, though he sat for days together behind the green table of the "Philistine." But as it was, we formerly appropriated only what we needed in meetings, and studied the Jewish Question out of pamphlets; the consequence was naturally the danger of a shallowing of our views upon all things Jewish.
None the less I believe that a negative criticism of our work will still not take from the Zionist student that slovenly and unworthy conception of Zionism which makes the way to it appear as easy as — lehavdil — to Liberalism. Words can only teach; example must educate us. Well then, our Students' Conference shall be a living example of how we ought to work. We are so fondly accustomed to expound Zionism as mechanically from Alpha to Omega as though it were a sum in arithmetic without unknown quantities. Past the problems which lie treacherously in the way awaiting their solution, many like to slip by. The Students' Conference is precisely to point out and discuss these questions, which after all only prove that our people is no automaton, but an organism. Well-prepared papers and thorough discussions will doubtless be able to yield many a new point of view. Indeed, even if the theoretical results of the conference — it will hardly be able to last longer than two days — were not very great, there remains beyond all doubt the educational value which it has for us when, from a platform audible to all students, serious questions are seriously treated. The discussion would then pass on into the societies, perhaps even — that would be a kind of ideal — into a students' organ of our own.
What problems must come up for treatment in this second part of the Academics' Conference, which would thus have to furnish beginnings toward the building up of the theory of the movement, experience will doubtless tell us. Perhaps we do not all feel the gaps in the sequence of thought of our movement equally.
The dispute about Uganda has shown how manifold are the motives which we attribute to Zionism. To one it is only a movement of distress, to another only the striving after a centre of culture, the third sees only the autonomous-territorialist element, etc. And as one needs it, so one interprets the programme. The decision can be brought only by history, in so far as it opens the way to an understanding of the Jewish Question of to-day. That, then, would be one thing: a derivation of Zionism from history and the present. It has already been given by Thon, Acher, Farbstein; but to-day it will be able to be a richer one, and withal more universal or more one-sided, according to the standpoint which one takes. And we can learn much in addition, not least for agitation, which — in the right manner, to be sure — I should by no means wish to see struck out of our activity.
We should then come to Palestine. The knowledge of Palestine is another such delicate point with us, one which demonstrates ad oculos how much or how little we are worth. In Austria there are perhaps not a dozen students who are accurately informed about Palestine. The Palestine Commission probably no longer counts upon our collaboration. But if we do not work independently, we ought at least to know something of the land and its people. A lecture devoted to Palestine — presumably without discussion — would perhaps say, more in a formal than in a material respect, how we ought to pursue the study of Palestine. Whether even a single speaker will be found?
All too many subjects should not be treated. Non multa, sed multum. One important point more might be put forward for discussion: the programme for the present. For there are so many contradictions and yet such infinitely many possibilities of work in it that we ought to reflect upon it. Of the economic part let others speak. I feel especially the necessity of a discussion of the question of culture, precisely because the Austrian student body represents East and West. The Eastern Jewish and the Western Jewish question of culture, set side by side and discussed with one another — that could not but yield a beneficent exchange of opinions. Not only theoretically; rightly grasped, the discussion could not but show us the way to the people. How one fills the youth, the people, ourselves with the Jewish spirit — all that belongs here.
I do not enter into detail. If these lines direct the attention of the fraternity brothers to the working conference and stimulate discussion, then their purpose is attained. I sum up: the Students' Conference is to criticise and is to build up; it is itself to be a living example of that which it teaches. And last not least: we may succeed, by preparing public opinion and by a worthy course of our gathering, in making it implicite a great demonstration of the Jewish-national student body of Austria.
The conclusion is then analogous to that of Descartes: "I work, therefore I am!" Let us work!
Hugo Bergmann, Prague.
On American and British Immigration Laws.
By Hans Fehlinger. (Conclusion.)
In Canada the example of the United States was soon followed; in the year 1886 a law¹²) was enacted which, among other things, also has reference to the immigration of persons without means, of criminals, and to contract labourers; later, however, the prohibition of immigration was extended to other persons as well.¹³) In the year 1903 a law came into being which hinders the immigration of Chinese in a high degree; this is to be discussed at the close, together with that of the United States. In the Canadian law the detention and deportation of immigrants with loathsome or communicable diseases, as well as of the insane, etc., is likewise ordained; so too criminal and vicious persons are excluded from immigration. The provisions which exist in this British colony are, however, not so comprehensive as those of the United States. Cases of rejection therefore also appear seldom.¹⁴) Some provincial legislatures of Canada have further enacted special provisions against particular categories of immigrants; but to these also no special importance attaches.
In Australia, even before the formation of the present federation (Commonwealth of Australia), there existed in some colonies laws which restricted immigration. In the year 1901 these were superseded by a uniform law. This¹⁵) forbids landing in the first place to all those persons who are not in a position to write down a dictation comprising 50 words in any European language. By this the Australian federation desires to protect itself not only against the influx of less educated persons, but also against certain races, above all against the Chinese and Japanese, who, under the existing unfavourable economic conditions, already in their present numbers form a hindrance to the rise of the working population of European descent. The emigrants from Eastern and Southern Europe never represent
¹²) Chapter 65, Revised Statutes of Canada
¹³) Act of May 15, 1902; cf. also: "The Canadian Labour Gazette," Vol. 4, No. 6 and 8, December 1903 and January 1904.
¹⁴) Report of the (Canadian) Minister of the Interior, 1902/3 and 1903/4.
¹⁵) Act No. 17, 1901; cf. Laws and Regulations respecting the Admission of Immigrants. London, 1904.