No. 53 — "Die Welt" — Page 5
Vienna or London?
The London "Jewish Express" of 30 November takes up the question "Vienna or London" ("Die Welt," No. 48). With reference to Dr. Deiches' remarks it writes roughly as follows:
It is incorrect, it says, that the West End Jews do not come into consideration for Zionism. If there are as yet few Zionists among them, one must bear in mind that London in this respect stands no lower than Vienna, Berlin or Paris, where there are just as many non-Zionists or anti-Zionists among the rich. On the contrary, in England a Montefiore, a Moser, a Zangwill have been won, whereas in Vienna or Berlin no such Jews have yet joined Zionism. It is further incorrect that the East End Jews cannot be conscious Zionists by reason of their lesser degree of education. Besides, it is quite enough to be a Zionist by "instinct," for true patriotism does not depend upon high education. There are more educated anti-Zionists than Zionists. He who does not possess patriotic feeling will hardly acquire it at any university. The services which the educated render us as Zionists through their education may be great, but with the masses it is enough that they be Zionists of feeling, or, as Doctor Deiches says, Zionists "by instinct." Among other nations too the patriotism of the masses springs from instinct.
Dr. Deiches holds that, because the masses are instinctively Zionist, they could easily be led astray and won over to the Uganda project that prevails in England. The contrary is true; it was precisely those who "reasoned" a great deal who took up the Uganda project, whereas by feeling they are for Palestine. Educated Zionists such as Ben-Jehuda, Chasanowitz, Reines, Sirkin are representatives of various schools of learning who are for East Africa. It is altogether incorrect for Dr. Deiches to suppose that all English Zionists are for Uganda. The proportion of Ugandists to Palestinians is numerically no stronger in England than in Russia. Dr. Deiches insults the masses when he supposes that they could be led by a speech from one tendency to another. Dr. Deiches has forgotten that the London masses have steadfastly resisted whenever anti-Zionist attempts were made, in the name of the "Chibbas Zion," to divert them from political Zionism. Dr. Deiches must above all be reminded that the East End masses stand no lower than those of Russia, Galicia or Roumania, since it is not the worst of the latter who come over to England; on the contrary, the masses who have settled in England have the advantage of a capacity for organisation and the like.
Dr. Deiches errs when he supposes that the English leaders brought about the Uganda crisis in Zionism. They would certainly not have ventured upon it had not the question been raised by Dr. Herzl. He errs further when he believes that the English Zionists follow their leaders blindly. He was long not yet in England when we vehemently opposed, on material grounds, those very Messrs. Greenberg, Cowen, Gaster and Bentwich, with the first two of whom we now agree, by no means for personal reasons, in so far as we must approve their convictions, apart from the Uganda question.
In conclusion the author of the article touches upon personal questions which Dr. Deiches had omitted, and into which we likewise do not wish to enter here. K-rg.
Correction.
It is not true that I caused it to be printed, against my better knowledge, that Dr. Kokesch had disparaged Herzl.
The truth is rather that I only asserted that "Kokesch's remarks have a painful effect, because in effect they disparage the one in favour of others."
It is not true that my article in the "Jüdische Rundschau" agrees "word for word" with the one previously sent to the "Welt."
The truth is rather that I recast in substance precisely the attacked introductory part of the article, after I had withdrawn it from Vienna and before I sent it to Berlin. Thus in the recasting I made it stand out with particular clearness that I do not believe the disparagement of Herzl by Dr. Kokesch to have been intended, but know it to be its effect, its result.
It is not true that I was enlightened on the point that Dr. Kokesch's article "in effect disparaged the one in favour of others."
The truth is rather that in the letter from the editors of the "Welt," whose receipt, but not whose contents, I acknowledged, I received the information that Doctor Kokesch did not intend this effect. As to whether it nevertheless results, I was and am of a different opinion from the esteemed editors of the "Welt," which I intend to substantiate more fully in the "Jüdische Rundschau."
With this all Doctor Kokesch's conclusions about my "manner of fighting" (?) and my "weapons" collapse, and above all his conclusions regarding some "system" which Dr. Kokesch does not name.
Breslau, 25 December 1904. Hugo Schachtel.
* * *
All these corrections cannot do away with the fact that Mr. Schachtel received our letter with the detailed explanation of his mistaken view. That he must himself admit. The effect of this fact, however, cannot be weakened by any trade in effects, however lively. The Editors.
On American and British Immigration Laws.*)
By Hans Fehlinger.
In recent decades a tendency has come to light in most of the civilised states of Europe which aims at extending the power of the State and entrusting to it tasks from which it formerly stood entirely aloof. "Our age desires a progressive social policy, and this is possible only where there exists a vigorous State authority which dares to curtail the liberties of the individual for the sake of the general welfare." 1) In the Anglo-Saxon countries, however, State-socialist aspirations have found but little favour. There the freedom of the individual was, and for the most part still is, rated higher than much of the good that would result from the intervention of the State in this or that field. All the more striking is another kind of restriction of absolute personal freedom, which in these very coun-
*) From No. 10 of Volume III of the "Politisch-Anthropologische Revue," a monthly for the social and intellectual life of the nations. Thüringische Verlagsanstalt, Leipzig.
- H. E. Ziegler, Introduction to "Natur und Staat," p. 18.
