Page 6 — "Die Welt" — No. 52
(continued from page 5)
…of the wording of the Statute and not of the actual circumstances. That anyone other than Doctor Herzl could actually have been elected never occurred to Dr. Kokesch, nor was it hinted at by him in a single word. 'Had one wished, one could also have elected another.' By its wording the Statute would have been no obstacle. From this Doctor Kokesch concluded that our Statute was not cut to fit Dr. Herzl's person, and therefore need not be altered now either. Whether this view is sound I shall not express myself upon at all; but I do wish to set right that no disparagement of Dr. Herzl was intended by these remarks, nor could any be inferred from them. Moreover, it is more than strange that you should suppose that I, so long as I sit in the editorial office of 'Die Welt' and am entrusted with its direction, would permit any disparagement of Herzl in this paper — from whomsoever it might come."
Mr. Schachtel acknowledged this communication by letter of 28 November a. c.
After Mr. Hugo Schachtel had received and acknowledged this explanation, he has his article, with the quoted paragraph word for word, appear in No. 49 of the "Jüdische Rundschau" of 9 December 1904.
The readers will excuse me for having taken up the word in this partly personal matter. Mr. Schachtel's construction implied at the least the reproach of tactlessness, had I, as one of Herzl's oldest collaborators, attacked or disparaged him shortly after his death in the paper he founded. That I could not let rest upon me.
How, moreover, the great unbiased Zionist public has understood my articles on organisation, one of the letters I received on the publication of these articles shall show. I quote a letter from Germany of all places, from a quite objective quarter, since it comes from a man who stands outside the bustle of parties and whom I do not know personally. This letter reads:
"Dr. O. Kokesch, c/o the Editors of 'Die Welt', Vienna, IX., Türkenstr. 9. Freiburg i. B., 5. XI. 04.
Dear Doctor,
Permit a non-Jew, who nevertheless takes a lively interest in the Zionist cause, to express to you his approval of your article 'On the Question of Organisation' in No. 45 of 'Die Welt'. May the nervous spirits within your movement modestly follow Bismarck's saying: 'Quieta non movere.' Great innovations must develop slowly and harmoniously, and only a mind equal to your Herzl will have the right one day again to reach into the works with the firm grip of genius. May the right men, may the right unity be granted to Zionism!
Respectfully, F. Heidner."
Does Mr. Hugo Schachtel believe that this man would have written to me in this manner had he found the faintest hint of a disparagement of Herzl in my article?
One consolation may be drawn from this manner of fighting: it must go ill with a system for which one fights with such weapons.
Dr. Kokesch.
Theodor Gomperz on Zionism.
Theodor Gomperz relates in his just-published and highly interesting "Recollections" (Stuttgart, Deutsche Verlagsanstalt) that up to his thirteenth year, following his father's example, he clung almost with fanaticism to the religious observances. The break with them came when he became Bar Mitzvah. It came under the auspices of his teacher Thomas Franz Bratranek, a canon of the Augustinian foundation at Altbrünn. It was he whose teaching inspired the boy, who first opened wide horizons to him and initiated him into philosophical thought, although from the very beginning he regarded the Hegelianism his teacher cherished with mistrust. His maternal grandfather, Lazar Auspitz, who had broken completely with all religious ritual and ceremonial and who, on his rare visits to the synagogue, read a textbook of natural science instead of praying, may also have rubbed off on the grandson. When Gomperz had completed his university studies, the era of the Concordat had begun. Although it closed the career of university teacher to Jews, he nevertheless remained true to the faith of his fathers. He held it a matter of honour and conscience not to turn his back on his ancestral religion. It affects us exceedingly unpleasantly that he has now abandoned this view. It pierces our heart when we read on page 24: "Nevertheless I held it, wrongly as I now believe, a matter of honour and conscience not to renounce the old religious community, and thereby for a long time barred my own way to fruitful activity." We are all the more painfully disappointed by this utterance, as at bottom it deals logic a blow of the fist. It is a riddle to me how the excellent thinker, who otherwise distinguishes so strictly between being and seeming, between the essential and the inessential, could for the sake of the religious observances become wholly estranged from Judaism — could throw out the child with the bath. Judaism by no means falls with the hedge drawn about it; rather it is, to speak with Hermann Cohen, the eternal meaning of historical Judaism that it does not let itself be spellbound and entrenched in forms which arise historically and likewise pass away, but that it believes in ideas, as in the springs of its strength, and in their inexhaustible significance and never-failing fruitfulness.
A man who is done with Judaism in the turn of a hand must, as a matter of course, lack all sense and understanding for Zionism. He cannot grasp its mainspring, cannot clear a path to its root. Gomperz's verdict upon the splendid movement is downright typical. It fares with him and Zionism as with so many others of our co-religionists, who break the staff over it without having taken the trouble to become acquainted with it, to immerse themselves in our immortal leader's "Judenstaat." It suffices him to know it by hearsay. Is it to be wondered at, under these circumstances, that he feels himself too much a Master Anton towards it, one who no longer understands the world, to be able to express himself upon it otherwise than in natural sounds of bewilderment? It strikes us as a bad joke when he remarks, with a show of wit: "So this is what it has come to! The stream of history, so it is seriously demanded, is to flow back to its source. Permit me to
*) The essay in question was first published in the Vienna "Zeit" after the appearance of the "Judenstaat."