Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 52 · 23 December 1904
5printed page
scan 5 of 20

No. 52 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 5

Now that he has passed away, the situation has so changed that a remedy is called for.

On the one side the antisemitic Austrian state of nationalities, a downtrodden Jewry narrowed in its horizon, a public opinion ill-disposed towards us; on the other the English Empire, broad Jewish masses living in freedom, a public opinion stirred by great ideas, and a press well-disposed towards us.

I think it is clear whither our interests point.

Dr. Friedemann.

* * *

Conference of the Members of the South German Group Federations.

The Conference of the Members of the South German Group Federations, convened for 18 December 1904 at Frankfort-on-Main, has adopted the following resolutions:

1. The Congress is to be convened for March 1905, in accordance with the earlier resolutions of the Greater A.-C.

2. The meeting is convinced that centralisation of the leadership is a necessity for the unhindered progress of the movement.

3. The leadership of the movement is to be transferred to London. Should this appear impracticable, Berlin is to be chosen as the seat of the leadership.

With devoted Zion greetings, Simon (Mannheim).

* * *

On the Discussion of the Question of Organisation.

Mr. Hugo Schachtel publishes in the "Jüdische Rundschau" a rejoinder to my article opposing the decentralisation motions, in which he asserts nothing less than that in my article I disparaged Herzl.

He finds the disparagement of Herzl in my statement that the existing Statute of Organisation knows no institution of leadership, that it does not even contain a provision that the President of the A.-C. is to be elected directly by the Congress, and that under this Statute the members of the A.-C. elected by the Congress could also have chosen someone other than Herzl as President of the A.-C. The readers of this paper know what is at issue. The propagators of decentralisation based their motions chiefly upon the unproven assertion that the existing Statute of Organisation had been cut to fit Herzl's person, that therefore, Herzl being dead, it did not suit present conditions and must be altered. The opponent of these motions was bound, above all, to prove that this fundamental premise was incorrect and therefore the conclusion inadmissible, and he proved that the existing organisation is not cut to fit Herzl's person. Given the universally known and by no one disputed fact that Herzl was in fact the leader, a Statute of Organisation cut to fit his person would have had to sanction that fact. It would have had to contain the institution of leadership or, if not that, at least to provide that the President of the A.-C. be designated by the Congress itself. But since the Statute of Organisation contains no such provisions, and rather entrusts the leadership of the movement to a body which itself elects one of its members as President, that is the best proof that this Statute was not cut to fit Herzl's person, but was adapted to conditions without regard to any one individual. The existence of Herzl's actual leadership is thus the very foundation of this line of proof. The argument that the Statute of Organisation was not shaped after the person of Herzl, because it knows no institution of leadership, would have had no sense whatever without the self-evident presupposition that Herzl was in fact the leader! How, then, can I be reproached with denying Herzl's leadership by these remarks?

The outstanding personalities capable of leadership are not always present in a movement. It would therefore be a great mistake, at a time when such a man is living, to arrange the organisation entirely around him, because then with his departure the organisation, and with it the movement, would collapse. Our Congress therefore, in wise foresight, entrusted the leadership not to a single person but to a body. If a towering personality is found within it, he will in time assume the leadership in fact. But if none is found, or if the one there is departs, then the body appointed by the Congress simply directs the movement, and the movement is preserved by this wise arrangement from too great convulsions. How, now, a disparagement of Herzl can be seen in the establishment of the fact that the Congress, which stood under Herzl's aegis, created a wise Statute of Organisation adapted to conditions and not cut to fit one person, is wholly beyond comprehension. One would think that he honours Herzl more who establishes that under his aegis a Statute was created which is adapted to conditions without regard to his person and retains its force even after his death, than those who would have him cut a Statute of Organisation to fit his own person, with the motto: Après moi le déluge.

One might now suppose that Mr. Schachtel had misunderstood the article; had he been enlightened, he would certainly have dropped the assertion.

To my regret I must state that Mr. Schachtel was in fact enlightened on this point, and nevertheless had the above assertion printed.

Here are the facts. Let the reader form his own judgment of this proceeding. I shall refrain from all comment.

Mr. Schachtel sent his remarks against my article to the editors of "Die Welt"; in them, among other things, the following was to be read:

"That no single man could replace the dead leader — that was the thought which now set everyone reflecting upon an alteration of our organisation. This thought is unknown to Dr. Kokesch . . . for his article does not present Herzl, as we have hitherto seen him, as a single one, a unique one, to whom four others were joined, but as one of five, who was elected President by these. But it is incorrect that the inner A.-C. could just as well have chosen another as its chairman . . . Herzl was indisputably the leader, whether this institution was provided for in the Statute or not. In the face of this fact the remarks of Kokesch . . . have a painful effect, because in effect they disparage the one in favour of others."

The editors of "Die Welt" returned the article to Mr. Schachtel on 27 November 1904, and Doctor Werner wrote to him concerning the paragraph quoted as follows:

"Concerning your article I should like to say a few more words to you. In his article Dr. Kokesch certainly did not wish to disparage our late leader. He wished only to show that in theory, under the provisions of the Statute, another could also have been elected President. It is a question only