Page 4. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 52.
(continued from page 3)
…onto this ground I follow. I do not fight for ideas by feuding with persons, and I therefore spare myself the obvious answer to his remark that he hopes I am, "if no pure Zionist, at least no Ugandist." Such insinuations one smiles at.
What Dr. Deiches says of the English Jews, they must settle with him. There was no occasion for the whole of this reflection, for Dr. Deiches has thoroughly misunderstood the paragraph of my article to which his argument attaches. I spoke of the milieu in which the Actions Committee would find itself in London, of the conception of politics prevailing in England — not only among the Jews there. And my honoured opponent, too, will not dispute that these English conceptions are considerably more realistic and practical than those in Austria, where politics consists essentially in muddling along. The reaction upon our own policy would not fail to follow, for men are, after all, always only the fruit of their milieu, and of sobriety in the conception of our situation we can still use a good portion. The best proof of this is the article of Dr. Deiches. For when one makes the whole future of a movement depend on the attitude of three or four well-known English Zionists toward the much-discussed Uganda project, one proves that calm reflection ceases entirely at the beginning of a certain train of thought. For no one can doubt it: the political negotiations will, within a measurable time, be conducted above all in London, whether the A.-C. has its seat there or not. And since the negotiators must in the nature of things be Englishmen, as was indeed the case in Dr. Herzl's lifetime, the English leaders who are so vehemently attacked will have to be called in in any case. And when it is urged against me that "a purely sober view of things would mean the ruin of Zionism," because the ideal plays the chief part in our movement, Dr. Deiches confuses two very important things: leadership and organisation. The latter shall and must exhaust the ethical and ideal content of Zionism, inspire and educate the masses, seek to win public opinion and show the idea its way. But with this its task is exhausted. For the final attainment of our goal it can accomplish nothing whatever; that it must leave to the leadership, and the leadership must indeed be realistic, realistic to the utmost sobriety. Even then it will have hard enough a fight!
It is further said that, as regards the leading men of England, they would do what they mean to do even if the Inner A.-C. sat in Berlin, Vienna or Paris. I think not. A Jew living in England ought to know what a foreign accent does in negotiations with English Ministers. More might be said on this, from our own past too, but it would not touch the heart of the matter. That lies rather in the question whether we should for a time attach ourselves to the policy of one particular Great Power or not. And this I must affirm with the same decision with which Doctor Deiches denies it. He would turn to all countries, to all peoples; we must not give the appearance that our movement is a Jewish-English one. Very fine. Only I am realist enough not to believe that all peoples, all countries will help us. On someone we shall have to lean in preference. Let one read the section in Bismarck's "Reflections and Reminiscences" on what he says of "standing well with all the world." And when in the year 1805 the Prussian envoy von Haugwitz came to Napoleon to negotiate with him, the latter rounded on him: "I will tell you the cause of your misfortune: you want to be the friends of all the world." We must go with England, because no one else will go with us in the long run; the history of recent years teaches that sufficiently. But we cannot demand that anyone be our friend to whom we ourselves do not show a considerable measure of friendship. The only question, then, is whether we hold England to be better disposed toward us than the other Powers. And here even the most committed enemy of Uganda will have to admit that England has shown us the honest will to serve us, that she disposes of means of power and influence of decisive importance, and that we have every reason to hope she will continue to use both to our advantage. We need not on that account fall into complete dependence on English policy, nor sign ourselves over to it body and soul; there are, after all, not only extremes in life.
And when it is further said that I apparently overrate politics, that is not at all the case. Certainly we are also to pursue an internal policy. But, as already said above, internal policy, that is, the cultivation of the programme, is the business of the organisation; policy is the business of the leadership, and both must work without encroaching upon each other. I hold it positively most dangerous to speak of a restriction of political activity. The gentlemen who act thus have apparently lived through the last 7 years in vain. They do not seem to notice that they are declaring the movement bankrupt. Were these ideas to pass into practice, it would be said of us for the first time, and with justice, that we have "held back our hand," and people would whisper and murmur everywhere: "Since Herzl's death they despair of reaching the final goal, and that is why they now wish to lay the weight exclusively on internal work." We ought therefore not even to utter such inexpediencies, let alone have them printed.
Political reasons, then, by no means tell against London. What Herr Deiches further objects is of less account. The official language of the movement can be German as before. I have nowhere asserted that the Congresses should be transferred to England. This objection therefore falls away. Just as little have I put forward the absurd assertion that "only in London do there live men eager for work who would be fit to take over the leadership." It is the property of Dr. Deiches. I have asserted only that a number of such men are to be found in London, with or without Mr. Zangwill, and that I maintain.
When, finally, it is said that perhaps one might "experiment for a certain time" with Vienna, I would ask it to be considered that a political movement is, after all, no rabbit for experiment. The future seat of the movement must be decided, and then definitively, or else the work lacks the proper stability. A certain rootedness in one soil is for us a question of life, and I would even, on this consideration, be for Vienna as the seat of the leadership, were not the reasons against it too numerous: a political atmosphere antisemitic in the highest degree, a Christian society which boycotts the Jew and strives to press him down to a pariah, a Jewish milieu thoroughly averse to Zionism, which mocks it and against which even a Herzl had a hard stand, and in addition the "Viennese Gemütlichkeit" already mentioned earlier — all this and much else could be taken into the bargain together with the one great thing.