Page 6 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 48.
(continued from page 5)
…English Government, although he lived in Vienna? And was not the offer — regarded by a part of the Zionists as a new epoch in the history of the Jewish people since the beginning of the Exile — made by the English Government to the Zionist leadership, although the latter did not have its seat in the neighbourhood of Downing Street? "Influence upon the men at the helm" in England can thus be exerted just as well from Vienna as from London.
Let us, however, look soberly at what England has in reality done for Zionism up to now. From the standpoint of pure Zionism it must be said that what England has hitherto accomplished in our interest and offered us contains, not the furtherance, but the injury of Zionism. England's good will to help the Jewish people is not thereby to be doubted in the least. I speak of the effects upon Zionism. It is far from my purpose to open here, say, a fresh debate upon the East Africa project. But everyone will admit that East Africa is not Palestine, that it has brought about a great split in our camp and conjured up a dangerous crisis in the movement, a crisis that is far from over. Nor will I let anyone take from me the right to maintain that the East Africa project not only contains within it the dissolution of present-day Zionism, but also (as the exponent of the territorialist principle) endangers the whole future of the Jewish people. But even the most zealous Uganda partisan, who expects from the realisation of this project a relief of Jewish distress and the gathering of a part of the Jewish people, must admit that nothing has been done towards the attainment of Palestine by the offer of East Africa, which rather entails an endless postponement of that goal. Wad-el-Arish, which England wished to help us to, is not Palestine either. I much prefer that Bülow should say: "I do not believe in the possibility of realising your idea; I can do nothing for you," than that Chamberlain should say: "Well, I cannot help you to Palestine. But I will just see whether I cannot get you some other spot of earth." Whereas the former leaves the Zionist principle untouched, the latter breaks through it and gives the course of the history of the Jewish people a new direction, one to be rejected from the Zionist standpoint. That England, moreover, in her East Africa offer, was not animated solely by interest in the Jewish people is shown also by the words which Sir Harry Johnston wrote in his letter of September 29 to Mr. Greenberg. He says, among other things: "I do not think under proper safeguards that this gift will be more than a judicious speculation on our part" (I do not think that under secure guarantees this gift will be more than a shrewd speculation on our side).
But I believe that Dr. Friedemann altogether overrates the importance of politics for Zionism. What we must chiefly cultivate is internal policy: to spread and deepen the idea of Zionism in the midst of our own people as far as possible, to convince all Jews of the historical necessity of Zionism, to cultivate the Jewish intellectual element, to do everything that can lead to the furtherance of these endeavours, and above all to hold fast to our programme. It must be emphasised in the sharpest manner, inwardly and outwardly, that our movement is not a philanthropic one, nor yet a colonial one, but a Jewish-Palestinian-national one. We wish to revive the Jewish people in the old Jewish land, for its own welfare and that of all mankind. And our foreign policy must consist chiefly in rousing the conscience of all nations, interesting all States in our cause and securing their support. We appeal to all countries alike. From the standpoint of policy, therefore, it must be immaterial to us where the seat of our leadership is. When Vienna became the seat of the Smaller A.-C., that came about because Dr. Herzl lived there. It was no political considerations that led to Vienna. Zionism, as it were, created its centre for itself. Although our leadership was in the capital of Austria it stood equally near to all the Powers. And when the Powers conducted negotiations with Dr. Herzl, it was not the Austrian Government of which they thought even in the remotest degree, but solely the representation of the Zionist body. But if we are now to transfer the centre to a city with the express emphasis that we wish to have a place "which has resonance, a population inclined towards Zionism, a lively political pulse," and "whose Government maintains lively relations with the leadership of our movement," it may appear to the other Powers as though our cause were no longer a purely Jewish one, but a quasi Jewish-English one, which would naturally be by no means advantageous for our movement. We might then have to feel, not the advantages, but the disadvantages of English world politics.
Further reasons of an external nature that may be urged against London are the following: London is not in the centre of Europe in the sense that Vienna, Berlin or even Paris is, and is not so easily reached by our brethren in the East as the cities named. Further, it must be borne in mind that hitherto the official language of the Zionist Organisation has been German, which is intelligible also to most Jews outside Germany and Austria. Upon any transfer of the centre to London, English would involuntarily take the place of German. But in view of the very small number of Jews who understand English (a very large percentage of those living in England included), that would be not only an injustice but an impossibility. I, for example, can by no means conceive of an English "Welt," nor of a Congress conducted in English. This point alone ought to decide for a German-speaking country. Much else could be urged against London, which, however, I will pass over, so as not to let the article grow over-long.
I come now to the personal reasons, and here I believe I may be somewhat briefer. Dr. Friedemann holds: "But the first precondition for successful work by the leadership is that the seat of the movement be transferred to a city in which a number of capable men, eager to work, reside," and says further: "And there (in London), too, five men can be found — I purposely name no names within the compass of this article — who are fitted to take over the leadership." Very well; Dr. Friedemann would be content if one Russian member were added to three Englishmen. As fifth member our fellow Zionist of Cologne might figure, who, however, would not live in London. So the "men eager to work" who would be capable "of taking over the leadership" are to be found only in London. And from these men the future leader is to emerge. "And the strongest personality of the Inner A.-C. to be newly elected would, in close collaboration, quickly attain that leading position which would very soon lead also to an outward recognition as head of the movement." And Dr. Friedemann knows, too, what we need, what