No. 47. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 7.
On the Question of Organisation.
(The Question of the Future Leadership of the Movement.)
Vienna or London?
In No. 45 of "Die Welt" Dr. Friedemann deals with the question, of interest to all, whether Vienna should remain, as before, the headquarters of the Zionists.
This question is of great interest to us. Above all it is a question of tradition. In the course of eight years, during which this city has become the centre of the entire Zionist movement, Vienna has not only taken a considerable place in the history of our people, but it also enjoys great popularity among the Jewish masses in whose midst we work.
Who does not know how easily traditions arise among us which soon afterwards pass into our flesh and blood? We cannot easily renounce them. We were able to see something similar in the choice of a place for the Congress. When our assembly moved to London in the year 1900, and when, after the Fifth Congress, there was talk of Amsterdam, The Hague and other places, the "change" found no favour with the great majority, not only of those taking part in the Congress, but of the electors as well. Such a view naturally bears a purely sentimental character. But like Dr. Friedemann, I too reckon with the fact that the cadres of our movement are made up of the persecuted Jewish masses, who live almost as much by sentiment as by cool reason. Basle and Vienna have already taken so firm a place in our thoughts and hopes that we are accustomed to regard these cities as the residences of our politically reviving people. These places, with whose names so much that is glorious and great is bound up for us, have become those fixed points about which the hitherto formless Jewish mass has begun the process of its crystallisation. The removal of these "centres of crystallisation" will call forth a shock among the Zionist masses. Wandering, and the carrying of the tent from place to place, so often darken our life that Zionism alone, with its firm organisation and its permanent centres, can offer us some illusion of repose and concentration. Are we, then, to wander eternally with Zionism too? All this is doubtless sentimental, but I repeat, the sentimental includes a force with which we must of necessity reckon when we have to do with a people of tradition, with a sensitive people par excellence.
For those of our fellow Zionists who acknowledge the part played by feeling in the political sphere, the following consideration will also be of importance. In Vienna lived and worked the man who transformed the city of Vienna for us Jews from a city "of Gemütlichkeit" into a city that held the best and loftiest hopes of the people. And the mighty force of his immortal genius was so great that he was able to lend his authority to those men and institutions which reflect the afterglow of his gigantic spirit. Dr. Friedemann is certainly right when he says that Herzl "enjoyed an almost idolatrous veneration among the people"; and this veneration is growing and becoming with many people a kind of faith, which strikes deep root in their hearts. There where Herzl's spirit hovers, his influence comes and will come into effect. I therefore believe that in Vienna a considerable part of the authority which the great departed enjoyed among us makes itself felt. Whatever shall be concluded in Vienna, whatever shall proceed from Vienna, will appear to the Jewish masses, who devoutly honour his memory, as the direct continuation of his work. These masses will not feel the change that has come about so painfully.
I proceed, however, to grounds of reason, while reserving the significance of the imponderables adduced above.
I will not enter into the point that Vienna, thanks to its German language and geographical position, corresponds in far greater measure to the practical interests of our movement than distant London, where the leading men proposed by Dr. Friedemann would probably not be in a position, even during the Congresses, to address us in a language understood by the majority. Let us suppose that these are mere trifles.
But the reason adduced by Dr. Friedemann in favour of London as a political centre congenial to our aspirations is far from a trifle. It would seem to me that precisely this view speaks against the choice of London. The disposition of the political interests of Zionism is still far from clear enough. In the eight years of work now past, Zionism has, in the political respect, only formed connections. It has entered into no coalitions. Indeed, I believe that Zionism, in its political sense, will never enter into coalitions, if that can be said at all of our movement, which disposes of no external power. With us it can only be a matter of protectorates, but any single protectorate could only harm Zionism, especially the protectorate of a Power whose political interests stand in a certain opposition to the interests of other rival Powers. Zionism must maintain with the greatest care an absolutely neutral position among the political factors of the present, the neutrality which Herzl knew how to preserve for it. By neutrality we of course understand here a certain reserve, so that our interests may not be chained, in any single or even excessively favoured manner, to the interests of any one of the existing political factors. In fact, however, we must tack between the complicated system of various dependencies. A blunder here might be fraught with danger. That is what makes the reason adduced by Dr. Friedemann for London appear in my eyes as an argument against London.
Nor can I agree with Dr. Friedemann in this, that London offers a far simpler and easier way out of the difficulties that have arisen among us with regard to the choice of the leading men. In his opinion three persons could be found in London. Certainly, had he named them, one might argue with him; but since nomina odiosa sunt, I abide by my opinion that it would be much easier to find three men in Vienna, where there are men who have gone through the wonderful school, where there are men who worked with Herzl for 8–9 years; devoted men, and no less capable than the candidates in London (I was thinking of all the candidates whom Dr. Friedemann could name). I should like further to point to Dr. Friedemann's defective consistency. In Vienna he insists on looking for five persons and declares that they are not to be had; in London he looks for only three persons and finds them. Had Dr. Friedemann been willing to look for only three men in Vienna too, he would have found them without difficulty. I find them in any case there and
