Page 14 — "Die Welt" — No. 46
Mandelbaum, Baruch, זרע יצחק ("The Seed of Isaac"), containing Aggada and Halacha. Part I, 167, p. 4. Printed by B. Frumkin, published by the author, all in Jerusalem.
Living in modest retirement, devoted exclusively to his studies, the author, although he is counted among the foremost scholars of Jerusalem, now steps before a wider public for the first time. Rabbi B Mandelbaum, commonly called the "Turower Rov", settled in Palestine some 30 years ago, after having previously resigned his office in the community named (Russia). Since that time, on a meagre pension granted him by the said community, his sole occupation has been "learning". The ripe fruits of these many years of toil are to be made gradually accessible to wider circles. One may look forward especially to the responsa which are in the author's possession. They contain a veritable treasure of learning. The present part already bears ample witness to the depth and breadth of his knowledge. It is divided into gates (שערים) and treats of: a) צדקה ומצות ("charity and commandments"); b) משפט ("judgment"); c) איסור והיתר ("the forbidden and the permitted") ...; d) גבאי צדקה ("wardens of charity") and e) קץ הימין ("the end of days"). The work, which very often takes occasion to praise the pure, God-devoted piety and the boundless charitable spirit of the late Baron Karl W. v. Rothschild, who decades ago granted the author a dwelling free of charge in the Holy City, bears the name of this immortal philanthropist at its head. Printing and get-up leave nothing to be desired. The proceeds of the work are to help defray the cost of printing the other parts. It is to be hoped that this pious wish will be fulfilled.
May it be granted to the learned author to live to see the time in which he awaits, with decided certainty, the redemption of Judaism (שער ה).
Jerusalem.
Dr. Grünhut.
Feuilleton.
Judaism and German Art.
In the Berlin "Börsen-Courier" of October 29th, Georg Hermann publishes the following article, which we reproduce for the present without comment.
"In the new weekly 'Der Deutsche', Ludwig Brehm deals with Judaism in German art. If this work were abuse on a grander scale, it would hardly be necessary to honour it with a reply. But precisely because it takes pains to give reasons and counter-reasons, precisely because, under the appearance of thorough expert knowledge, it builds false conclusions upon false premises — precisely this compels us to refute it.
The author himself was probably none too comfortable when he wrote it. For with any sense of logic he must have seen that, with each next artist he treats, he extols as special merits of his gift the very defects he censures in the one before; that when at the close he draws the balance as to the artistic endowment of the Jewish race or its influence upon German art, he ought really to have found proven all that which it seemed his task and most sacred duty to prove lacking.
Let us go somewhat more closely into the contents of his work.
Brehm first of all attempts to justify from what "German" sentiment Germany has thus far set up no monument to one of her foremost poets, namely Heinrich Heine. He relates that he was himself present at that meeting of the town councillors in Düsseldorf, of immortal disgrace, which refused the monument to Heine. We are speaking here only of principles. For whether Heine receives a monument or not is absolutely a matter of indifference. In Germany one may come by a monument without knowing how, just as the jockey comes by a broken collar-bone. Monuments in Germany, moreover, have so utterly inartistic a character that one really need not be agitated over the lack of a Heine monument. What astonished me all the more, however, is the schoolboyish criticism which Brehm passes on Heine himself. Precisely that he can find nothing further to say in his praise than to point to the unique beauty of his songs shows, in truth, how infinitely remote from Heine he stands, and how he simply does not see, or will not see, all the germs of the modern that slumber in him. It is not the Heine who wrote the "Buch der Lieder" who is of value to us to-day, it is not he who has exerted influence down to the present day, but that other Heine whom I will call "the first modern man"; he who sounded the great notes of social lyric in the "Weavers' Song", who in "Poor Lazarus" told of all the pains of a suffering, sick soul, who in "Pomare" depicted a life that ends in the gutter and that is yet forgiven in spite of all its sinfulness; that Heine in whom a piece of Hellenism lived on, and who on his last outing dragged himself to our beautiful Lady of Milo. Of him, I believe, Brehm has heard little and understood less. And one may be assured that if Heine had written only those beautiful songs which Herr Brehm so praises, a German poet who is truly a "poet" and at the same time a "German" — namely Richard Dehmel — would not have raised to him in words that wonderful Heine monument in which one may also read:
And at the left, at the baptised Jew's feet,
sniffing and blinking at his stick, there squats
— I would propose, of Rhenish iron quartz —
a fat swine, the true German domestic swine.
Make me this swine right truly true and fine,
as this great artist merits; and
forget me not the bristles, either!
Having now set up Heine as the prototype of the Jewish artist, and having cried in the tone of deep conviction, "he lacks earnestness, he lacks the reverence which has ever filled the true German artist with a sense of responsibility, because he feels his art to be in the most intimate connection with the welfare of the people as a whole", Brehm now attempts — not quite so clumsily, of course — to demonstrate all these qualities in the Jewish plastic artist of German nationality.
First, however, he must acknowledge that, in proportion to the number of German Jews, there is an unusually high percentage of able, leading artists, and he is at any rate so obliging as not to deny their importance.
At the head of Jewish artistic creation in Germany to-day stands Max Liebermann. "Liebermann," says Brehm, "seized upon the new naturalistic tendency, which fully corresponded to the natural naturalistic character of his race. For the exercise of the knowledge he had gained he found the fitting place in the atmospheric wonders of Holland." Very well! That is correct. And if that is correct, how can Brehm demand of Liebermann the bright and luminous words that break, say, like fanfares from the pictures of a Boecklin? Boecklin was bright and luminous because the home of his Alpine air was Switzerland. Liebermann is comparatively colourless, is grey, because as a modern he carries on the line of the old Dutch art of the 17th century, the line of Rembrandt, which found its continuation in Israels. And Boecklin is luminous because his art offers a mixture of the elements he took over from the Florentine Quattrocentists, from the early Netherlanders and from the Flemings. And the one simply excludes the other. Each, however, has as much right of domicile on his own soil as the other. That, incidentally, Brehm's assertion is refuted a hundredfold by Liebermann's latest works, which are extraordinarily colourful, I will not even go into. Just as his words, that in Liebermann the lingering delight in details of tone and colour is lacking, tell only of the insufficiently trained eye of the writer, and that another reproach, such as that Liebermann daubed, is really so amateurish that I, after a few sensible thoughts which in