Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 46 · 11 November 1904
15printed page
scan 15 of 20

No. 46 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 15

(continued from page 14)

…find in the argument, would not have expected. Old Rembrandt daubed too, and thundered at the art-rabble the pretty saying: "My pictures are not there to be sniffed at!"

But it is far from my intention to read Herr Brehm a course in aesthetics. Though it would really be necessary, for one would think the writer had never looked at a picture by Liebermann, when he says that for sheer distraction the great total impression vanishes. If he maintains this of a "Woman with the Goat" and before ten other Liebermann pictures that can be named to him, nothing remains for us but to recommend him an operation on his eyes or to doubt his good faith.

And when Brehm plays off Boecklin against Liebermann, and sees in the one merely technical mastery while in the other he feels a rushing wing-beat of fancy, he really shows that he has never properly looked at either; and that he has never made clear to himself how a picture comes into being with Boecklin and how with Liebermann. We have, indeed, from the faithful diaries of Boecklin's pupils documents which read quite otherwise than the fanciful Boecklin worshippers would so gladly have it, and which present themselves solely as an earnest struggle with the technical. "In the line of Boecklin," says Brehm, "lies German art." Boecklin in all honour, but what have his imitators achieved thus far? And has not modern art, in the fine-nerved sensibility of its feeling for colour, already gone far beyond Boecklin? And lastly this everlasting talk of the Germanness of Boecklin, who was so good a German that he could feel at ease only in Italy, and in whose art there lives at least as much Hellenic sensuousness and Romance splendour of colour as there is anything German in it!!

But let us hold fast for once to this: that Liebermann has no colour, no fancy, but can draw instead; for that the draughtsman's talent is unusually strongly developed in Liebermann, that he is one of our best draughtsmen, Herr Brehm will grant me, provided that Liebermann's drawings, which are indeed preserved in abundance in the museums, have ever come into his hands.

And let us then pass to Lesser Ury, whom Brehm treats in the second place. Lesser Ury is a colourist, on Brehm's own testimony, so colourism must surely lie within the domain of Jewish art. Ury's pictures are inadequate in their total composition, which cannot be asserted of Liebermann's pictures, but in return they have the fanciful element that Liebermann is said to lack.

But how, then, does Brehm's assertion stand, when he finally cites as a Jewish artist Max Slevogt, of whom he himself admits that he unites the merits of both and is moreover by no means un-German, that he achieves extraordinary things as a draughtsman, is a strong, sensuous colourist, and, thirdly and lastly, also possesses the gift which Brehm would gladly deny to the Jews, namely that of an organically creative fancy? Or will Brehm deny the importance of the excellent illustrations to Ali Baba? Ah, if only he would not always pass such infinitely amateurish judgments, this Herr Brehm. "Because," he writes, "he" (namely Slevogt) "lacks the secret of finishing, none of his important works bears the stamp of completion." In every older history of art Brehm will find the remark that Rembrandt's glorious Brunswick family picture is unfinished, and yet we know to-day that it is as complete as could not be conceived more rounded and self-contained, and that every further stroke of Rembrandt's brush would have been blasphemy against the divine revelation of his art.

But as for what Brehm says of Thomas Theodor Heine — that through this unusually witty, nay, gifted satirist of the pencil caricature has run wild — that is an utterance which flies in the face of all the facts. If our caricature has ever acquired style through any artist, if it has become, as Brehm says, a kind of graphic script, it has become so solely through the strongly stylish and large-minded art of Thomas Theodor Heine. And one would like to give the author the counsel again and again: see a little more and talk a little less!

And it has a positively ludicrous effect when Brehm closes his argument: "He who is just must acknowledge that the Jewish artists in the domain of German art have worked as a fermenting, disintegrating, and, especially in technical matters, as a forward-driving force. And such 'negative' forces (since when is a forward-driving force negative?) are necessary to preserve our nature from torpor. But there is a limit here, beyond which they must bring ruin to our positive, creative gifts, and this limit has long been overstepped." And now Herr Brehm prescribes to German art the direction it must take. Ah, it will trouble itself little about that! Above all, however, I believe Herr Brehm is mistaken. Among the artistic qualities of the Jew, which Herr Brehm indeed acknowledges, and which have hitherto probably not all appeared united in one person, but have found expression only in individual artists, such as Veit, Liebermann, Heine, Slevogt, Lesser Ury, Pisarro, Antokolski and so forth — and have found expression, moreover, in thoroughly self-creative minds — among these qualities there is not one that is not equally peculiar to the German race. But why talk?! I am convinced that if Arnold Boecklin had chanced to be a Jew, Herr Brehm would reject as un-German him before whom he now expires in uncritical enthusiasm.


Animals — and Jews.

Oxen and other beasts are allegedly to be spared pain, in order that pain may be inflicted on the Jews. We mean the question of shechita, which has now been raised in the Lower Austrian Diet.

The Provincial Committee of the Diet has put forward the following motions: "1. The Imperial-Royal Government is requested to issue a prohibition with regard to the practice of shechita, or rather with regard to the practice of commercial slaughtering without previous stunning of the animal. 2. The Lower Austrian Provincial Committee is instructed to report to the Diet at the next session on the result of the negotiations to be conducted with the Government in this matter." These motions have been laid before the Diet for deliberation and resolution.

The proposal to forbid the Jews the ritual slaughter of animals in Lower Austria is justified in a long-winded report of the Provincial Committee. The authors of the report, who are animated by the wish to accomplish once again a great deed of "Practical Antisemitism", put on a sanctimonious air and declare in honest-seeming tones: Let no one believe that our action is prompted by hatred of the Jews! Heaven forbid! On the contrary, our motion is dictated by love for the suffering animals. We merely wish to do away with a cruelty to animals!"

The blubbery compassion for the pitiable cattle with which the report of the Provincial Committee is larded appears all the more ludicrous when one learns that the real spiritual author of the whole action is a gentleman who once proposed that a "shooting-bounty" be set on the head of every Jew. How gentle a soul must be by nature, what tender and heartfelt sympathy with all creatures it must feel, how deeply