Page 4 — "Die Welt" — No. 45
(continued from page 3)
…English judge will declare such a thing legally valid?
But, the gentlemen will say, the Bank's statute and the other instruments can of course be amended in this respect as well. Well, who does not know how difficult such amendments are to carry through? Who does not know that ever since the Third Congress the amendment of Point 1, Paragraph III of the Bank Memorandum (the restriction of colonisation to Palestine and Syria) has been striven for, and that there is not yet even a beginning of its actual execution?
One sees that the ruinous shocks are becoming ever plainer. And why are all these difficult amendments to be carried through? So that nine gentlemen living in different places can pull at the Zionist cart, or so that the President of the Bank's Board of Directors can become his own Board of Supervision! No, gentlemen, there is nothing to save! There is only one thing: Do not destroy! Hands off! *)
Dr. Oser Kokesch.
The Future Direction of the Movement.
When we left Vienna after the last session of the Greater Actions Committee, it was in the expectation that a great and comprehensive discussion would now begin on all sides about the future direction of the orphaned party. We had seen in Vienna how thoroughly unclarified opinions were in this respect, and we knew that a public exchange of views was most necessary. For the future of the movement must not be decided by a Congress debate, which in the nature of things is inadequate. It is rather necessary that the delegates form an opinion by mature reflection before the assembly. This may then be modified at Basle after the exchange of views; it must not first come into being under the impression of skilful rhetoric and influenced by the state of excitement that is wont to accompany our Congresses.
Instead, the discussion drags wearily on. Some drafts of organisation have been published, which may please one or another better or worse. But in them, too, the most important thing stands only between the lines. All of them are cut more or less to decentralisation, to a division of the powers which hitherto the one man united in his hand. And from all of them speaks the feeling that it will be impossible to find an authoritative personality to take Herzl's place. Hence Dr. Bodenheimer proposes executive committees, Marmorek the sections, and Hantke and Klee even wish for complete decentralisation under the individual responsibility of the heads of departments.
It seems that we ought first to examine whether the movement will bear such a decentralisation, and only then whether the personalities are lacking that must be at hand for the retention of a central administration. I know well that as a rule the opposite way is taken, and the question of persons is discussed first, then that of centralisation or decentralisation weighed. But that is by no means right. We are not so poor in capable men that we must commit practical inexpediencies. Perhaps there is no one in the party against whom one or another would not have something to object. But we have hitherto been spoiled and should not always apply the strictest standard. The Electio quasi per inspirationem is a rarity even in Rome, and at the moment we need no geniuses at all, but capable men with clear, sober understanding, honesty and diligence. And these are to be found.
What, then, does the movement need above all? We think, above all, a man who will seize the reins of direction with a strong hand.
The plans mentioned above may be well and good for other parties, which do not have to reckon, as we do, with masses little schooled in politics. For us neither governing committees nor directing commissions are suitable, for the masses want a name! They want a flag in the fight, a banner to which all look when the bullets whistle and the ground shakes. They want the personification of their ideas and their hopes, an embodiment of the movement in a name. If Theodor Herzl enjoyed an almost idolatrous veneration among the people, a very great part of it was certainly owing to his singular personality. But the circumstance that he was the leader also contributed its good share to that feeling. I am firmly convinced that people will bring more good will to a new leader, even a moderately gifted one, than to the best-working committee, on which lies the odium of impersonality and which will therefore always lack popularity.
And one thing more determines me to oppose a splintering of the powers of the President of our A.C. I am, namely, convinced that the committees will not work well. There will be endless conflicts of competence. Personal questions will play a vexatiously large part. The furtherance of the idea will at times fall behind private interests — we have indeed already had to undergo sad experiences more than once.
Besides this — especially with a decentralisation of the administration under the individual responsibility of the heads of departments — it will be uncommonly difficult to maintain the necessary unity and to impress upon them the consciousness of the need for working together. All this will be confirmed by anyone who has had occasion to occupy himself practically with questions of administration. My German friends think they can point, in support of their contrary view, to the example of the German organisation. But they forget that the German leaders have all known one another well for many years, stand in friendly relations with one another, and that German Zionism is without essential contradictions in its intellectual character. Moreover, almost the whole of the work is done by the Berlin bureau. What is good for Germany, therefore, need not be right for the whole.
Perhaps many a one who takes the trouble to read this essay will agree with me, but will ask sadly who, then, is to be put forward for the centralised direction. And here I must indeed declare: I too do not know whether we possess a wholly suitable personality. But that we cannot survey at all today. Nor is it a question of bringing such a man to the head of the movement overnight,
*) A second article with concrete proposals follows.