Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 45 · 4 November 1904
5printed page
scan 5 of 20

No. 45. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.

(continued from page 4)

…but rather to create the precondition whereby, in a centralized Actions Committee, men of vigour may find a suitable field of activity and the opportunity to secure, by the superiority of their personality, a decisive influence. And in a decentralized administration that is as good as ruled out.

The first precondition for successful work on the part of the leadership, however, is that the seat of the movement be removed to a city in which a number of able men, eager for work, reside, and which at the same time forms a real political centre. Vienna, in my judgment, cannot remain the seat of the central office, and would never have become so had Dr. Herzl not lived there. Vienna has long ceased to be one of the places in which European policy is made; it is, moreover, so poor in capable workers that it would cost great pains even to bring the present inner A.-C. — whose unselfish labours hitherto we by no means underrate — up to five members. The place in which the leadership of our movement resides must, however, have resonance, a population inclined towards Zionism, a lively political pulse, and a temper very different from the "Gemütlichkeit" of Vienna. Such a place, however, exists but once in Europe, namely in the country whose Government in any case maintains lively relations with the leadership of our movement. I mean London.

There live Jewish working masses; there is the centre of present-day world politics, and with it the opportunity of personal influence upon the leading men; there prevails an earnest, businesslike, sober view of things, which is a guarantee of a realistic conception of the position of our movement.

And there, too, five men may be found — I purposely name no names within the compass of this article — who are fit to assume the leadership. But in my view we should confine ourselves to the election of only three Englishmen, and complete the inner A.-C. with a Russian member, who would have to take up his residence in London. I believe that one or another Russian fellow Zionist will make the sacrifice of removal for the sake of his conviction; the entry of a trusted representative of the Russian organization into the inner A.-C. would assuredly strengthen its authority in an extraordinary degree. Only in favour of the fifth member of the A.-C. would the principle of centralization have to be broken. The entry of that fellow Zionist of Cologne who was the confidant of our dead leader appears to me important enough to admit an exception in his favour. Besides, the gentleman in question is so often in London on the business of the Bank that no hindrance to the work need be feared from his absence.

In this way a sweeping change of the organization could be avoided. And the strongest personality of the inner A.-C. to be newly elected would, in close collaboration, quickly attain that leading position which would very soon lead also to an outward recognition as leader of the movement.

I hope that this proposal will give occasion for a discussion. The sooner opinions are clarified, the easier will agreement be later on.

Dr. Friedemann.


Letter from Berlin.

We now stand shortly before the elections to the Assembly of Representatives. No clash of arms announces the "coming day of moment." Quiet and peace have for years characterized Jewish public life and the Jewish communities. Whenever any party threatens to disturb the quiet by raising its voice more loudly and demanding a special position for itself, it is called to order by being reminded of Jewish concord, and of the danger that threatens from without if differing views on certain points should prevail among the Jews. We are the very last who should underrate Jewish concord, overlook its great historical significance, or mistake its necessity for our present preservation. But one must not identify with Jewish concord — which in the hour of danger and of struggle with our enemies reconciles and strengthens all — that quiet in Jewish communal life which is merely the consequence of indifference, of indifferentism. In larger communities an entirely uniform opinion can never prevail. The more many-sided the life of a larger community, the greater the diversity of opinion. The soundlessness of Jewish communal life signifies the passing of the direction of public affairs from the people to oligarchs, the lowering of the level of public affairs from the collective interests of the Jewish community to a few more or less unimportant administrative activities. The elections in the Jewish communities therefore now regularly take place, properly speaking, behind the scenes, without any livelier general interest, without clamour and without struggle.

The low voices which now make themselves heard before the elections come from the two principal camps into which Judaism has everywhere been divided since the Mendelssohnian epoch, which formerly fought one another with the greatest bitterness, but have now for the most part lost their former sharpness: from the Liberals and the Conservatives.

We must by no means mistake the historic mission of the liberal tendency in Judaism; the inner liberation from the Ghetto is undoubtedly chiefly its merit. But we know all too well, too, the grievous injuries which Judaism has suffered from it. Liberalism estranged the Jews more and more from their people, and in its consequences led to wholesale apostasy.

Remarkably enough, a strengthening of the defeated conservative party may be observed in the latest period. We shall trace the historical development of this phenomenon another time; for the present let it suffice us to point to a few facts. Since the fifties the Conservatives have begun to raise themselves up again and to gain in power. This movement is not entirely correctly described as reaction, inasmuch as this orthodoxy appears in fairly broad forms, which do not disguise the influence of the new age. "Fidelity to the Law combined with modern culture" is the motto of the chief representatives of orthodoxy: a Samson Rafael Hirsch, a Fränckel, a Hildesheimer and others. Their most important weapons are, like those of Liberalism, the periodical and the school. Besides the rabbinical seminaries in Breslau and Berlin, secondary and higher schools are founded for the male and female youth, in which — in contrast to the long-established Jewish institutions, in which Hebrew instruction has in the course of time ceased entirely and religious instruction almost wholly, and which have in general lost their Jewish character altogether — to instruction in the Hebrew language and in religion, with use of the sources in the original, a comparatively large