Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 45 · 4 November 1904
2printed page
scan 2 of 20
Facsimile · scan 2 of 20
Scan of p. 2
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 2 — "Die Welt" — No. 45

Can it be said that such an organisation was cut to Herzl's measure? By no means; it is fitted to the character of the movement, not to a person.

The provision, too, that the five members of the Inner A.C. must be domiciled in the same city was made not out of regard for Herzl's person, but in the consideration that so great a movement cannot be directed by a body whose members live in different places. Had this provision been called forth out of regard for Herzl's person, it would, as has been said, have had to state that the five members must live in Vienna.

Now to the proposed amendments themselves. The most important amendment, proposed both by I. W. Marmorek and by Klee and Hantke, is decentralisation. The gentlemen will perhaps resist this description; but their proposal means nothing else. For even if they wish formally to leave the direction in the hands of a body, the A.C., they nevertheless give this A.C. an entirely different character. It is to consist of nine persons, who may live in different places and each of whom administers a department independently. The provision that these persons shall meet once a quarter for deliberation does not yet give this body the character of a unified direction. There are nine directing persons, each of whom works for the most part independently of the others.

What in all the world is there, then, that should make so sweeping a measure, a rending asunder of the central direction, necessary? Two reasons are given for it. A negative one: that the form hitherto existed only out of regard for Herzl's person and must fall with him; and a positive one: that only in this way can capable persons be drawn in who do not happen to live in one and the same place. The first reason has already been shown to be untrue. The second, too, is not sound, nor is it important enough to deprive our movement, on its account, of the central direction, which is surely more important still. It is not sound, because able men — even if they do not sit at the centre — can be drawn in for counsel and work, as has been done hitherto (see Nordau, Katzenelson, Cowen, Greenberg, etc.), and because by the principle of remuneration, as Zangwill, Simon and Pasmanik have already recommended, the obstacle of place can in many cases be removed as well. It is not important, because — an example will best demonstrate it — a hay-wagon reaches its goal sooner when three farm horses draw it with united strength in the same direction than when it is harnessed to nine Arab horses, each of which pulls at its own trace.

But we have not nine Arab horses at our disposal at all! It is well known that we do not produce many geniuses; on the other hand, even envy must grant us that we possess talents and workers enough. If it is believed that more capable forces are to be found in London, Paris or Berlin than in Vienna, there is no obstacle to establishing the A.C. in one of these cities. The Organisation Statute prescribes no particular city. Moreover — as already mentioned — in so great a cause removals could also be brought about.

As for the division into departments, no amendment of the Organisation Statute is needed on that account. It admits such a division quite well; at the least it does not forbid it. And in fact such a division existed and exists in the present A.C. — which the movers, surprisingly, seem not to know. Apart from foreign policy, which was the province of the late Doctor Herzl, Kremenezky has the National Fund, Marmorek the press, Kahn culture and Hebraica, the writer of these lines internal affairs and finance. The report on legal matters is shared by the two last named. The movers, to be sure, wish the Congress itself to elect the heads of the several departments. But is that desirable? One would think that the members of the A.C., who work together, would know better how to assess one another's abilities for the several departments than the Congress delegates, who come together once in two years and many of whom see the individual candidates for the A.C. for the first time.

But decentralisation is not only not necessary and not useful; it is positively dangerous. Our administrative departments cannot, as Dr. Pasmanik has rightly remarked, be directed quite independently and separately from one another, because nearly all of them interlock. The referent for internal affairs will forgo many an action in a given country when his colleague for foreign affairs shows him that it is against the political interests of the movement; in another case he will proceed boldly in agreement with his colleague. On the other hand, the referent for foreign affairs will be able to contribute much toward preventing disturbances of the internal organisation in a country if he is kept informed of these disturbances through constant intercourse with the referent for internal affairs. All the departments, the political included, depend upon the finances. Nothing important can be undertaken without being informed of the state of the finances. Our income and expenditure are still far from being so fixed that one could draw up a correct budget with even approximate probability and settle the allowances of the several departments at the beginning of the administrative period. And now eight "Dezernate" are to work independently and, of course, to dispose of the finances as well. One can imagine what sort of housekeeping would come of that? Whether under such circumstances anyone would be found willing to take on the responsibility for the financial administration is more than questionable. And one thing more: even the men of greatest genius are not infallible, and four eyes often see more than two. Through the constant deliberations of the heads of departments with one another, their knowledge, experience and judgment are widened, supplemented, often corrected, and each obtains as clear a picture as possible of the whole movement.

The Actions Committee hitherto, apart from its regular weekly sessions, often held deliberations every day. Often one member came into the session with a quite definite preconceived opinion and, through deliberation with his colleagues and the facts communicated, came away of an entirely different mind. Often, too, situations changed so quickly that in the afternoon a resolution was corrected which, in keeping with the situation then prevailing, had had to be taken in the morning of the same day.