Die Welt · Vol. VIII, No. 43 · 21 October 1904
5printed page
scan 5 of 20

No. 43. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.

That is nothing new; these principles were merely given shape and form in Pressburg . . ."

Dr. Adler (Lübeck), our highly esteemed fellow Zionist, one of the most competent men among the leaders of the "Misrachi," takes issue, in No. 41 of the "Jüdische Rundschau," in a lengthy and matter-of-fact discussion, with the grave objections which Dr. Jungmann had raised in an earlier number of the "Rundschau" against the founding of the Misrachi organisation. We take the following passages from this article:

. . . The Misrachi has not only now come into being. One would be justified in calling the formation of any new party within Zionism at the present moment a grave tactical error, since the existing conditions have become so difficult in every respect through the untimely passing, never sufficiently to be lamented, of our great leader, that every energy must be strained first of all to preserve what exists. But precisely from this there follows the imperative duty to work with all our might towards the consolidation of the organisation already in existence, for only from such an organisation can we expect an orderly plan of work and a purposeful activity of propaganda. It was out of the recognition of this necessity that the Misrachi, which has already been organised for some years, thought it well to come before the public with its programme at the Pressburg Conference.

The wording of § 1 in particular has given Dr. Jungmann occasion for censure. He finds questionable the standpoint of the Misrachists, who wish to hold fast first and foremost to tradition, and only in the second place emphasise the creation of a legally secured home in Palestine. From this wording he would infer that a Misrachist can at most be regarded as a Zionist Orthodox Jew, but not as an Orthodox Zionist. Would to God — and I believe Dr. Jungmann will join in this wish — that all our co-religionists were first made up of Zionist Orthodox or Liberals or of whatever shade you please; our cause would then already be helped far more . . .

Or should he really be the worse Zionist who will not let the religious element — which has unquestionably sustained Judaism through many centuries in times of the direst need — take second place to the national idea? It is surely agreed in all Zionist circles that, in order to raise up our people effectively, one must care not only for the ultimate Zionist aims, the creation of a legally secured home, but that we also need manifold preparatory labours, which shall enable our people to enter, with steeled body and ripened mind, into the competitive struggle of the nations. And if some seek to raise the strength of the people by founding gymnastic and choral societies, Toynbee Halls and the like, upon others lies the duty of reviving the old spirit of the people by strengthening the power of faith, by cultivating our old national literature, the language we have inherited, etc. Both place themselves in the service of truly national work, in the accomplishment of which one ought properly not to see any neglect of Zionist activity. It goes without saying that in our work we do not wish to go without the achievements of modern culture. If at the recent Pressburg Congress a voice really did speak disparagingly of the cultivation of modern science, the Misrachi can no more be held responsible for such a view than the Zionists in general could be held responsible for those unedifying debates, called forth by individual persons, which filled almost the whole of the first two days of the last Basle Congress. Incomprehensible to me remains the opinion of the reviewer that he would credit the Misrachi with propagating anti-Zionist ideas, inasmuch as he sees in the emphasis of the Orthodox standpoint an offence against the traditional law of the Congress. All convictions within the party, so his argument runs, are to be respected alike, but under no circumstances discussed. But, in the name of all the world, such a clause can surely refer only to the tribune of the Congress, and cannot possibly claim validity within the four walls of our own house! That would indeed be a coercion without parallel, and, hand on heart, which party in our midst could withstand such criticism? At the Congress, to be sure, all religious controversies ought to be silent. For my own part I should go still further and say that every religious dispute ought likewise to be struck out of our Zionist daily papers. To discuss the pending questions of the day in our national work in a calm and objective manner, without constraining the freedom of conscience of the individual — that would be the ideal of which I have dreamed. In a personal exchange of ideas on religious questions a far more conciliatory solution might be brought about . . .

. . . "The great power" of which the reviewer speaks, which will shortly march into the Congress in a closed phalanx, will never abuse its influence in order to proclaim from the tribune doctrines that might disturb our peace. Mutual tolerance is guaranteed; we shall hold this guarantee in honour. It was admittedly not we who threw the apple of discord into the assembly. Pressed by the Fraction, the Misrachi saw itself reluctantly obliged to take up, in a certain sense, a separate position. But it was bound to insist that its holiest feelings should in no way be wounded. If in such a case it defended its skin, even in the most energetic manner, then it was truly not the Misrachi that had struck a disagreeable note. Should the Misrachi in future indeed no longer have to take action in its own defence, none will greet this with greater joy than the Misrachi itself . . .

On the Misrachi question the author of the article "Achtung" ("Attention") sends us the following remarks:

The article which appeared under the title "Achtung" seems to have answered a need. This is proved by the strong echo which it has awakened in Zionist and other Jewish papers, and by the flood of letters for and against which it occasioned.

Those, however, are in error who describe this essay as a polemic against Orthodoxy. The article did not wish to be so understood. On the contrary, the author expressly guarded himself against such a misunderstanding. The article says, word for word:

"To prevent misunderstandings: these lines are by no means directed against Orthodoxy, or indeed against the Orthodox. They would just as