Page 2. — "Die Welt" — No. 39.
(continued from page 1)
…five — Jewish immigrants ought not to be urgently dissuaded from immigration to America, and, should that not suffice, whether measures ought not to be taken against it.
That is, of course, a childish proceeding, which has no conception whatever of the danger and the consequences of such a measure; but the thing is uncommonly characteristic, and the Jewish papers of America are unhappily not all sufficiently uninfluenced or well-informed to take a stand against it with all energy. There is no doubt that America will long have room enough and employment enough for immigrants, and it is not to be seen why obstacles should be laid in the way of precisely so active, capable and intelligent a section of the population as the Jews. All these misgivings would needs be scattered like chaff before the wind if an orderly immigration took place, if it were not to be feared that the newcomers would settle at a few points only, if care were taken to direct them to where they might find work for themselves without injuring others.
For this, too, is a pretext employed even by people who are allegedly free of all hatred of the Jews: that the native workman is undersold by the Jews and thereby depressed in his minimum of existence. Did not even the annual congress of the "Trades Unions" at Leeds lately greet such imputations with applause? We must not conceal from ourselves that we can offer counter-proof only on the basis of carefully compiled material. This material, however, cannot be furnished by a single individual, nor by one city or another, but only by a world organisation, which can bring forward evidence in figures because it is in a position to carry on the necessary inquiries in the bureaus of the several countries. The enemies of the Jews will not, indeed, be instructed thereby; but the states and countries will come to hear other than merely hostile voices.
Perhaps the journey of Mr. S. Berman, who was sent by the London "Jewish Board of Guardians" to the United States and to Canada to study the conditions for further Jewish immigration, may after all be welcomed as the beginning of a preventive activity. In itself it is of no particular value, since neither Mr. Berman nor the "Jewish Board of Guardians" alone is competent or able to decide so important a question. As an example of a more thorough treatment of this problem, however, Mr. Berman's journey is decidedly to be praised, even though we are fully aware of the insufficiency of the undertaking. We can therefore only point out again and again that this important question, perhaps at the moment the most important question of present-day work for our people, can be solved with prospect of success only by the Jewish community as a whole. We Zionists shall greet such a common action with joy and support it in every way. It shall not be our fault if the unworthy, dangerous and withal enormously costly methods of the present Jewish migration are retained in future as well, if the tireless labour of individuals upon the great problem grows weary, and if even the little that is now already being done is at length, in the course of time, no longer accomplished for want of interest, of helpful benefactors and of material means.
We hope, however, that our fellow Zionists, if no others, will ever anew revive interest in this question. If, thanks to the indifference of so many Jews, we cannot yet acquire our publicly and legally secured home, we shall at least try, besides much else, to take care that our wandering brethren need not perish in misery.
Dr. Siegm. Werner.
A Letter of Zangwill's on Zionism.
Mr. Zangwill recently addressed a letter to a largely attended Zionist meeting which took place on the 9th inst. in St. Andrews Hall, London. Zangwill's letter ran:
"I greatly regret that my newest work, which claims me wholly, made it impossible for me to appear upon your platform. But perhaps gam su letowa. This is now a very critical moment for our movement, and that which is worst said must soonest be amended. The air is full of unwise speeches. What we most need is unity; but unity cannot be attained if every man will hold his own conception alone to be Zionism.
"Zionism will be broad enough to embrace all conceptions, else it will lack the strength to translate any conception into deed. The whole strength of Jewry barely suffices for the solution of the problem Zionism has set; how are a few atoms to accomplish it! It is high time that the tail gave up its presumption of leading the dog.
"In the present state of affairs it is very necessary to call to mind what our movement really is. The shrewd definition of the 'Misrachi,' that their Zionism is Zionism plus something else, that is to say, plus the religious element, proves clearly that Zionism does not essentially coincide with religious aims. It is, as it always was, a political movement. Indirectly, to be sure, it serves the cause of Judaism far more than most synagogues; but on its outward side it must be taken as purely political. Any other way of treating it would be its ruin.
"As Zionism is no religious movement, so neither is it an East African one. It is bound to no other place than Palestine. But neither is it excluded from any place, if this or that place can serve the great end of our political restoration by accustoming us to lead a life of our own, by helping to gather our forces for the last migration, and by accumulating political capital to smooth the way to our final resting-place. If nineteen centuries of vegetating and inaction cannot be effaced in one generation, we should be happy if our generation had the fortune to see the beginning of the end, if it were granted us to serve the future. It has been said that Russia worked slowly towards Constantinople for centuries. If we are once to become political, then we must also acknowledge the factor of slowness which politics involves, and recognise the necessity of the united labour of generations.
"And as Zionism is no East Africa movement, still less is it one for the colonies in Palestine. Chovevei-Zionism has been tried