No. 39. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3.
(continued from page 2)
…and has proved deficient. Between colonies under a capricious rule and some measure of self-government in East Africa under the British flag, no reasonable man would hesitate in his choice. Begging in Palestine is not yet politics, and it cannot be emphasised strongly enough that politics is the breath of our life. "A publicly and legally secured home" is the pivot of the Basle Programme, whose zealous adherents they declare themselves to be who are now ready to work for a private, illegal, unrecognised dwelling-place, from which they may be expelled within a week, if only it be in Palestine.
"I hope in all earnestness that the next Congress will be able to see from the data which the East Africa Commission will bring whether the land offered us suits us, and whether we possess the labour-power needed for the cultivation of the land.
"Until we have these data before us, we cannot express ourselves upon this point; some, however, appear to have overcome this impossibility in a certain measure.
"I greatly fear, nevertheless, that owing to our own hesitation, caused in part by the illness and death of our great leader, a golden opportunity slipped from us, and that we therefore stand now, as heretofore, before the closed door of Palestine. I know not what peculiar charm lies in the contemplation of a closed door. We may all hope that the New Year will bring more light upon our ways and blessing upon our work, and that the Day of Atonement will lead us also to atonement. Although Zionism is merely a political movement, Zionists themselves are not excluded from the customary moral and religious considerations.
"My New Year's greetings to all who have the movement earnestly at heart.
Israel Zangwill.
Attention!
The Misrachi is organising itself. The Misrachi is the clerical tendency in our movement. It is quite unobjectionable, however strongly the clericals may be represented among us. It is a fundamental principle of Zionism that every Jew, to whatever shade of party he may belong, can take an active part in it. But it is not a matter of indifference when clericalism as such spreads itself in our movement.
For since the existence of our movement a second fundamental principle has been observed, by which alone the maintenance of the first principle and the preservation of unity in the movement were made possible, namely: within the movement its adherents pursue only that which is common to all, and avoid everything that can bring about disunion. Outside the movement every Zionist is free to be active in any political, religious or social tendency as well.
Thus, whoever professes Zionism has, in common with the others, to foster the Jewish national idea, to combat assimilation, and to strive for the establishment of a publicly and legally secured home in Palestine.
Religious, political and social controversies he may not carry into the movement. The movement cannot and must not concern itself with such controversies. The movement has one goal, towards which its adherents must strive with the exertion of all their strength, and it must not be held back by wretched party wrangling.
Only by keeping to these two principles was it possible to make the movement great, and only by further observance of them can it be maintained at its height.
Only under such a policy was it possible for the strictly believing orthodox rabbi beside the freethinker, the conservative beside the progressive, the radical socialist beside the capitalist, to sit at one council-table and work together for the restoration of their people.
Only because the Zionists, within the movement, set aside everything that divides them and brought forward only what unites them, could fruitful work be done.
The Misrachi appears to wish to break with this principle. The Misrachi appears to wish to carry on clerical propaganda within the movement. Indeed, it appears that orthodoxy lies far nearer its heart than Zionism. According to the reports before us, the Misrachi "Congress" in Pressburg occupied itself chiefly with orthodoxy and only incidentally with Zionism. Its programme lays stress in the first place on orthodoxy and only in the second on the home, and reserves to itself the safeguarding of orthodox ideas in the general organisation of the Zionists. Over against this general organisation is set a Misrachi organisation extending over the whole world, with an Actions Committee at its head. An organisation within the organisation, then.
What if the freethinkers, the capitalists, the socialists now resolve to safeguard their ideas in the general organisation? Is work then possible? What if these likewise create special world organisations for themselves, because they cannot agree within the general organisation with the others who bring their party standpoint to the fore? We may then live to see four and more congresses, each of which claims to be the Zionist Congress. Then we shall indeed have the Tower of Babel, and then farewell, Zion. The creation of such a world organisation beside or within the general organisation is, moreover, contrary to the resolutions of the Congress. The organisation statute of the Congress knows only territorial federations, which have no relations with one another but are all subordinate to the Actions Committee. In order to meet the organising endeavours of the Misrachi without disturbing the character of the general organisation, a compromise was concluded, in which it was conceded that 50 societies having 5000 shekel-payers in one country may form a special federation directly subordinate to the Actions Committee. But a union of societies or federations of different countries, bypassing the Actions Committee, was not granted.
To prevent misunderstandings: these lines are in no way directed against orthodoxy, still less against the orthodox. They would have been written just the same had another shade of party threatened to endanger the general organisation. On the contrary, it is acknowledged that orthodoxy has hitherto preserved Judaism, and nothing is more ardently desired than that all the orthodox should join Zionism — as Zionists. In life outside the framework of the movement they may practise orthodoxy as much as they will, but within the