No. 23. — "Die Welt" — Page 7.
(continued from page 6)
…whether some bits of ghetto egg-shell are not still sticking to him, — whether some Golus contraband does not still lie hidden in some hiding-place. It must be admitted that this conception of the shekel, which is widespread, even if perhaps not expressed quite so drastically, — that this conception does not lack idealism. The shekel-payers would then form a kind of élite of Jewry, and it would be a delight to sit together with such ideal figures, to exchange wise discourse, and to wait until by a miracle the Zionist ideal fulfils itself. For any practical work will of course no longer be possible, — rather we shall possess only theorists, who will find it far beneath their dignity to devote themselves to real things.
The task is to find the middle way between these extremes. We will not accept the shekel from everyone who pleases, since we do not believe that anyone who is able to pay a mark has thereby already furnished proof of his fitness to help determine the destiny of our people. But neither will we make admission artificially difficult, nor set ourselves to repel well-disposed Jews by every possible means.
The touchstone is our programme. — But little is said when we lay this programme before a man in its wording. Certainly, whoever does not profess this programme is excluded by us without more ado. — We must lay this programme before everyone who comes to us word for word, — word for word, not paraphrased, — and we may assume of a normal person that he knows what he is doing when, by giving the shekel, he acknowledges this programme. — But we must be cautious in the interpretation of this programme.
One thing I must state at the outset. Our programme runs: Zionism strives for the Jewish people (not "for the Jews" who cannot or will not assimilate) — for the Jewish people the creation of a publicly and legally secured home in Palestine. That is the programme — nothing more. This leading principle alone is contained in § 1 of our statute as laid down by the Congress. — The ways and means, on the other hand, by which we intend to reach the goal are not essential parts of our programme.
What requirements, then, are to be made of every shekel-payer according to our programme?
There we have first the question of the land. Zionism would solve the Jewish question in Palestine. — I do not know whether the newest sea-serpent in our Zionist sea of newspapers — Territorialism — denotes anything real. If so, it must be said that Territorialists such as are depicted to us in the fable-books of some of our friends may not be admitted by us. Of course I know that there are people who say that the Jewish question can also be solved by founding a home outside Palestine, — only I deny, until further notice, that this view is represented within our movement by any quarter that comes into consideration at all. — As a matter of course, however, our minimum requirement in this regard refers only to our final goal. — It may be a matter of complete indifference to us, at admission, what attitude the person concerned otherwise takes towards colonisation in other lands, whether, for instance, he is for or against a provisional colonisation, even one to be undertaken by ourselves; we demand only that the final solution be acknowledged as possible only in Palestine.
Then comes the point of the publicly and legally secured home. — It appears as though even in circles that form the stronghold of our idea this demand is not fully grasped in its significance. — And yet precisely this point of the programme is for us almost more significant than the point just treated, from which we derive our name of "Zionists." — We are not the first to name Palestine as the terminus of our people's way of sorrows. But we are the first to break with the system of charitable colonisation, with the policy of alms, with small colonisation as an end in itself. From every shekel-payer must unconditionally be demanded, secondly, the recognition that a solution of the Jewish question, as it can be created only in Palestine, so can it be created only on a basis of public law. Whoever believes that he can dispense with this does not belong to us. — Here again it must be observed that all our requirements relate only to the goal. Whoever, therefore, is of the opinion that our final goal may be reached precisely through small colonisation, — that such colonisation is capable of bringing public-legal security in its train, thereby expresses no deviation from the programme and will be entitled to represent his opinion in our council.
But now come the two points whose treatment in agitation offers particularly many rocks. There is, first, the question: "For whom does Zionism work?" and further, the question of Jewish nationality. Both must be discussed in interpreting the words "for the Jewish people."
For whom do we work? — This question should certainly not be in dispute, and yet we often hear quite astonishing answers from our German Zionists. As a matter of course we do not work for the poor Jews of Russia or Roumania, — not for the poor Jews at all, — not for any category of Jews whatever; but we work, as the programme unequivocally declares, for the whole body of the Jews, for the Jewish people. Whoever interprets otherwise already sins against the spirit of Zionism. But just as much a matter of course, and declared often enough from the most authoritative quarter amid the unanimous assent of the whole Congress, is it that we wish to compel no one — how absurd, too, is the thought — to make use of the possibility afforded to everyone. We wish to create a home that stands open to every Jew. Whether he will seek it lies in the hand of each individual. In practice it will presumably be shown that from those lands in which the Jew feels least at ease the influx will be proportionately the strongest. That will be shown one day, and it is really not worth while to make conjectures about it or to quarrel over it. We must set forth this view of ours to those who ask for enlightenment, but it may be a matter of indifference to us what the man paying the shekel thinks about it. Certainly I shall never be permitted to say in a propaganda speech: "We work only for the Jew of the East," — but if a gentleman from the audience now comes forward and says to us: "I agree in everything and will pay my shekel in full acknowledgment of the programme, but I think and wish that only Eastern Jews will seek that home," — then I shall take the shekel with heartfelt pleasure and say: "That is not our affair! Let us hope we shall soon have occasion to establish it!" To be sure, I shall soon be told that I am breeding Rachmones-Zionists. — Well, I believe that of all possible catchwords, senselessly coined and senselessly applied, this is the most senseless. — The word is apt only when it means those persons whom I characterised earlier in this speech, who without any reflection, out of pure momentary pity, pay their mark; but surely we will not let it come to this, that, as the "Schlemiel" very nicely parodied lately, Rachmones is regarded as the worst thing that can be said of a Zionist. After all, we are all Rachmones-Zionists. We have pity for the poor Jewish people, — pity for the poor, prostrate people of our fathers. — Only we mean to exercise this pity of ours more reasonably and more thoroughly than others have done: — we disdain begging and alms-giving; in their place we set labour and the demanding of our right. In place of private charity above all we let charity step forth in the form worthy of a people, — and so we enter the field of politics. —
And now the national question! — Our programme speaks of the Jewish people. — Our programme does not create the people, nor does it declare the existence of the people, — but it presupposes the existence of the people as self-evident. That shows us how this point is to be treated. The existence or non-existence of the Jewish people is a fact which no majority resolutions can alter. Were there no Jewish people, not even Dr. Faust's learned famulus could construct one; but since there is a Jewish people, the resolutions of all corporations and associations, however mighty, cannot abolish its existence from the world. Our Zionism is nothing arbitrary, nothing hatched at the green table. — It is a product of historical development, represents a phase of our national life-process. A Zionism without Jewish nationality is just such an idiocy as the idea of a Jewish religion without a Jewish people. That we all know, — that is something self-evident! — But one does not talk about self-evident things, except at the general meeting of certain charitable societies. Whoever has the task of setting forth the nature of Zionism cannot do otherwise than sketch its historical development; he must touch upon the national foundation, must profess our nationality in the most unequivocal manner. But it is really a superfluity and a concession to prove first of all that there is a Jewish nation. True — if anyone should wish to deny its existence, one must reduce him ad absurdum; but one must not forget that it is a matter of an ab-
