Page 4 — "Die Welt" — No. 22
(continued from page 3)
…opened schools and courses and promoted training in the crafts with good success. In order to come to the aid of Jewish distress in North Africa, the Alliance had sought to spread agriculture among them. The agronomic school at Djedeïda had had good results, but the pupils, who then seek work with the landowners, had in many cases been exposed to the competition of the Christian labourers, mostly Italians and Spaniards of strongly anti-Semitic sentiment, who persecuted them severely. This went so far that the Alliance has purchased an estate near Algiers of 1600 hectares in extent, and there it will provide the young people with work and land. This, he said, was a beginning of greater activity.
The Society, he went on, had not means enough for the education of all the children in the East, so that in the great cities alone over 30.000 Jewish children remain without education. Yet it had been able to provide in some measure for Palestine: it had supported the Talmud Torah school and was gradually introducing hygienic and cultural reforms into it. It was said that the Alliance was perhaps creating too many enlightened young people in the East, who in the prevailing economic misery would in many cases be declassed. Were that so, why then would the communities and parents contribute almost half the expenditure towards the maintenance of the schools?
As regards the treasurer's report, it runs for 1903: receipts 1,440.474 Frcs. (among them 600.000 Frcs. as contributions from the communities and parents, and 263.700 Frcs. from the Ica), expenditure 1,525.003, deficit therefore 84.529 Frcs.
Herr Simon welcomes the activity of the Alliance, which, as he says, gladly and benevolently accepts objective criticism and advice, and thanks the President and the Committee.
The President, Herr Leven, asks the meeting whether anyone wishes to speak, and, as all present remained silent, he further announces the opening of the library which the Alliance has built for the public in the garden of the teachers' seminary, and which is perhaps the largest *) in the world. He says that Zion would never perish; Zion was wherever Jewish hearts were conscious of their great mission (?!) for civilisation and progress. With that the meeting closed. N. B. D.
Berlin Letter.
Berlin, 16 May 1904.
It is not so very long since a violent struggle over religion raged within Jewry. We look back scarcely into the third generation of men when we look back upon the endeavours after intellectual emancipation from former rigidity, so intimately bound up with the movement for civil emancipation in Germany, upon the ideas of reform then proclaimed and the counter-struggles they called forth. The epoch of Friedländer, Zunz, Geiger, Holdheim lies not at all far behind us; in the historical development of Judaism (in Germany especially) it is the one nearest to our own, immediately preceding it — and yet, like its representatives, it has sunk into almost complete oblivion. Want of any consciousness of historical tradition marks, indeed, our present generation altogether; but perhaps the rift between our to-day and the days gone by runs most sharply through this yesterday.
In religious matters the utmost fragmentation reigns in Judaism to-day. From the American and German Reform Jews to the various shades of Russian and Polish Orthodox Jews there are manifold gradations, and, next to these, the vast mass of the indifferent; and the groups, so far removed from one another, could in fact hardly be united by a bond of common religious conviction.
Could one, amid this dismemberment, speak of a development of Judaism in religious respects? Where are the works of our reformers?
Let us enter the temple of the Jewish Reform Congregation in Berlin. It is one of the oldest Jewish Reform-
*) Presumably Jewish is meant. It stands adjoining the teachers' seminary of the Alliance at Auteuil and comprises 40.000 works.
congregations. Next year it will celebrate its sixtieth anniversary.
On Sundays, punctually at 10 o'clock, the service begins; punctually at 11 o'clock it is over. A few dozen (so as not to use the strictly banished Hebrew word "Minian") men on the right and ladies on the left are assembled for prayer. The men are bareheaded, the ladies, on the other hand, in hats. A solemn stillness reigns, a chilling, shivering coolness. Pretty choral singing and organ music. The reader, with theatrical gestures and in a tearful or affectedly solemn voice, reads prayers in the German language to the pious, devout congregation. A few single sentences are still quoted in the Hebrew text. A prayer for the Imperial House follows, and prayers for newborn, newly married and deceased Reform Jews. The Torah is brought out, and the Torah reading is "indicated" by a few lines read in the original and in translation. Then follows the sermon, a few more quite short prayers — the hour is up, and the God-filled, strengthened and edified congregation goes home again, sated for a week.
We look at the elegantly dressed gentlemen and ladies, all worthy, respectable citizens, and marvel that we must see in them the direct disciples of Geiger and Holdheim, the legitimate bearers of the Jewish mission. Since they are our brethren, we are glad that at least the burden of the mission does not weigh too heavily upon them, which agrees well with the growth and prosperity of their bodily periphery. Evidently they also bear with equanimity the fact that the number of the priestly guard is always a very small one. The Reform Congregation here numbers barely 600 members — which, set against the total number of Berlin Jews, is very inconsiderable.
Yes, it is remarkable how the champions of Reform, who constantly stressed the capacity of Judaism for development and wished to carry it forward only in the sense of its previous historical development, could in fact be so unhistorical. Their combating of the entire ceremonial law, their wish to return to a purified Biblical Judaism, was a ruthless break with all historical development, and, carried to its logical conclusion, would have led to the rejection of all forms and to the abolition of religious community altogether. They, however, replaced the former forms by others, rigid and alien; they rejected the historically justified content and left standing only an intangible "ideal kernel." They did it out of a sincere and great love for Judaism. Only they were blinded. They thought they must sacrifice so much of Judaism in themselves as thanks for their admission among the foreign peoples — and there they knew no bounds.
What, then, nevertheless moves the members of the Reform Congregation to maintain it? Is it religious feeling? Purely religious feeling would find as much satisfaction, or perhaps more, in quiet devotion at home; or, if one feels nearer to God in the company of other men, then in any community whatever that prays to God. Principles of the Jewish religion, then? Of these, however, nothing is to be perceived here, and of what the first teachers wished to lay down as the foundation of their reforms the members of the Reform Congregation have not the least notion. Yet to the question of what has brought them here they would surely answer decidedly: The religion of our fathers! Is there not unconsciously expressed in this the feeling of an unacknowledged tribal kinship? Can we still count even upon those so strongly assimilated?
Does it prove anything that their preacher, in his sermon, calls upon those assembled with warm words to support Jewish learning?
Perhaps! Little more is likely to blossom for Judaism out of these circles. j.
