No. 22 — "Die Welt" — Page 3
(continued from page 2)
…that we have already fallen sick; nor have I ever asserted it. My view is that, if England is to remain the home of freedom for the poor refugees whose only crime is poverty, the clause against them in the Bill must be struck out. And with that our objection to the Bill would be removed altogether..."
And with this view of Zangwill's almost all classes and strata of Jewish society unanimously concur. With the exception of the few Jewish Members of Parliament who voted for the Bill; with the exception, say, of B. L. Cohen, the true type of the assimilationist, who would like to suppress everything Jewish because it is Jewish, and who could easily be won for any anti-Jewish measure if only he could thereby ingratiate himself with John Bull — with the exception, then, of these few, whose mere names do not exactly awaken agreeable feelings among the better-minded English Jews, all Jews take the same attitude in this matter as Zangwill.
Indeed, they are beginning to see that the Bill will acquire a far-reaching significance. How easy it is, for instance, for the Italians, who after all also flock to London in crowds, to let this measure pass over them. Behind them stand their Government and their country, which will always lend an ear to their cries for help. There the Bill will really acquire no great "fundamental" significance. It is otherwise with the Jews. And the Jews count as the aliens par excellence; agitation is stirred up against them both by fanatical Catholic Ireland and by the Anglican British Brothers. The foreign problem has swiftly turned into an internal one, as the "Jewish Chronicle" remarks in its leading article. In England the Jewish question is coming into being. And however official England may resist this imputation, as is evident from the Prime Minister's letter, it remains a fact none the less. The Jewish question has, after all, this peculiarity, that it needs but a small spark to blaze up into a flame. At a meeting held last week in Limehouse Town Hall, the Member of Parliament Sir Harry S. Samuel gave expression to these apprehensions, and his remarks on the subject are in some points very interesting. Although the Jews are now being made to feel their Jewishness, although they are being rather curtly reminded that they are, after all, no Englishmen, one should not and must not cower, hide oneself and hold one's tongue, as the dyed-in-the-wool assimilationists preach, whenever they venture to have a say in Jewish affairs at all.
He held, on the contrary, that the Jews will be respected by the population only if they do not deny their race and religion, but hold fast to them and esteem them highly. A further step on the road of self-knowledge will perhaps lead the honourable Member to the more radical, more thoroughgoing solution of the Jewish question — the national one. It is interesting that Leroy-Beaulieu, the celebrated French political economist and friend of the Jews, who is at present staying in America, has expressed himself in an almost analogous manner on the future of the Jewish people. In a conversation with a contributor to the "Jewish Comment" of Baltimore, who had put to him, a little anxiously, the crucial question of what was to become of Judaism, Leroy-Beaulieu answered that he believed in the future of Judaism, although not in the form in which Zionism presents it. He raised very weak objections to Zionism, and in the end said that Judaism needed a reform, but an inner rather than an outer one. In the inner life of Judaism, he said, lay its strength; in its own bosom its destiny was secured. That thinking and true-hearted Jews, such as Sir Samuel for example, will yet go beyond this standpoint — which has, after all, a great deal to be said for it — and arrive at an active programme of national self-help, is what the signs of the times indicate, unless all deceives... And that the Aliens Bill has become an internal Jewish question in England is proved also by the fact that a Jewish deputation was sent to the Prime Minister to confer about the Bill. At the head of the deputation stood Lord Rotschild. What the deputation has obtained we do not yet know, but in itself it is already a significant phenomenon. — And in the "sphere of British influence," too, things are beginning to stir. From the Thames to the veld of the Transvaal, from Yorkshire to Benares. So, for example, in India, where according to the last census (1901) there are 18.228 Jews. The Jews are found chiefly in Bengal, Bombay and Burma. As is well known, a new Jewish newspaper has been founded in India, "The Voice of Sinai." The Voice of Sinai, in Calcutta! And as everywhere, the Indian Jews too show the capacity to adapt themselves in a high degree to the culture of other peoples. And the Jews, who are immigrants yesterday and to-morrow bearers of the culture of their adopted country, remain none the less, in the opinion of Mr. Arnold White's associates, "undesirable aliens"... And one more comical incident before I close my letter: Mr. Dowie is "tired of Christians." He now wants to convert Jews to his faith, the only one that brings salvation. He suffered a fiasco in New York, and now he wants to win laurels in the East End. He issues Jargon leaflets, and conversion lectures are being held in the East End. Mr. Dowie is said to be a shrewd man of business, but here he has been taken in.
Spectator.
Paris Letters.
VII.
Paris, May 1904.
The Alliance Israélite Universelle held its annual meeting on the 15th inst. Some 100 members had come. Among them only one from abroad, Herr Simon of Berlin.
The Secretary, Herr Bigart, read the report on the activity of the Alliance for the year 1903, comprising the relief action for the unfortunates of Kischenew, and the support of the emigrants, of education and of the school-children in Roumania. Further, the Alliance had alleviated much suffering and misfortune in Morocco. In Persia, where some 50.000 of the most unfortunate Jews are to be found, it had prepared a better future for our brethren through the personal influence of its officials with the Government, through the founding of new schools, which together number over 2000 pupils, and through the introduction of handicrafts. In Constantinople it had taken the promising rabbinical seminary under its financial care. It had also in many cases supported, out of special funds, writers and scholars devoting themselves to Jewish learning or to apologetic literature.
Most important of all, however, was the educational activity of the Alliance. It maintained or subsidised 120 elementary schools in the East, of these 76 boys' and 44 girls' schools, together numbering 33.000 pupils. In addition it maintained a teachers' seminary in Paris, where 75 pupils were preparing themselves especially for the teaching profession in the East, besides the 44 young ladies receiving their training in Paris as teachers and instructresses in handicrafts. To these were to be added two agricultural schools, at Jaffa and at Djed Ida (Tunisia), and the trade school in Jerusalem, which numbers on the average 100 pupils. The Alliance had directed particular attention to the spread of handicrafts in the East, had created several industries for boys and girls in Turkey, Tunis, Persia, Bulgaria, etc., and had combated the contempt for manual labour among the Jews. In Algiers, where religious and moral education had in many cases been so neglected that this appears to be one of the causes of anti-Semitism, the Society has
