Page 2 — "Die Welt" — No. 19
(continued from page 1)
…be emphasised here. Attention is to be drawn to the process of transformation which is taking place at this very moment and which surely deserves the closest attention of Zionist circles.
Certainly! There are still vast differences between our programme and that of the Union. When "care for the co-religionists of the East" is excluded on principle from the working programme of this association, that is already a far-reaching difference, quite apart from the fact that our final aim, the creation of a publicly and legally secured home in Palestine, lies wholly outside the scope of the Union's activity. But the intention to negotiate with governments and representatives of the people, to abandon the part of silence, of muted protest, of creeping away behind other factors; the emphasis upon the unity of Jewry; the refusal to meddle in religious disputes; and above all the founding of a Jewish representation common to all German Jews — all this we Zionists can and will greet with joy and support to the best of our powers. The publicity of the Union's proceedings, the composition of its leadership, the demand that the election of delegates be conducted, if possible, on as broad and popular a basis as is the case with the Zionist Congresses, the prevention of the intrusion of a clique, of whatever kind, into the governing body — these will be the chief points to which our German fellow Zionists, like all others who wish the Union well, must devote their care.
But the Jewish efforts towards organisation, which are showing themselves not in Germany alone, should at the same time serve us as a signpost for the work immediately before us. Here again is a field upon which we can work together with the non-Zionists for the welfare of Judaism. If we do not neglect this work, if, without dispersing our forces, we can send suitable men to take part in such collaboration, then these organisations will become strong pillars of the Jewish national idea; then in time that part of our programme too which is not yet recognised by all others will be accepted by every conscious Jew. Then we shall attain what we regard as the precondition for the success of our work: the gathering together of all those forces which are not yet lost to Judaism.
W.
The Union of German Jews.
Some 130 representatives had appeared from the most diverse districts of Germany; only the Jews of Bavaria and Würtemberg declined on principle to take part, because entry into the Union could not be reconciled with certain peculiar laws of their states. The delegates were drawn from deputations of the communities, the district and provincial unions, the Rabbinical Union, the Teachers' Union, the Central Association of German Citizens of the Jewish Faith, the German-Israelite Communal Federation, the synagogue unions, the three rabbinical seminaries, and numerous private individuals.
Since the Union wishes to be regarded as a body representing solely the interests of the German Jews, all associations and institutions whose activity extends beyond the borders of the homeland were excluded from participation. Hence neither the Hilfsverein der deutschen Juden nor the Zionist Federation for Germany was officially represented. We shall therefore be sincerely grateful to the conveners of the "Jewish Congress", and gladly acknowledge their loyalty, in that they nevertheless did not forgo the collaboration of the once so troublesome Zionists, but sent personal invitations to take part to the German members of the Actions Committee. Whoever knows the names of all those Justizräte, professors, rabbis and Liberal deputies of whom the Union of German Jews is composed will know how to value duly the inclusion of the Zionist representatives. It implies, first of all, the admission that even in the leading circles of German Jewry our movement can no longer be passed over if one wishes to display an imposing Jewish activity. But I believe, too, that the non-Zionists have come to know our tried capacity for work and our readiness for sacrifice well enough not merely to be unable to do without our co-operation, but to desire it.
The chief purpose of the Jewish Congress, as appears from the statements of the reporter and of the speakers in the discussion, consists in watching over the legally guaranteed rights of the German Jews. For what reasons the "Union of German Jews" describes its future work as positive, in contrast to the allegedly negative work of the "Central Association of German Citizens", is not clear to me. At bottom both strive for the same thing, even if it will be admitted that the Central Association lacked the "necessary authority" to carry its wishes with the decisive quarters. Whether the new Union will be able to count as an authority within Jewry and in its bearing towards the outside world, the future will show.
That the Union represents an advance upon other associations founded earlier shall be acknowledged. That it was once again thought necessary to place the community of religious interests in the foreground — by way of justification, as it were — does not, however, make one's hopes of a new course among the German Jews overly lively.
How little, moreover, people were convinced of the community of religious interests is evident from the very fact that the Union excludes all discussion of questions of religion and worship from its proceedings. That is not done because people know themselves to be united in these matters of conscience, but because they know themselves to be very much disunited.
The Union ought to have had the courage to break with the old, inwardly untruthful tradition of earlier associations, and to seek the common bond where it really lies, namely in descent. The Union ought to have styled itself a representation of German citizens of the Jewish nation; then it might have inscribed truthfulness upon its flag in addition to its good intentions, without its aims and hopes being altered by a single atom. Then that would hold true which the Zionist delegates, Dr. Bodenheimer and Dr. Klee, emphasised with particular force in the assembly: that the Union might contribute first and foremost to awakening and strengthening self-respect and the feeling of solidarity among the German Jews. But whether the somewhat unclear tendency of the Union will win great sympathy among the German Jews appears doubtful. It is to be presumed that the Union will be met with the same benevolent indifference as the Central Association of German Citizens of the Jewish Faith. To make an impression upon the people, and to win over a community standing so high intellectually as the Jews, one must be able to show a firm and pithy programme.
Perhaps the gentlemen at its head will likewise struggle through to this conviction. Then the Union may achieve something profitable. We will wait and wish it the best.
Dr. Jungmann.
